Ohio State Recruiting Forum

Ohio State Recruiting Forum

OSU football and basketball recruiting fan talk.

Know Thy Enemy: Comparing Oklahoma's and Ohio State's Defensive Recruits

Matt Gutridge's picture
September 8, 2017 at 4:07pm
17 Comments
Stuffed

Wins on Saturdays are often determined by signed letters of intent over Februaries past. This piece is an in-depth look at the composite ratings of the defensive players that signed on the dotted line for Oklahoma and Ohio State.

 

DEFENSIVE STARTER RECRUITING RANKINGS
       
o
 
     
OHIO STATE                     
POSITION PLAYER COMP. RATING POSITION PLAYER COMP. RATING
DE GREG WARD .941 DE TYQUAN LEWIS .898
DT NEVILLE GALLIMORE .962 DT TRACY SPRINKLE .859
NG MATTHEW ROMAR .858 DT DRE'MONT JONES .938
JACK OGBONNIA OKORONKWO .866 DE SAM HUBBARD .923
SLB CALEB KELLY .984 LB DANTE BOOKER .972
MLB KENNETH MURRAY .877 MLB CHRIS WORLEY .868
WLB EMMANUEL BEAL .808 LB JEROME BAKER .969
CB PARNELL MOTLEY .945 CB DENZEL WARD .903
FS WILLIAM JOHNSON .869 S DAMON WEBBB .982
SS STEVEN PARKER .947 S JORDAN FULLER .938
CB JORDAN THOMAS .871 CB DAMON ARNETTE .860
           
  AVERAGE .902 AVERAGE   .919

Ohio State's comp. average jumps to .935 if Nick Bosa (.997) is substituted for Tyquan Lewis and Kendall Sheffield (.931) is substituted for Damon Arnette. The players above are listed as or on this week's depth chart.

DEFENSIVE RECRUITING NOTES 2013-2017
  • Oklahoma's highest rated defensive starter is strong-side linebacker Caleb Kelly (.984)
  • The largest gap among the defensive starters is the 161 point difference between Ohio State's LB Jerome Baker and Oklahoma's WLB Emmanuel Beal (.808).
  • The average of Ohio State's defensive starters is 17 points better than Oklahoma's defensive starters.

 

DEFENSIVE RECRUITING COMPARISON 2013-2017

 

2013-2017 COMPARING OKLAHOMA'S ILB COMMITS TO OHIO STATE'S
o
       
O
     
PLAYER (YEAR) HGHT WT COMP. RATING   PLAYER (YEAR) HGHT WT COMP. RATING
RICKY DeBERRY (2015) 6–2 240 .958   RAEKWON McMILLAN (2014) 6–2 242 .989
LEVI DRAPER (2017) 6–3 222 .945   TREY JOHNSON (2013) 6–2 218 .949
          NICK CONNER (2015) 6–3 225 .912
                 
AVERAGE 6–2 231 .952   AVERAGE 6–2 228 .950


Both Oklahoma and Ohio State have been stingy with their scholarships to inside linebacker prospects. Both schools are picking up high quality players, but have signed a combined five ILBs since 2013. Neither team will have a signed inside linebacker starting on Saturday. 

 

2013-2017 COMPARING OKLAHOMA'S OLB COMMITS TO OHIO STATE'S
o
       
O
     
PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING   PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING
CALEB KELLY (2016) 6–3 215 .984   BARON BROWNING (2017) 6–2 229 .993
BRYCE YOUNGQUIST (2016) 6–1 215 .914   JUSTIN HILLIARD (2015) 6–0 225 .985
KENNETH MURRAY (2017) 6–3 225 .877   MIKE MITCHELL (2013) 6–4 222 .973
ARTHUR McGINNIS (2015) 6–2 226 .869   DANTE BOOKER (2014) 6–3 212 .972
CURTIS BOLTON (2014) 6–2 215 .865   KEANDRE JONES (2016) 6–3 210 .954
K'JAKYRE DALEY (2017) 6–3 220 .852   KYLE BERGER (2014) 6–3 215 .929
TAY EVANS (2014) 6–3 200 .850   PETE WERNER (2017) 6–3 220 .897
KAPRI DOUCET (2016) 6–3 225 .847   TUF BORLAND (2016) 6–2 225 .893
JORDAN EVANS (2013) 6–3 205 .845          
DEVANTE BOND (2014) 6–3 230 .840          
EMMANUEL BEAL (2016) 6–2 215 .808          
                 
AVERAGE 6–2 217 .868   AVERAGE 6–2 220 .950


Where inside linebacker was lacking, outside linebacker is where these programs are loading up. The schemes of today's offenses is putting an emphasis on the linebacker who can cover space.  

 

2013-2017 COMPARING OKLAHOMA'S CB COMMITS TO OHIO STATE'S
o
       
O
     
PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING   PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING
JUSTIN BROILES (2017) 6–0 175 .961   JEFFREY OKUDAH (2017) 6–1 190 .994
PJ MBANASOR (2015) 6–0 176 .939   SHAUN WADE (2017) 6–1 177 .988
TRE BROWN (2017) 5–11 178 .937   DAMON WEBB (2014) 5–11 180 .982
JORDAN PARKER (2016) 5–11 180 .928   ELI APPLE (2013) 6–1 185 .975
LJ MOORE (2013) 6–2 185 .903   MARSHON LATTIMORE 6–0 175 .973
PARRISH COBB (2016) 5–11 178 .902   CAM BURROWS 6–0 195 .972
WILL JOHNSON (2015) 6–0 185 .869   ERIC GLOVER-WILLIAMS (2015) 5–11 165 .952
ANTOINE STEPHENS (2015) 6–1 187 .865   AMIR RIEP (2017) 5–11 185 .940
MARCUS GREEN (2014) 6–0 178 .858   MARCUS WILLIAMSON (2017) 5–9 180 .935
TITO WINDHAM (2014) 5–10 175 .857   GAREON CONLEY (2013) 6–1 172 .932
TRE NORWOOD (2017) 5–11 168 .852   KENDALL SHEFFIELD (2017) 6–0 185 .931
DAKOTA AUSTIN 5–11 160 .832   DENZEL WARD (2015) 5–11 165 .903
          WAYNE DAVIS (2016) 5–11 190 .891
          JAMEL DEAN (2015) 6–2 195 .891
          JOSHUA NORWOOD (2015) 5–10 175 .870
          DAMON ARNETTE (2015) 6–2 185 .860
          RODJAY BURNS (2016) 6–2 6–2 .853
          KAREEM FELDER (2016) 5–11 170 .851
                 
AVERAGE 6–0 177 .892   AVERAGE 6–0 180 .927

Bob Stoops put a priority on picking up wide receivers, Urban Meyer's position of choice is corner back. Over the past five signing days, Meyer added 18 corner backs to Ohio State's roster. Not only has he brought in a shit-ton of CBs, but he has recruited some of the best in the country. 

Consider this, Oklahoma's top-rated corner back since 2013 is Justin Broiles (.961). The Buckeyes have signed six players with higher ranking in that time span. Ohio State's average of .927 is higher than seven of the 12 signed Sooners.

Nick Bosa
Nick Bosa (.997) is the highest rated player on either team, yet he is not a "starter" for the Buckeyes.

 

 
2013-2017 COMPARING OKLAHOMA'S SAFETY COMMITS TO OHIO STATE'S
O
       
O
     
PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING   PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING
ROBERT BARNES (2017) 6–3 194 .957   VONN BELL (2013) 5–11 193 .987
STEVEN PARKER (2014) 6–2 188 .947   ISAIAH PRYOR (2017) 6–1 195 .973
WILL SUNDERLAND (2015) 6–3 195 .929   ERICK SMITH (2014) 6–1 185 .967
HATRARI BYRD (2013) 6–1 195 .928   JAYME THOMPSON (2013) 6–2 190 .912
CAHLIL HAUGHTON (2015) 6–2 175 .897          
CHANSE SYLVIE (2016) 5–11 226 .851          
PRENTICE McKINNEY (2015) 6–2 180 .875          
JORDAN THOMAS (2014) 6–1 175 .871          
AHMAD THOMAS 6–1 205 .867          
VONTRE McQUINNIE 6–2 190 .855          
                 
AVERAGE 6–2 188 .901   AVERAGE 6–1 191 .960

Stoops put an emphasis on the sizeable safety. 60 percent of his safeties are at least 6'2" tall. Meyer took a quality of quantity approach and signed four highly rated safeties.

 

2013-2017 COMPARING OKLAHOMA'S DT COMMITS TO OHIO STATE'S
o
       
O
     
PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING   PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING
NEVILLE GALLIMORE (2015) 6–2 330 .962   HASKELL GARRETT (2017) 6–2 288 .968
MARQUISE OVERTON (2015) 6–1 301 .917   MICHAEL HILL (2013) 6–2 315 .924
KERRICK HUGGINS (2013) 6–4 282 .904   BILLY PRICE (2013)  6–4 300 .916
DILLON FAAMATAU (2017) 6–4 290 .878   JERRON CAGE (2017) 6–1 275 .909
QUINCY RUSSELL (2013) 6–3 305 .873   MALIK BARROW (2016) 6–3 270 .899
CHARLES WALKER (2013) 6–3 280 .866   DONOVAN MUNGER (2013) 6–4 285 .898
MATT ROMAR (2013) 6–3 276 .858   ROBERT LANDERS (2015) 6–2 295 .872
ZACCHAEUS McKINNEY (2017) 6–4 300 .857   DAVON HAMILTON (2015) 6–3 285 .829
COURTNEY GARNETT (2014) 6–2 280 .851          
TYREECE LOTT (2017) 6–3 270 .837          
                 
AVERAGE 6–3 291 .880   AVERAGE 6–3 289 .902

Both programs understand the importance of winning the line of scrimmage and recruited the defensive line accordingly. OU signed 24 D-lineman and Ohio State 22.

The Sooners believe in a strong middle and added 10 defensive tackles. Of those players, 6'2", 330 pound Neville Gallimore stands out.  

 

2013-2017 COMPARING OKLAHOMA'S SDE COMMITS TO OHIO STATE'S
o
       
O
     
PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING   PLAYER HGHT WT COMP. RATING
DJ WARD (2013) 6–4 242 .941   NICK BOSA (2016) 6–4 265 .997
AMANDI BLEDSOE (2016) 6–5 263 .929   JOEY BOSA (2013) 6–5 270 .981
MATT DIMON (2013) 6–4 255 .898   JASHON CORNELL (2015) 6–4 260 .956
GABRIEL CAMPBELL (2015) 6–6 250 .870   DRE'MONT JONES (2015) 6–3 266 .938
AUSTIN ROBERTS (2015 6–6 265 .868   DYLAN THOMPSON (2014) 6–5 270 .872
KENNETH MANN (2015) 6–4 240 .853   JOSHUA ALABI (2015) 6–5 295 .866
TROY JAMES (2017) 6–4 275 .845   TRACY SPRINKLE (2013) 6–4 250 .859
BRANDON GLENN (2014) 6–4 254 .840   DARIUS SLADE (2014) 6–5 240 .846
                 
AVERAGE 6–5 256 .881   AVERAGE 6-4 265 .914

The Buckeyes offensive line will need to account on DJ Ward and his counter part Ogbonnia Okoronkwo. Looking at the averages, Oklahoma goes after a slightly  taller and slimmer SDE than Ohio State. 

 

2013-2017 COMPARING OKLAHOMA'S WDE COMMITS TO OHIO STATE'S
o
       
O
     
PLAYER (YEAR) HGHT WT COMP. RATING   PLAYER (YEAR) HGHT WT COMP. RATING
ADDISON GUMBS (2017) 6–4 220 .941   CHASE YOUNG (2017) 6–5 251 .992
MARK JACKSON JR. (2016) 6–2 221 .919   JONAHTON COOPER (2016) 6–2 234 .980
ISAIAH THOMAS (2017) 6–5 230 .898   JALYN HOLMES (2014) 6–5 225 .962
OGBONNIA OKORONKWO (2013) 6–2 220 .866   TYQUAN LEWIS (2013) 6–4 227 .898
JON-MICHAEL TERRY (2016) 6–4 225 .864   RASHOD BERRY (2015) 6–5 240 .857
DWAYNE ORSO-BACCHUS 6–5 255 .809   RASHOD BERRY (2015) 6-5 240 .857
                 
AVERAGE 6–4 229 .882   AVERAGE 6-4 235 .938

 

Ohio State has three weak-side defensive ends ranked higher than Oklahoma's best. Freshman phenom, Chase Young will be the highest-rated of all the WDE's in Ohio Stadium Saturday night.

Oklahoma also has two talented young players in Addison Gumbs and Mark Jackson Jr., but they are playing behind a senior beast, Ogbonnia Okoronkwo. Not only does Okoronkwo have the best name on the Sooners, but he is also a stud player. 

NO. OF PLAYERS RECRUITED PER POSITION
o
   
Ohio State
POSITION NO. OF PLAYERS POSITION NO. OF PLAYERS
SDE 8 SDE 8
WDE 6 WDE 6
DT 10 DT 8
OLB 11 OLB 8
ILB 2 ILB 3
CB 12 CB 18
S 10 S 4
       
TOTAL 59 TOTAL 55

Like last year, the players will determine which coaching staff did a better job recruiting on the field. Hopefully Ohio State will finish the game with a similar result as last year.

ICYMI
The Rundown: No. 5 Oklahoma at No. 2 Ohio State
Know Thy Enemy: Comparing Oklahoma's and Ohio State's Offensive Recruits

This is a forum post from a site member. It does not represent the views of Eleven Warriors unless otherwise noted.

View 17 Comments