The Buckeyes lost at least 30 scholarship and walk-ons and gained 16 replacements so far. On balance how do people feel the Buckeyes did? Irrespective of graduates, completed eligibility, or guys that left early for the draft since those were happening regardless of the portal, did we lose more than we gained in talent and experience and production, or vice versa?  I have my own opinion (I think it's a net positive) but I'd like to hear what others think. I hope 11W goes into this in depth after the portal closes and gives us their portal +/- scorecard. I'd also like to hear opinions of how other teams did.