I'm a little biased. But I think if there are two four star Picktown Boys who just won a State Championship, we should, at least, offer:
 

I'm looking at Trenton Gillison 4 Star - grant it we have 5 TE's on roster, but he was picked up by MSU. Coach Wilson was recruiting him, but no offer. 

Xavier Henderson was being recruited as an athlete, is also four star. Luke Fickell was recruiting him at one time, but he received no Ohio State offer. MSU plucked him as well. 

I don't know. I guess I don't "get" the new recruiting style.