Ohio State Recruiting Forum

Ohio State Recruiting Forum

OSU football and basketball recruiting fan talk.

2019 Recruiting Class: How Do The New Players Compare To Ohio State's Highest-Rated Recruits?

Matt Gutridge's picture
December 20, 2018 at 3:58pm
35 Comments
Garrett Wilson

Christmas came six days early for Ohio State as 15 players signed their letter of intent yesterday. Let's take a look at how the newest Buckeyes' recruiting rankings stack up with the highest rated Ohio State players at their projected positions.*

*Recruiting rankings are a relatively new process and rankings prior to 2008 are not as thorough. Many talented players did not receive a ranking and are not eligible for this list.

Top 3 Ohio State WR Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 GARRETT WILSON 2019 ★★★★★ 992 TX
2 TREVON GRIMES 2017 ★★★★★ 986 FL
3 JALIN MARSHALL 2013 ★★★★ 983 OH
11 JAMESON WILLIAMS 2019 ★★★★ 940 MO

Garrett Wilson is now Ohio State's highest rated commitment at WR. The Ausitn native replaces Trevon Grimes at the top of the list. Grimes was a lauded ball catcher, but he only appeared in two games during his Buckeye "career". Near the end of the 2017 season, his freshman year, Grimes announced that he was transferring to Florida to be closer to home.

Remember, recruiting rankings are not an exact science. Angelo Chattams (.968) signed with Ohio State in 2001 and is ranked 4th at WR. Chattams played in 9 games and caught two passes for 26 yards during his only season with the Buckeyes.

On the other end of the spectrum, some guys named Michael Thomas (.848) and Santonio Holmes (.867) are the lowest rated receivers for Ohio State. Again, recruiting rankings are nice, but they don't always predict how a player's career will unfold.

Top 3 Ohio State SDE Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 ZACH HARRISON 2019 ★★★★★ 997 OH
1 NICK BOSA 2016 ★★★★★ 997 FL
3 ROBERT ROSE 2006 ★★★★ 983 OH
17 NOAH POTTER 2019 ★★★★ 896 OH

According to the experts, Zach Harrison is the marquee player in Ohio State's class of 2019. Hopefully the Olentangy Orange star will have a career similar to the Bosa brothers. Harrison is only the second player to enter the program as a 5★ prospect at SDE. 

Noah Potter comes to Ohio State with rankings similar to Nathan Williams, Tim Schafer, Darryl Baldwin and Dylan Thompson. Some players that out performed their low rankings were Jay Richardson (.800) and Tracy Sprinkle (.859)

Top 3 Ohio State OC Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 MICHAEL BREWSTER 2008 ★★★★★ 990 FL
2 HARRY MILLER 2019 ★★★★★ 985 GA
3 MATTHEW JONES 2018 ★★★★ 965 NY

Expectations are going to be very high for Harry Miller. The Georgia native comes in as the program's second highest rated center. Miller is only the second 5★ center in Ohio State history.

Top 3 Ohio State S Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 TYREKE JOHNSON 2018 ★★★★★ 988 FL
2 VONN BELL 2013 ★★★★★ 987 GA
3 EUGENE CLIFFORD 2007 ★★★★★ 984 OH
9 RONNIE HICKMAN 2019 ★★★★ 949 NJ
17 BRYSON SHAW 2019 ★★★ 876 MD

Vonn Bell had a very successful Ohio State career and is currently spending his Sunday's playing in the NFL. This season, Isaiah Pryor had significant playing time with mixed results, 2019 might be a big season for him. 

Here is a list of other Ohio State players recruited at safety between 2001-today that have been selected in the NFL Draft: Dustin Fox (.968), Nate Salley (.900), Donald Washington (NR), Jermale Hines (NR), Nate Ebner (NR).

For those wondering, Jordan Battle (.963) would have landed sixth on Ohio State's all-time safety recruiting rankings.

Top 3 Ohio State OLB Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 BARON BROWNING 2017 ★★★★★ 993 TX
2 MARCO COOPER 2000 ★★★★★ 992 MI
3 DORIAN BELL 2009 ★★★★★ 989 PA
10 CADE STOVER 2019 ★★★★ 952 OH

Nine players came to Ohio State with higher recruiting rankings than Cade Stover. However, rankings are not an exact science and the Buckeyes have found success with lower rated outside linebackers. Think about this, Etienne Sabino, Justin Hilliard, Reggie Arden, Mike Mitchell, and Dante Booker had higher rankings than these Buckeye defenders that were ranked well outside of the top 10: Ryan Shazier (.946), Joshua Perry (.941), Bobby Carpenter (.900) and AJ Hawk (.833).

Zach Harrison
Top 3 Ohio State ILB Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 MIKE D'ANDREA 2002 ★★★★★ 993 OH
2 RAEKWON McMILLAN 2014 ★★★★★ 989 GA
3 CURTIS GRANT 2011 ★★★★★ 989 VA
10 TOMMY EICHENBERG 2019 ★★★★ 897 OH

Tommy Eichenberg ranks 10th out of the 14 Ohio State commits to receive a ranking at inside linebacker. This appears to be a bad sign for the St. Ignatius player. However, James Laurinaitis (.833) has the lowest ranking of the 14 ILBs and he ended his career as one of the most decorated Buckeyes in program history. 

Top 3 Ohio State ATH Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 CURTIS SAMUEL 2014 ★★★★ 970 NY
2 JEROME BAKER 2015 ★★★★ 969 OH
3 TORRANCE GIBSON 2015 ★★★★ 961 FL
11 STEELE CHAMBERS 2019 ★★★★ 912 GA
14 CRAIG YOUNG 2019 ★★★ 874 IN

247 has Ohio State with 23 players recruited at the ATH position since 1996. Many of the players have become household names among Buckeye fans. Some names you might recognize, Darron Lee, Sam Hubbard, Malik Hooker, Tyvis Powell, Christopher Worley, Malik Harrison, Corey Brown and Cie Grant. 

Will Steele Chambers and Craig Young join the list of memorable names above? 

Top 3 Ohio State TE Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 LOUIS IRIZARRY 2003 ★★★★★ 983 OH
2 JEREMY RUCKERT 2018 ★★★★ 981 NY
3 JAKE STONEBURNER 2008 ★★★★ 961 OH
14 CORMONTAE HAMILTON 2019 ★★★ 869 TN

Cormontae Hamilton joins AJ Alexander as the lowest rated tight ends to sign with Ohio State. With the TE not being a focal point of the Buckeyes' offense, I don't see a top-rated player at this position signing with the Ohio State unless Ryan Day makes some changes on offense.

Top 3 Ohio State RB Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 BEANIE WELLS 2006 ★★★★★ 996 OH
1 SAM MALDONADO 2000 ★★★★★ 996 NY
3 MAURICE CLARETT 2002 ★★★★★ 984 OH
16 MARCUS CROWLEY 2019 ★★★ 888 FL

Looking at the top 3, you can see that one of these things is not like the others. Sam Maldonado did not live up to the hype. After two seasons and 218 rushing yards on 61 attempts, Maldonado transferred to Maryland.

On the other end of the spectrum, Beanie Wells and Maurice Clarett lived up to the lofty expectations. Although it would have been nice to see Clarett play for more than one magical season.

Of the 17 Ohio State players to have a recruiting ranking, only three score below .900. Crowley joins Daniel Herron (.875) and Jordan Hall (.870) on that list. Two players listed just above Crowley are Warren Ball (.914) and Carlos Hyde (.900).

For those wondering, Jaelen Gill, JK Dobbins, Demario McCall, Ezekiel Elliott and Dontre Wilson are list at the APB position and are not in the RB rankings.  

Top 3 Ohio State OT Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 NICHOLAS PETIT-FRERE 2018 ★★★★★ 996 FL
2 ALEX BOONE 2005 ★★★★★ 993 OH
3 DEREK MORRIS 2002 ★★★★★ 991 NC
19 RYAN JACOBY 2019 ★★★★ 902 OH

Of the 27 Ohio State players that have received a ranking from 247, 20 of the players have had a 4★ rating or higher. Malcolm Pridgeon, Taylor Decker, Kyle Dodson, Kyle Trout and Gavin Cupp are Buckeye offensive tackles with similar recruiting numbers to Ryan Jacoby.

Top 3 Ohio State DT Recruits
RANK NAME YEAR STARS RATING STATE
1 TARON VINCENT 2018 ★★★★★ 988 FL
2 ALPHONSO TOWNSEND 2000 ★★★★★ 985 OH
3 DAVID PATTERSON 2003 ★★★★ 976 OH
24 JADEN McKENZIE 2019 ★★★ 859 NC

Last year, Ohio State hit a recruiting home run with Taron Vincent. The Bradenton, FL native is the highest-rated DT in program history. This season, Jaden McKenzie comes in as the second lowest-rated Buckeye in history. Only Davon Hamilton (.829) had a lower rating. Joel Hale, Robert Landers and Adam Bellamy are players with a similar ranking to McKenzie.

The time for recruiting rankings is over. It's time for the players in the 2019 class to earn their spot on the roster and on the field.

This is a forum post from a site member. It does not represent the views of Eleven Warriors unless otherwise noted.

View 35 Comments