Ohio State Football Forum

Ohio State Football Forum

Ohio State football fan talk.

4 Consensus All-Americans for First Time in OSU History

+3 HS
NOVABuck45's picture
12/17/25 at 3:06p in the OSU Football Forum
11 Comments

The 11W article today breaks down the All-America team distribution well, but a fun fact that I think it worth a thread here:   JJ, Caleb Downs, KMac, and Arvell Reese are the first foursome in OSU history to be named Consensus All-Americans in the same season.  

We've had three many times.  But never four.  In that sense, it's the most decorated single season Mount Rushmore in OSU history.

Question:  in your view, what was the greatest foursome in Ohio State history?

I'm going Eddie George, Orlando Pace, Terry Glenn, and Mike Vrabel from 1995 -- the first three were consensus AAs, but Vrabel was only on one 1st team.  But this 2025 crew is definitely in the conversation.

This is a forum post from a site member. It does not represent the views of Eleven Warriors unless otherwise noted.

View 11 Comments