Ohio State Football Forum

Ohio State Football Forum

Ohio State football fan talk.

Ranking of Greatest College Football Teams of All Time. Oregon Higher than Ohio State in 2014?

+1 HS
SilverHaven's picture
December 6, 2016 at 5:15pm
57 Comments

The greatest college football teams of all time (actually since 1936 when the AP polling started) have been ranked, and this year's Alabama team tops the rankings.

The renowned 538 statistical group has applied their "Elo" system, that was so successful in the Soccer World Cup, to ranking the NFL, and now to ranking college football.  Here are their peak Elo rankings:

rank team ELO
1 Alabama 2016 34.2
2 Nebraska 1995 33.9
3 Alabama 2015 32.8
4 Oklahoma 1974 32.3
5 Miami 1988 32.2
6 Oklahoma 1973 31.9
7 Florida 2008 31.9
8 Alabama 2012 31.9
9 So Cal 2004 31.8
10 Oregon 2014 31.6
11 Nebraska 1971 31.6
12 Ohio State 2014 31.6
13 Nebraska 1977 31.3
14 So Cal 2005 31.2
15 Florida 1996 31.0
16 Miami 2002 30.9
17 Alabama 2013 30.7
18 Alabama 2011 30.4
19 Army 1945 30.3
20 Miami 1989 30.1

I was shocked to see Oregon ranked higher than Ohio State in 2014.  I would strongly suggest, instead of Elo, using Eto, the "eye test option."  The 2014 championship game was a dominate crushing, except for 4 turnovers, two of them unforced errors by a third-string QB inserted into his third start.

Do you more dedicated students of the game, see other interesting comparisons? Where would you put the 1968 and 1969 Buckeyes?  And the 2002 Buckeyes? Or even the 1993, 1994 and 1998 teams?

For more detailed info and continuing down to #30 see this link:
http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/we-rate-alabama-the-strongest-team-i...

This is a forum post from a site member. It does not represent the views of Eleven Warriors unless otherwise noted.

View 57 Comments