First, I like to say that this question has the scenario that we win out, Louisville wins out, Bama wins out, Clemson wins out, and either the PAC 12 champ or BIG XII champ has a loss. This isn't about whether you think that we are good enough to win out.
With that scenario, who do you think the committee would choose. A 12-1 B1G Ohio State or a 11-1 Louisville?