College Sports Forum

College Sports Forum

College sports fan talk.

Another Poll No One Cares About

+3 HS
Urban Achiever's picture
10/28/25 at 8:55p in the College Sports Forum
1 Comment

Been hibernating a while, starting to get back out there.

College football has been fun this season.  One discussion point early on was AP poll voting.  I think it all works itself out once we get to the end of the season, but there was some silliness being called out early. 

Anyway, got me to thinking if a bunch of dopes get to vote in the AP poll, maybe this dope could give it a try and make my own rankings.  It's been a fun exercise, a couple pages worth of scribbles in a notebook each week and enhances that week's viewing experience a bit too.

Figured at this point I'd post here for a bit of "personal accountability" and put it out there since it was the criticism of AP voters that got me thinking on this (and maybe to add on to what's been a fun new mid-week hobby for me).

3 criteria/personal decisions I gave myself:

  • Wait until October to make 1st poll (this below is the 5th iteration now)
  • Cut it at Top 20 (with 12 team playoff no need for me to spend extra time parsing #22vs23vs24 etc)
  • Include (at least) 1 G5 team each week since they'll get a bid.
    Rec Next Notes
1 Ohio St 7-0 v PSU  
2 Indiana 8-0 @ Md  
3 Alabama 7-1 --  
4 Texas A&M 8-0 -- Still expecting a stumble, but good win.
5 Georgia 6-1 v Fla Hate to say it, but Gunner Stockton is a winner.
6 Vandy 7-1 @ Texas I know I'm "too high" on them but it's a damn good football team
7 Oregon 7-1 -- (These guys might actually be phony as hell)
8 GA Tech 8-0 @ NC St SOFT schedule; they'll go 11-1 without having to do much
9 Ole Miss 7-1 v S Car Should win out; we'll see
10 Miami 6-1 @ SMU  
11 Texas Tech 7-1 @ K St  
12 BYU  8-0 --  
13 Louisville 6-1 @ VT Very good team; I probably like them better than GT
14 Notre Dame 5-2 @ BC  
15 Tennessee 6-2 v Okla Hanging around but I expect they'll fade
16 Cincinnati 7-1 @ Utah  
17 Pitt 6-2 @ Stan Really coming on lately
18 Oklahoma 6-2 @ Tenn Probably too high; the yolo boy QB will drag them out soon
19 Iowa 6-2 -- Actually playing pretty solid ball
20 Navy 7-0 @NTx Undefeated troops get the G5 nod until they ain't

"Keeping an eye on" (in no order): Houston, UVA (phonies), Washington, Nebraska (not really), San Diego St, Boise, AAC competitors

Fuck michigan.

This is a forum post from a site member. It does not represent the views of Eleven Warriors unless otherwise noted.

View 1 Comments