Parris Campbell / KJ Hill

Parris had a lot of straight line speed & a lot of hype, but KJ had a lot of production & consistency. Both great players & great Buckeyes, but I give the edge to KJ Hill.

Jeffery Okudah / Shawn Wade

Okudah had a lot of hype, Wade hade a lot of impact (see the 2019 Clemson game). OSU was a different team when #24 was off the field. Both great players but I believe Shawn Wade was a more impactful DB at Ohio State.

JT Barrett / Cardale Jones

JT started more games but didn’t always finish (see 2014 & 2017 Michigan - Cardale Jones & Dwayne Haskins finished the job). JTB lost 6 games, Cardale lost zero. Cardale brought home the natty in 2014 & I don’t think JT could have won it all. Both are Buckeye Legends, but Cardale’s run will be immortalized forever.

Disagreements are welcome, what are some other comparisons that come to mind?