I was originally gonna go with all time starting offense but it would have taken too long. As a lifelong Buckeye fan I have been to many game at The Shoe & have seen countless great Ohio State players. Actually there are too many to list so here are my five selections...
QB: Troy Smith (he was 3-0 vs. meeeechegan, enough said)
RB's: Archie & Eddie (three Heisman's between 'em, not too shabby)
WR's: HOFer Cris Carter & Terry Glenn
Honorable Mention: Craig Krenzel, Beanie Wells, Keith Byars, Terry Glenn, Santonio 'OhNo!' Holmes.