B1G Recap: Poor Northwestern

By Nicholas Jervey on November 17, 2013 at 6:00a

Big Ten fans are familiar with narrative in all its good and bad forms, so here's an easy analogy for where the conference stands as of Week 12: falling action. The confusion and drama peaked in midseason; now the division races are winding down and bowl teams have nearly all been determined. The Big Ten Championship Game serves as the dénouement, as does the bowl season. Come to think of it, wouldn't bowls be part of the exposition for next season? This literary stuff is cyclical, after all.

#14 Michigan State (9-1, 6-0) 41, Nebraska (7-3, 4-2) 28

The main plot being told in 2013 is the collision course between Michigan State and Ohio State in the Big Ten Championship Game. Jeremy Langford's 151 yards and three touchdowns allowed Michigan State to clinch a share of the Legends division title.

Nebraska’s offense did its defense no favors on the day. Three first quarter turnovers put the Blackshirts in an early hole, and though the defense held up a muffed punt enabled an R.J. Shelton touchdown run to put Michigan State up 10-0. Tommy Armstrong Jr. struggled through the first half, and his fumble late in the second quarter let Jeremy Langford bruise his way to the end zone to give Michigan State a 20-7 halftime lead.

In the second half, Imani Cross had a thunderous 51-yard touchdown run and Armstrong threw a 38-yard touchdown pass to Kenny Bell to close the deficit to 27-21. The Cornhuskers were positioned for a go-ahead score after intercepting Connor Cook at the MSU 30, but replay officials overturned the interception. One exchange of punts later, Michigan State went on a lengthy drive sustained by a fake field goal and capped by Keith Mumphery's 27-yard touchdown catch to seal the win.

Langford's 37-yard touchdown run served as window dressing. Ron Kellogg III's touchdown pass in the final minute made the score closer for Nebraska.

Nebraska's offense did far better than one would expect, accumulating 392 yards of offense, 19 first downs and 28 points against the stingiest defense in the country. Had the Cornhuskers avoided turning the ball over five times, the game was there for the taking. Its division hopes dashed, Nebraska can now return to the matter of contriving a reason to fire Bo Pelini. A loss at Penn State next week might do the trick.

The decision to make Connor Cook the quarterback and stick with him has paid off well for Michigan State. The Spartans earned the program's first ever victory against Nebraska, pushing the series record to 1-7. Michigan State has nearly clinched a Big Ten Championship Game berth; the only way it can lose the division is if it loses to both Northwestern (next week) and Minnesota (in the season finale).

Michigan (7-3, 4-3) 27, Northwestern (4-6, 0-6) 19, 3OT

AL BORGES IS A GENIUS3.9 yards per carry = offensive juggernaut. [MVictors]

Michigan made an improbable field goal at the end of regulation and Devin Gardner dominated three overtimes to win an amazing, terrible fiasco of a game and punch yet another hole in the hearts of Northwestern fans.

Everyone expected pathetic offense in this game, and Northwestern and Michigan lived down to expectations. Neither team could generate a push on offense, resulting in many slow, ponderous drives in regulation. Northwestern's Jeff Budzien kicked a 22-yard field goal to make it 6-3 at the half and another to make it 9-3 in the third quarter. When Michigan couldn't do anything to help itself, NU punter Brandon Williams did it for them with a seven yard shank from his own end zone, giving Michigan a bizarre first and goal at the 10. The Wolverines squandered the field position, settling for a field goal.

In spite of a failed fourth down conversion with five minutes to go, the Wolverines had one last opportunity to tie the game. Michigan faced a 3rd and 23 at the NU 43 with 18 seconds left, and Gardner threw a 16-yard pass caught inbounds. With a running clock, Michigan was somehow able to hustle the offense off the field, race the field goal team on the field, get set for a second (though they weren't) and kick a game-tying 44-yard field goal in the span of ten seconds. Michigan and Northwestern traded touchdowns in the first overtime and field goals in the second; it appeared that Northwestern recovered a fumble to end the game in the second overtime, but Michigan came out of a pile of Wildcat defenders with the ball to stay alive. In the final overtime Northwestern couldn't match Gardner's touchdown or two-point conversion scramble, and suffered its sixth agonizing loss in a row.

It just can't get any more brutal for Northwestern fans. This loss is even worse than the previous five, since Michigan beat the Wildcats last year with a similarly crazy finish and overtime and the Wildcats should have had this game won several times. This is the kind of loss that bothers a fan for decades, and being the best six-loss team in the country is no solace for Northwestern. Now it’s do-or-die: beat No. 14 Michigan State next week, or spend bowl season at home.

Hey, rushing for positive yardage is fun! Subtracting sacks, Michigan’s offense rushed for an unimpressive 3.9 yards per carry, cause to celebrate after two weeks of negative rushing yards. The offense was an ugly grab bag that did just well enough to survive against an undersized opponent suffering from the worst luck in America. Flush with success, Michigan looks for another exhilarating win at Iowa next week.

#17 Wisconsin (8-2, 5-1) 51, Indiana (4-6, 2-4) 3

JUMP AROUNDEven receivers were in the rushing spirit.

Indiana came to Camp Randall Stadium hoping to end Wisconsin's streak of blowout wins. 554 rushing yards later, the Hoosiers left Madison broken and battered.

The demolition began with Wisconsin’s first play from scrimmage, a 93-yard touchdown run by James White. Melvin Gordon added another touchdown less than two minutes later, and the rout was on. Jared Abbrederis, a wide receiver, he had three carries for 86 yards and two touchdowns. Corey Clement, a fourth-string tailback, had two rushing touchdowns. Indiana's only score came on a 23-yard Mitch Ewald field goal in the third quarter. Judging by the fog and lightning warning during the game, even the forces of nature were powerless to stop Wisconsin’s offense.

When Indiana hired Kevin Wilson in 2010, he was supposed to reproduce Oklahoma’s high-octane offense. He has had mixed success at that, while three years of defensive regression have put him on the hot seat. Fresh from the bludgeoning in Madison, Indiana travels to Columbus to face No. 3 Ohio State next week. Out of the frying pan and into the fire.

White and Gordon had 296 combined yards at halftime; if Gary Andersen wanted to run up the score, he could have broken the NCAA record for combined yardage of two teammates (504). In spite of the Arizona State screwjob, Wisconsin is in fine position for an at-large BCS bid if it wins out. Wisconsin plays for Paul Bunyan’s Axe at No. 25 Minnesota next week.

Penn State (6-4, 3-3) 45, Purdue (1-9, 0-6) 21

Zach Zwinak rushed for three touchdowns and Allen Robinson had his school record 78th pass reception of the year as Penn State overwhelmed Purdue to ensure a winning record for the second straight year under sanctions.

Penn State perforated Purdue's porous defense, scoring touchdowns on four of the first five possessions. But a 100-yard kickoff return by Raheem Mostert made the score 28-14 at halftime, and Danny Etling’s 11-yard touchdown run made it a dangerous 28-21 game in the third quarter. That's when Zwinak took over, scoring his third touchdown of the day and allowing Penn State to grind down Purdue's defense with 17 unanswered points to end the game.

Purdue should feel good about staying in this game so long. Sure, the Nittany Lions are no world beaters, but playing its last two opponents close gives Purdue hope for winning its final two conference games. Next week is the matchup we’ve all been waiting for all season: winless Purdue hosting winless Illinois, a.k.a. the Bile Bowl.

Penn State came into the game struggling on red zone offense and came away with seven scores on seven red zone attempts, six of them being touchdowns. The Nittany Lions have benefited from a backloaded schedule, which catches up next week when they host Nebraska.

Cincinnati 52, Rutgers (5-4, 2-3) 17

RUTGERS IS WRETCHEDUnseemly: yes. better than Northwestern's uniforms: yes.

Rutgers gave up any pretense of being a good team, allowing 405 passing yards to Brendon Kay in a home annihilation by Cincinnati.

Cincinnati blitzed Rutgers in the first quarter and never let up. After Gary Nova threw a 16-yard touchdown pass to cut Cincinnati’s lead to 10-7, the Bearcats scored 42 straight points to put the game away. It was 24-7 after the first quarter and 38-7 at the half; only Savon Huggins’ touchdown run with 4:53 remaining and a field goal in the final seconds flattered the final score.

Rutgers’ inability to stop passing offenses has progressed to an ongoing embarrassment. Coming into the game, it was 121st in the country in passing defense, and it’ll only get worse. On offense, Gary Nova’s inconsistency is even stranger. Who else but Nova alternates 390-yard, 5 TD games with 18-of-38, 170-yard games?

Rutgers has little time to prepare for a game at No. 15 Central Florida on Thursday night. In all likelihood, Blake Bortles will throw for 600 yards.

Maryland (6-4, 2-4) 27, Virginia Tech 24, OT

Maryland held Virginia Tech to just 264 yards of total offense, and C.J. Brown's 3-yard touchdown run in overtime sent the Terrapins to a bowl game.

Though Virginia Tech scored first, the defense held the Hokies scoreless through the rest of the first half. William Likely returned a punt 62 yards for a touchdown, and Brown led Maryland on a five play, 56 yard drive in just 35 seconds to put Maryland up 14-7 at the half. A touchdown pass from Brown made it 21-7 until Logan Thomas’s touchdown passes in the third quarter and in the fourth quarter tied it at 21. In overtime, a questionable pass interference call on VT's possession was mooted by Brown's winning touchdown run.

Nobody would have expected a depleted Maryland squad to recover from its midseason swoon by taking down a division frontrunner, but that’s exactly what happened in the road upset. The Terrapins have shown tremendous resilience passing through the worst of their schedule, and now they can play their way into a better bowl by beating Boston College next week.

And there you have it for Week 12. Week 13has at least four pseudo bowl game attractions: the Newcomer Bowl (Penn State-Nebraska), the Actually Competitive For A Change Bowl (Wisconsin-Minnesota), the Pointsplosion Bowl (Ohio State-Indiana) and the Bile Bowl (Illinois-Purdue). I think we all know which game has the greatest ironic value.


Comments Show All Comments

BeijingBucks's picture

Ok I'm a homer... And I have to say the B1G is awful. Wish some of these teams were not bowl eligible. Just gonna make the Bucks look bad. 
win or lose against UM is a no win scenario. 
im beginning to think with the increases in SOS importance the playoff is going to be even more of a fashion show. 

None can love freedom heartily, but good men; the rest love not freedom, but license. ~ John Milton

fanatibuck's picture

Does any of our fans watch any of the other conferences? The ACC and BIG12 are not that much better. We need to stop feeding into the negative stereotypes perpetrated by the media. Buckeye Nation is a part of the problem at some point.


SgtMdx's picture

Have to agree. With the exception of FSU, the ACC is hard to watch and that includes Clemson.

The deadliest weapon in the world is a Marine and his rifle.
Gen. John "Black Jack" Pershing, U.S. Army

Thajinn's picture

100% agree but for me this also goes for a lot of the Sec games I had a EVERY hard time watching that Tide vs Miss St game..

GoBucksOSU's picture

I would argue that the Big 12 is worse than the Big 10 this year.

Abe Froman's picture

I am surprised more wasn't made on the missed call by the refs at the end of regulation in the Michigan / Northwestern game.  When the were lining up for the kick, the entire team was moving (obviously) as the ran onto the field, the kicker walked it off as they were getting set and WITHOUT stopping stepped forward and kicked the ball.  Not even close to stopping for the required second, he just kicked it.  I don't want to get into specifics, but I don't want to see football get like basketball where they don't really make calls in the last two or three seconds.

Basking in the wake of mediocrity.....

Thajinn's picture

well it will happen if that is what Networks want to get Rattings which mean more $$$$..thats where all this always boils down too..

gumtape's picture

Mark Dantonio has the greatest poker face ever. This was his fake field goal call.

It is not a poker face. That is Dantonio's "I'm pooping a pine cone" face.

High and tight boo boo

DaiTheFlu's picture

Which, to be fair, is exactly the same as his normal face.

We can't stop here; this is bat country...

Kurt's picture

I didn't see any of the Mich State - Nebraska tilt.  But in the 11W poll on Friday said that the game should be for Nebraska to lose (if not for the tough season they're having).  Sure enough 5 turnovers and only a 2 score defeat with a backup QB.
I really think Nebraska would be foolish to fire Pelini.  

gumtape's picture

If they do he would make a great defensive coordinator for some team. Not us of course
Fickell-Withers 4Life!

High and tight boo boo

Seattle Linga's picture

These coaches in the B1G need to recruit recruit recruit better or else nothing will ever change. 

Kurt's picture

It's not all recruiting.  Just look at the state of Michigan football right now.  Offensive and defensive schemes are incredibly important as well.  

Arizona_Buckeye's picture

Northwestern earned that loss yesterday!  They battered Devon all day and when it counted, with no timeouts, 3 and long with the clock winding down to a victory - coach Fitz decided to rush TWO PEOPLE!!!  Gave him all day to throw and the rest is history... I have absolutely no idea why he didn't throw the kitchen sink at him and the game would have been over... Oh well, you are Northwestern for a reason!

The best thing about Pastafarianism? It is not only acceptable, but advisable, to be heavily sauced