Opening the Floodgates

By Chad Peltier on August 13, 2012 at 6:00p

We've talked a lot before about how poor Ohio State's offense was last year - relative to both what we're used to and to every other offense in college football. 

The numbers - 115th out of 120 FBS teams in passing, and 107 in total offense - don't lie: last year was a terrible campaign, but thankfully it was an aberration. 

I don't intend to dwell on last year's numbers, because it's likely commentators will have that covered in every single broadcast you hear this season. 

Disclaimer: No Urban Meyers were harmed in the making of this picture. Urban's offense will surely bring a deluge of points

Instead, we Buckeye fans find ourselves on the dawn of a new era in Ohio State football. Urban Meyer has returned to lead the Buckeyes and he's hired an offensive coordinator that has more than "Dave," "ISO" and a play action pass.

Essentially, we can be optimistic because simple competency in the passing game would be a huge improvement. Case in point:

Herman, who will leave play-calling duties to Meyer, deemed them a “2” on a scale of 1-10 following spring practice. But they’ve already improved by 100 percent in a handful of fall get-togethers."Light years,” said Herman, describing the improvement. “We can actually throw and catch a football. We are still not real good, but we are still a lot better than we were at the end of the spring, which is a testament to our guys and how much they worked in the offseason."

Just going from a "2" to a "4" can be considered opening the floodgates compared to last year's offense, but what exactly does a "4" look like? 

Ohio State in the Tressel Era 

Our baseline expectations for next year should be first based on what Ohio State has done in the past decade. Urban will undoubtedly be compared against Ohio State's last best coach ever - Jim Tressel. 

Run-based, field position-winning Tresselball was never flashy. After Ohio State's second defeat against USC in the Shoe, Chris Brown wrote

Jim Tressel is the closest thing we have to that Woody Hayes, Bo Schembechler style. This is not to say power running is gone, but the absolutely ridiculous idea that you can beat Southern Cal by running the same power play -- what Tressel calls "dave," with a pulling guard and a fullback who kicks out the defensive end -- over and over again, is to "live in the deep dark past.

Those are definitely harsh words (though not Chris's worst in the article), but to Tress's credit, the offense did show some signs of innovation in subsequent years. What it lacked was mostly consistent application of these new strategies. 

Looking at Ohio State's offense over the Tressel-era, I'm struck by a couple of things. The below graph shows Ohio State's total offense from 2003-2011, with the red dotted line as a rolling 4-year average. 

Yeah, total offense isn't always the best measure of offense, but DEAL WITH IT

Tressel-led offenses typically suffered a big dip in overall production with every quarterback transition. The 2004 team lost Craig Krenzel, the 2008 team saw Pryor overtake Boeckman early in the season, and last year saw the unexpected departure of Pryor and the way-too-slow advancement of Braxton to the starting spot. 

Tress's teams averaged 2321 yards rushing and 2293 yards passing per season. Last year was clearly an outlier for Ohio State offenses, though it's also clear that Bollman teams never had prolific offenses apart from the 2006 and 2010 years (just look at the variation in Quick Strike scores!).

These basic trends make me believe that next year's offense would have improved significantly, even without a Mensa-genius starting as offensive coordinator. After each dip year (2003, 2004, 2008), the following year's offense improved by ~350-500 yards passing (rushing yards are fairly constant, except for the Lydell Ross years). 

If this upcoming season were another Tressel team, we might be happy with something like 2200 yards passing for Braxton and 2300 yards on the ground between the backs.

2200 yards through the air is comparable to what Pryor put up his sophomore year. While Pryor had more yards through the air his freshman campaign than Braxton did, much of that had to do with number of attempts and the fact that Braxton wasn't given the full reins to the offense until relatively later in the season. 

Essentially, if we hadn't spent half of 2011 watching Bauserbombs into B-Deck, it's possible (and likely) that Braxton's numbers would more closely approximate Pryor's freshman year. If we can all remember, expectations for Pryor's passing were sky-high following his freshman year, and he regressed in many ways (the Quick Strike score again reflects this). 

Braxton is a much different player than Pryor, with a sharper release and cleaner throwing motion. While his footwork was severely lacking according to Herman in the spring, his accuracy should improve significantly with adequate coaching. His 2012 numbers will reflect this improvement. 

Year Quick Strike Passing Yards cmp% RUsh Yards
2003 0.374 1639 57 1639
2004 .386 2105 54 1745
2005 .485 2708 65 2360
2006 .548 2791 65 2208
2007 .462 2565 64 2553
2008 .444 1953 60 2502
2009 .428 2257 55 2540
2010 .562 2971 65 2861
2011 .393 1651 51 2485

The New Blood: Meyer and Herman 

As Ross has previewed extensively, Urban's offense will consistently stress defenses by providing a quarterback run threat that will equalize defenses' numbers advantage on every play. While Pryor certainly presented a running threat to defenses, the actual offense was too strategically schizophrenic to consistently negate opposing defenses' numbers advantages. Ohio State will still utilize a power-run offense, but

The difference is that Meyer runs these plays in multiple directions from the spread, with quarterback reads and options built in.  Therefore, all 11 defenders remain threatened even when they see initial run action.

Catch up on everything you need to know ahead of the season kickoff.

Additionally, we can expect to see extensive use of the no-huddle and packaged plays, greatly improving the passing game's sophistication. These schematic changes will set Braxton up for success in ways that previous "multiple" -type offenses didn't.

Even without all of these schematic additions, any improvement would look extraordinary, simply because of how poor last year's offense looked. Nevertheless, we can look at how Urban and Tom Herman's offenses performed during their respective first years at Florida and Iowa State. 

Urban's first year at Florida wasn't entirely representative of his offense - Chris Leak was definitely not his ideal quarterback like Tebow would be - but Leak nonetheless managed 2639 yards through the air. The tailback committee averaged 147 yards per game, which is comparable to Tressel's 2003 and 2004 squads. 

The genius behind our new space-age offense

Herman's Iowa State teams, however, totaled 2338 on the ground and 2403 yards through the air in his first year at Iowa State. Herman's offenses didn't really get rolling until last season, when Iowa State hung 44 on Oklahoma State. As Kyle reported, his achievements at Rice were even more impressive:

During the 2008 season, Rice ranked in the Top 10 nationally in passing offense, scoring offense and total offense. Rice scored more than 41 points per game compared to 18 the following season without Herman.

While it might look like we shouldn't expect a record-setting season based on Meyer and Herman's respective first years, these offenses weren't close to the "final product" because Meyer in particular lacked a quarterback run-threat with Leak.

Tebow's first year as a starter (his Heisman year) might provide a better point of reference: Tebow threw for over 3286 yards and the team rushed for an average of 200 yards per game. I'm not predicting that Braxton wins the Heisman just yet, but there's no debating that he has a higher ceiling as a passer than Tebow. 

Based on the new offense's schematic advantages and the fact that Braxton gains a true quarterback coach, and in spite of the difficulties in implementing a new offense, we might expect something like 175-200 yards per game on the ground and anywhere from 2500-3000 passing yards.

putting it all together

Should the upcoming year's offense meet the expectations set by previous seasons at Ohio State, Meyer at Florida or Herman at Iowa State, we'll likely be ecstatic with anything over 2200-2500 yards passing and 2400 yards on the ground.

It's worth repeating that these numbers are approximations and are roughly based on previous years. However, it's clear the 2012 Buckeye squad is a different animal than any other, with a different quarterback, new innovations, and different circumstances. Regardless, Meyer, Herman, and Tressel's previous offenses will still form the context that we will use to evaluate the upcoming season. 

Those base-line numbers wouldn't be close to record-setting. Oregon's 2011 offense, which was fourth-best in the country in total offense, totaled 4189 rush yards and 3130 pass yards. Yet even those numbers would seem like an absolute deluge of points and offensive firepower after last year. 

Last year's group set the bar pretty low - unacceptably low for any team, let alone a Meyer and Herman coached offense. Here's to Braxton and company clearing that mark with ease. 


Comments Show All Comments

Buckeyejason's picture

Maybe next year ^^
Good read Chad!


Ken-Yon Rambo's picture

"We can actually throw and catch a football"
-Tom Herman

How firm they friendship...

buckeye76BHop's picture

Good stuff Chad as always...nothing illustrates stats than good old graphs.  This is what i always bring up to my friends about this upcoming year (and no not graphs but stats)...This below:

"The numbers - 115th out of 120 FBS teams in passing, and 107 in total offense - don't lie: last year was a terrible campaign, but thankfully it was an aberration. "

So many of my friends in and around the Columbus area seem to think 12-0 is a definite...I tend to look at these stats from above and have to use discretion.  I can foresee 9-3 or better...not sold on an undefeated season until OSU beats MSU and Neb...handedly.  Then I'll be a believer.  

"There's nothing that cleanses your soul like getting the hell kicked out of you."

"I love football. I think it is most wonderful game in world and I despise to lose."

Woody Hayes 1913 - 1987 

Buckeyejason's picture

Without a big ten title to play for or a bowl will be extremely difficult to stay motivated through 12 games without a real reward in sight..besides beating scum of coarse.


avail31678's picture

Possibly...while this is certainly a concern, EVERY single interview I've heard/read from many Buckeye players indicates high intensity, high levels of competetion, and high levels of excitement. The upperclassmen have a horrible season to redeem, and the incoming freshman have spots to fight for and somethign to prove (just by virtue of being new). We'll see how it plays out - hopefully Meyer and co. are up to the challenge of keeping them motivated. I'm betting on yes. CAN'T WAIT!!!

Run_Fido_Run's picture

The Buckeyes will be coarse on Michigan.

ih8rolltyde's picture

I see what u did they're

****igan smells like old water that hot dogs were boiled in.  FACT

Buckeyeholicwompa's picture

"Herman, who will leave play-calling duties to Meyer"
I'm just a tad confused, I was under the impression that Meyer did not want to call plays and wanted to leave it strictly to Herman? Something like this was mentioned after Herman was hired last year. Is this a point the finger to one another kinda thing or is there a set individual calling the plays??
IMHO.....besides from Bollman calling plays last year, I always feel that calling plays from up above is best because you have a birds eye view of what's really going on down on the field. While the HC or OC on the ground can't really see anything except a bunch of bodies hitting eachother.

CowCat's picture

My recollection was that Herman will dial in the plays by default and Meyer will override if he disagrees or sees an opportunity.
Also, with no huddle the plays will need to be signaled from the sideline, so maybe this plays a part.
11W Staff?

"We get paid to score touchdowns, not kick field goals"
-- Urban Meyer

slicksickle's picture

I agree with you. My understanding was that Herman had the play calling duties, but recall hearing that Meyer had the 'veto' ability.

slicksickle's picture


New offensive coordinator and QB coach Tom Herman had a chance to talk about his offensive philosophies and Braxton Miller. It was noted on Thursday that while Meyer will hold veto power, Herman will be calling the plays on gamedays.

Buckeyeholicwompa's picture

Ah I recall that. So my impression is Meyer will most always have a head set on and he'll be aware of whats going on at a communications stand point. Seems from what I remember when he was at Florida, he kinda took a back seat but interjected at times. Of course as we know, Meyer will also be looking to make sure his players are handing the ball to the officials after a TD and other things. How many pats on the ass is John Simon gonna get this year? 

osubuckeye4life's picture

Nice article Chad! It's going to be interesting to see this offense at full strength (personnelwise) finally! 
The funny thing is these guys in Herman's book are running at a 4. I wonder what ranking Coach Herman would give his North Texas, Rice, and Iowa State squads? 
Only 6 days away!