Mount Buckmore of the Decade: 1980s

By Chris Lauderback on May 21, 2012 at 10:00a
Mount Buckmore for the 80s features Cris Carter, Marcus Marek, Keith Byars and Chris Spielman.

Continuing our plow through the off-season waiting for fall camp to start, it's time for the latest installment of Mount Buckmore. 

The Buckeyes have been competing on the gridiron since 1890, racking up a filthy tradition including seven national titles, 34 conference crowns, 78 All-Americans, an all-time winning percentage of 72% generating 819 wins and seven Heisman Trophy winners. As Woody preached, you win with people and there have certainly been some special ones pass through Columbus. 

In an effort to separate the legends from the stars, the goal is to isolate the fab four Buckeyes from each decade.

If you'll recall, we kicked things off with a 60's wall that featured Jack Tatum, Jim Stillwagon, Rex Kern and Bob Ferguson. Not too shabby.

Last Monday, the 70s were up and so was the competition for real estate though the final four of Archie Griffin, John Hicks, Tom Counsineau and Randy Gradishar is packing all kinds of heat

Now we turn our attention to the 80s and though the Buckeyes won just three league titles, a number of elite players donned the scarlet and gray. 

cris carter - wide receiver - 1984-86

Carter's hands and body control were second to none

With Carter taking money from and signing with notorious agent Norby Walters, costing himself and OSU his senior season, I was 10% iffy about putting him on the wall but the fact is his onfield exploits make him impossible to exclude.

An All-B1G and All-American selection in 1986, Carter is one of only four Buckeyes to to register a 1,000 yard receiving season with 1,127 in '86 on the heels of a 950 yard effort in '85. His 69 receptions in '86 are the 3rd most all-time in a single season.

Despite missing his senior year, Carter racked up impressive career numbers ranking 2nd in total receptions with 168, 4th in receiving yards with 2,725 and 2nd in TD catches with 27. Clearly, even in college all he did was catch touchdowns. 

A circus catch waiting to happen, the Middletown HS product ranks 3rd all-time with nine career 100+ yard receiving games and owns the school record for consecutive 100+ yard receiving games with five. 

Unbelievably, Carter was just scratching the surface while in Columbus. After being selected by Philly in the '87 NFL Supplemental Draft, Carter went on to have a stellar pro career featuring eight pro bowl nods and having his jersey retired by the Vikings.  

Not yet enshrined into the Pro Football Hall of Fame due solely to off field transgressions, Carter ranks 2nd all-time in both receptions and touchdowns, right behind the greatest receiver ever born in Jerry Rice. 

marcus marek - linebacker - 1979-82

A three time All-B1G selection and a 1st Team All-American in '82, Marcus Marek is another in a long line of stud linebackers to grace Ohio Stadium. 

Captain of the '82 squad, Marek is the school's all-time leading tackler with 572 stops and owns the 3rd, 8th and 16th most prolific tackling seasons in OSU history with 178 in '82, 148 in '81 and 140 in '80.

In his senior year, he picked up 21 stops and a key 4th quarter interception leading to the winning field goal against a previously undefeated Michigan team in Ann Arbor setting up a 30 point win over Steve Young's BYU Cougars in the Holiday Bowl.

Marek's 316 assisted tackles rank 1st all-time. 

While I feel pretty secure in my decision to include him on the mountain, he's definitely the last man in and worthy of the most debate. 

A member of Ohio State's All-Century Team, Marek boasts one of the truly legendary perms in OSU annals.

Keith byars - running back - 1982-85

Keith Byars was the best player in college football in 1984. He only finshed 2nd in the Heisman voting thanks to some voters being mesmerized by Flutie's heave against the 'Canes and the notion that Byars would surely win the stiff-arm in '85, his final season at Ohio State. 

In his magical '84 campaign, Byars chewed up 1,764 rushing yards averaging 147 yards per game, both good for the 2nd best single season totals in Buckeye history. He also set a school record with 2,441 all-purpose yards thanks in large part to being an outstanding receiver out of the backfield. The signature game of Keith's ridiculous season came as he almost singlehandedly erased a 24-0 Illinois lead rushing for 274 yards and scoring five TD's, the 4th sans his left shoe on a 67 yard scamper, in a 45-38 win on Homecoming. 

For his Buckeye career, Byars is the 5th leading rusher all-time with 3,200 yards and ranks 2nd with 42 rushing TDs and 50 TDs total. Those numbers are especially impressive when you consider he injured his foot three separate times in an injury plagued '85 campaign that limited him to four games. 

Despite the injury, the Dayton native was the 10th pick in the NFL Draft earning All-Pro honors in '90 and a Pro Bowl selection in '93. 

Chris Spielman - Linebacker - 1984-87

Granite plain meets granite with a mustacheMy favorite Buckeye of all-time, Spielman is more than just a candidate for his particular decade. The legendary player and person can make a strong case for a place on the Final Four in Buckeye history. 

A crazed, tackling machine from Massillon, Spielman was a three-time All-B1G performer in addition to being named All-American after both his junior and senior seasons. 

Spielman led the Buckeyes in tackles in both '86 and '87 and his 29 stops in the '86 version of The Game remains tied for the school record. 

His monster junior season featured 205 total tackles, the 2nd most all-time in a Buckeye single season, and his 546 overall stops are good for 3rd place in OSU history. 

Setting bar ridiculously high heading into his senior year, all Spielman did was capture te Lombardi Award. 

A captain of the OSU All-Century Team, Spielman was inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame in 2009 and went on to become a four time NFL Pro Bowler prior to retirement which he now spends throwing haymakers at breast cancer in honor of his late wife. 

The Notables

As with the previous decades, I feel pretty good about those chosen to take a spot on the wall though the 80s definitely brought some stiff competition. 

Pepper Johnson is probably my first alternate. I loved watching him wreck ball carriers as a kid and and he's got some credentials as a two year captain and All-B1G selection in addition to being named an All-American in '85. 

Tim Spencer also deserves a mention as a two time all-conference performer and captain of the '82 squad. He always felt like a homerun threat running on the old super thin Astroturf and had a nice pro career. 

John Frank is another personal favorite of mine. The tight end was elected to two All-B1G teams, was captain of the '83 team and was a two time Academic All-American. 

The best of the rest include Jim Lachey, John Uhlenhake and Tom Tupa


Comments Show All Comments

gravey's picture

Mt. Buckstache.

Nappy's picture

Spielman's is stachetastic

I never saw a football player make a tackle with a smile on his face

Arizona_Buckeye's picture

I was lucky enough to be at The Game when Spielman owned the field against AACC.  He was a freakin beast that day determined to send Earle out a winner!!!  I will never forget it - I had front row seats in the end zone when AACC had it inside the 5 yard line.  A TV timeout was called and everybody, being dead tired had their helments off and sucking in water.  Not Spielman - he was pacing in the endzone, banging on his helmet and verbally talking himself in a frenzy!  I couldn't hear what he was saying but you could see the white fog coming out of his face mask with such verosity that you knew he was just going to kill anybody attempting to cross the goal line.  Glorious thing to witness live and a glorious game to end the season on, especially being Earle's last game!

The best thing about Pastafarianism? It is not only acceptable, but advisable, to be heavily sauced

Maestro's picture

Tough to argue with that Mount.  Nice work.

vacuuming sucks

BrewstersMillions's picture

Easily the best one yet-if for no other reason than for the aforementioned staches.

Poison nuts's picture

Yeah - this is spot on although, if Pepper was on here I would say the same. These Mount Buckmores have been great - thank you! Here come the 90s & it going to be tough...I got Eddie & Orlando for sure but the others won't be so easy. Cooper may have had a problem with tsun but he had no shortage of talent while he was there.

"Do not pass me, just slow down - I can move right through you" Superchunk - Precision Auto.

BrewstersMillions's picture

Eddie, Pace, Katz, and Boston? Springs? Winfield? Big Daddy? Spellman? Man, the 90's might be the toughest one to do....

BuckeyeSki's picture

D(bol) Boston....that is all

Banned from BlackShoeDiaries since 2008. Crime: Slander/Defamation of Character Judgement: Guilty

Poison nuts's picture

I think you hit it with your first 4 Brewster, but there were plenty of great ones in the 90s for sure.

"Do not pass me, just slow down - I can move right through you" Superchunk - Precision Auto.

45buckshot's picture

up next the 90s! :)

i'm going to go for Germaine, Eddie, Winfield, and the Big Kat. but how is Boston not on that list? Springs probably should be too... what a minute, Pace has to be on there!

Big Daddy?


“The true soldier fights not because he hates what is in front of him, but because he loves what is behind him.”
—G.K. Chesterton

harp35's picture

Ive been thinking about the 90's team for a bit now. George, Pace are no trainers unless your a college football hall of fame voter. I gotta go with Winfield as the second biggest hitter from the safety position in OSU history. Then Boston based on numbers and his take no crap from that piece woodson

SilverBullet's picture

Not to be correcting you cause i hate that but Winfield was a cornerback not a safety. Probably all the more reason he should be on that mount.

harp35's picture

Not no trainers but brainers, stupid spell correction on phone

Oakland Buckeye's picture

Total agreement on 80s! Marek's problem was Spiels made a lot of people forget about Marcus.
90's - Eddie, Pace, Boston & Katz in order, with 4b on Winfield & 4c on Big Daddy & Springs. Germaine cannot even be mentioned until 8 or 9 in this decade at best....

Buckeye Chuck's picture

Sorry, but Joey Galloway and Terry Glenn would go on my list ahead of David Boston.
And if we stick with 2 offense and 2 defense like we have been, I think wide receivers are getting ignored in the '90s. Iit probably has to be George, Pace, and Wilkinson as the three no-brainers, with another defensive player (Vrabel? Katzenmoyer? Winfield?) as your fourth.

The most "loud mouth, disrespect" poster on 11W.

Buckeye Chuck's picture

I guess I'm going to be the one to debate Marcus Marek, and yes, I did see him play in person. I know there's been an effort here to balance 2 offensive and 2 defensive players, but the plain fact is that the defenses during Earle Bruce's tenure simply weren't very good (disappointing enough, in fact, to get Nick Saban fired). OK, Marek made a lot of tackles. But did he make a real difference? I don't think so. Jerome Foster, from the same general era, is even more ignored by history than Marek has been, but he was a better player--probably the only really decent defensive lineman that Earle's teams ever had.
I'm not going to argue him too strenuously, but he's clearly on a level well below the other three.
Oh, and one correction: the '82 Michigan game was at the 'Shoe. 

The most "loud mouth, disrespect" poster on 11W.

johnblairgobucks's picture

Wiliam White, Jim Karsatos, Carlos Snow and Derek Iseaman(sp?) were some of my favorite Buckeyes to root for.
Tom Tupa(punter), Jim Lachey and John Franks were some of the best Buckeyes to ever play their positions.

osubuckeye4life's picture

Awesome list Byars, Carter, and Spielman were given and I'm alright with Marek though I could have seen Johnson in place of him. 
One more note thank you so much for leaving Art Shyster off both the 70's and 80's lists!!!! 

Man of Scarlet and Gray's picture

how the hell are you going to make the 90's and 2000's mount's? Absolutley nuts how much talent we've had in the shoe the last two decades.

 "I like to believe that my best hits border on felonious assault."
--Jack Tatum

NorthernOhioBuckeye's picture

Spielman is the greatest Buckeye EVER! He is proof that there is a God. If he had the physical tools that Katzenmoyer had, with his intensity, he would have killed people on the field. There is not another player in the last 50 years that I believe played as hard and loved Ohio State like Spielman did. 

osubuckeye4life's picture

Anyone heard the Spielman and Barry Switzer story they sometimes tell on 97.1 The Fan.
It was the Pro Bowl and Spiels was playing and getting upset because no one was trying. 
He looks over at Switzer who is the coach of his team eating a hotdog. 
Spiels goes over to Switzer and lights him up (pretty much Spiels is saying everything in the book and probably foaming at the mouth) and then Barry just smiles and starts laughing continuing to eat his hotdog.
Spiels was nuts!