I was just reading a forum post over at BSD on this same topic and thought it might be interesting to see what people came up with over here because, well, offseason.  I only ask that you keep your picks to people that are currently alive and that played (not just coached) for the good guys.

My picks:

HC: Vrabel (Toss up with Fickell)

OC: Guiton

DC: Fickell

OL: Bentley 

DL: Alonzo Spellman

QB: JT

LB: Freeman

RB: Eddie

DB: Jenkins or Doss

WR: Hartline (this one was easy)

ST: Nugent? Honestly no idea on this one.