College Football's 10 Best Head Coaches

By Alex on August 2, 2012 at 3:00p
54 Comments
Two old palsWhere do Saban and Miles fall on this list?

After seeing Athlon Sports and then ESPN do a little back and forth on their top college basketball rankings, it got me thinking about who would be on the list of top college football head coaches currently still in the game.

Of course lists like this have been compiled before, but with camps kicking off across the country this week, it seemed like a good time to examine which programs give themselves the best opportunity to win games by putting the right man on the headset come game day.

Buckeye fans know too well after last season's 6-7 mark what a head coach really can do for you. While Luke Fickell seemed to be doing and saying all the right things off the field, there were too many times where his inexperience kicked in and he looked like a deer in the headlights when football decisions needed to be made.

When looking at the 10 best coaches currently in the game, you can't look at just one year, but rather the complete body of work throughout a career. Lightning in a bottle can certainly strike once or twice, but it is the coaches who have continually had success at the highest level, year after year, regardless of conference or program, that are deserving of recognition. People like Brady Hoke will likely be on this list over the next few years as his fit at Michigan is a glove, but someone of that type can't be included when they held a below .500 record before one very good year.

That being said, it's time to take a look across college football and examine which programs currently hold the best head men in the game. Join us after the jump to find out who they are.

10. Mark Richt, University Of Georgia

After successful stints as Florida State's quarterbacks coach and offensive coordinator during the Seminoles' run atop college football in the mid to late 90's, Mark Richt was hired as head coach at the University of Georgia prior to the 2001 season.

Is Richt's seat still hot?Richt has had great success Between The Hedges

Since landing his first head coaching gig, Richt has posted an impressive 106-38 overall record (73.6%) and 60-28 SEC mark (68.2%) over his 11 year stint leading the Bulldogs.

His teams have appeared in a bowl game every season, where he holds a 7-4 record in those games, including appearances in three BCS Games, all Sugar Bowls, where he holds a 2-1 mark.

While Florida, Alabama, Auburn, and LSU are the names that come to mind of late when you think of the SEC, Richt has done a good job keeping UGA in conference contention year in and year out, winning the overall title in two seasons and the SEC East crown five teams.

While he has been on the hot seat numerous times for his teams underachieving, Richt has rebuilt the Georgia football brand into a powerful one, and headed into the 2012 season the Bulldogs are considered a favorite in the SEC East once again.

9. Steve Spurrier, University of South Carolina

Steve Spurrier, better known around these parts as "The Old Ball Coach" (OBC), was living the dream as Florida's head coach from 1990-2001. The former Gators' quarterback found himself sitting at the end of the 2001 season with a 122-27-1  (81.3%) overall record, 87-12 (87.9%) SEC mark, four "BCS bowl" wins, six conference championships, eight division championships, and one national championship.

The OBC is digging the GamecocksThe OBC is doing work again in the SEC

There's not much more Spurrier could have asked for as he not only owned the town of Gainesville, Florida, but also was right up there in the college football world. That was until Daniel Snyder came calling.

Spurrier jetted the college ranks to bolt to the NFL and the Washington Redskins. The move turned out to be a horrible mistake on the OBC's part, as his "fun'n'gun" offense did not work out in the pros, leading to his team's posting a record of 12-20 during his two years in the nation's capital.

Spurrier took a year off from coaching before making a bold move in his return to college football, accepting the job at one of Florida's SEC rivals, South Carolina. Spurrier inherited a Gamecocks team from Lou Holtz and the program was in a bit of a rut after the former Notre Dame legendary coach was unable to pump life into the program, posting a 33-37 record and just two bowl appearances (we will choose to forget this and this) in his six seasons at the helm.

It has taken Spurrier longer than he had likely hoped to get USC to where he wanted them, but the Gamecocks have certainly made great strides. The OBC has posted a record of 55-35 (61%) overall and  29-27 (51.9%) in the SEC during his eight seasons in charge. More importantly, in the last two years, his overall mark is 20-7 (74%) and SEC record is 11-5 (68.8%), including one division title in 2010 and a second place finish in 2011. 

With the Gamecocks continuing to do well on the recruiting trail and executing on the field, Spurrier will look to improve his career mark of 197-75-2 (71.9%) in 2012, where his team should battle with Georgia for the SEC East crown.

8. Chris Petersen, Boise State University

Unlike the other coaches on this list, Chris Petersen doesn't have the luxury of playing in a big time conference with revenue sharing, boosters giving millions annually to the football program, or five star recruits flocking to his school. Like the other coaches on this list though, Petersen continues to keep winning games as head coach of the Boise State Broncos.

From zero to heroPetersen has made Boise State into a power house

Petersen began his coaching career at University of California-Davis back in 1987 and spent five season coaching the freshman team and then wide receivers there. He moved on to Pittsburgh to coach quarterbacks in 1992, but that was short lived as he moved back west to take over the same gig at Division II Portland State under Tim Walsh in 1993 and 1994.

Moving back west helped his career tremendously, as Petersen really grew up as a coach when he was hired by Mike Bellotti at Oregon and spent six seasons learning to hone his craft. He learned a lot from Bellotti in Eugene as wide receivers coach before accepting a promotion in 2001 to be the offensive coordinator at Boise State under new head coach Dan Hawkins.

After helping Hawkins build Boise State up from little known program to national Cinderella (53-11 record and four bowl games from 2001-2005), Petersen got tabbed as the Broncos' next head coach after his mentor left to take the same position at Colorado.

Petersen took his new job and ran with it, having immediate success with an undefeated season and Fiesta Bowl victory during his first year, and posting an incredible 73-6 (92.4%) during his current six year stay running the program. In addition to a great record, he has notched a 4-2 bowl record, including 2-0 in BCS Games, as well as four conference titles, with second place finishes in the two seasons he didn't win the crown.

More importantly for the Boise State program, he has brought them from the Western Athletic Conference to the more competitive Mountain West Conference, and word recently broke that they will move to a current BCS automatic qualifier in the Big East starting in 2013. Petersen is an incredible head coach who has done more with less during his time at Boise State and will continue to be a name at the top of every university's wish list when their head football coaching job becomes open.

7. Frank Beamer, Virginia Tech

Another coach who has been on the hot seat for not being able to get over the hump despite putting up continuous years of winning seasons is Frank Beamer of Virginia Tech.

Beamer is a mainstay at VaTechBeamer Ball has done the trick in Blacksburg

Now entering his 26th season as head coach of the Hokies, Beamer has posted a 209-98-2 (67.6%) overall mark with the school. Like Petersen he helped build the Hokies into the program they are today, taking over in 1987 when they were an independent team, moving them to the Big East in 1991, and finally settling them in their current home of the ACC in 2004. 

Talking about his successes, Beamer has been to 19 straight bowl games, including 8 "BCS games" that featured a loss to Florida State in the title game during the 1996 season. He won three conference titles while in the Big East and has four in the ACC, including six trips in eight years to the conference title game. 

Beamer is best known for his emphasis on defense and special teams generating points for the team in addition to the offense, a philosophy that has been pegged "Beamer Ball". His teams are usually well disciplined and have a knack for blocking punts and kicks or getting timely plays in the return game and/or on defense in order to make a victory the complete team effort.

Beamer heads into 2012 with yet again another successful team, led by QB Logan Thomas, and the Hokies should once again be set to have a successful year in the ACC.

6. Chip Kelly, University of Oregon

Charles "Chip" Kelly has been a well known commodity in college football since bursting onto the scene with his innovative system as offensive coordinator of Oregon in 2007.

Willie Lyles who?Kelly's offense has given Oregon an identity and wins

Prior to landing at Oregon, Kelly started his time in the coaching ranks at Columbia University in 1990, where he spent two seasons coaching on the defensive side of the ball. He left Columbia in 1992 for New Hampshire, left in 1993 for a quick stint at Johns Hopkins, before returning to UNH from 1994-2006.

It was at New Hampshire where he studied and developed his current spread offense that he took with him to Oregon. After having immediate success with the offense at UO, Kelly was promoted to head coach after Mike Bellotti stepped down as head coach to accept the role of athletic director.

Since taking over in 2009, Kelly has put together a 34-6 record (85%), including an unbelievable 25-2 (92.6%) run in the Pac-12. He has won the conference title in all three years he has been at the helm, and brought Oregon to two Rose Bowls (1-1) and a national championship game, where the team lost to Auburn 22-19.

Kelly, along with the help of Nike's Phil Knight, has completely reinvented Oregon Football and it seems like he has the program here to stay when it comes to being on top of the college football world. The Ducks will once again be ranked among the top 10 to start the season and if they can get by other conference heavy weights USC and Stanford, they will make a remarkable fourth straight BCS game and have a shot at the national title.

5. Mack Brown, University of Texas

Out of all the names on this list, Brown will get the most criticism, at least on placement, but when you look at the body of work over his career it is hard to argue his place amongst the ranks.

Brown on the way down?Brown needs a big season in 2012 to stay on top

Despite having disappointing results the last two seasons, Brown has led the Texas Longhorns to a 141-38 (78.3%) overall record and 86-27 (76.1%) Big 12 record in his 14 years as their head coach.

Prior to arriving in Austin, Brown coached Appalachian State for a year and Tulane for three years before making the jump to North Carolina. As head coach of the Tar Heels from 1988 to 1997, Brown completely turned the program around. In his first two seasons the team went a combined 2-20, but in his last two seasons UNC posted a combined 20-3 line to give the coach a 69-46-1 (59.9%) overall record and 40-35-1 (53.3%) ledger in the conference.

Texas liked what they saw from Brown and the move to bring him on in 1998 paid off. In addition to his lofty record, Mack has claimed six division titles, two conference titles, and a national title while at UT. He has only has one losing season (5-7 in 2010) and has posted at least nine wins in all but two during his time in charge. 

Brown has led the Horns to 13 bowl games (8-5), including 4 BCS bowls (3-1) that featured 2 national title games (1-1). UT has been down the last couple of years (5-7 in 2010 and 8-5 in 2011), but is expected to make a come back in 2012 now that the quarterback position has been more established and the defensive talent returning is top notch. If Brown continues the trend of the last two seasons, expect him to drop significantly on this list come next year.

4. Les Miles, Louisiana State University

His methods may be unconventional at times, but Les Miles, a.ka. "The Mad Hatter", certainly gets the job done when it comes to bringing his team victories.

The Mad Hatter is going for ring number twoMiles has proven he can run a big time program at LSU

A former player at Michigan in the mid 70's, Miles returned to his alma mater in 1980 as an assistant coach under the legendary Bo Schembechler. His stay was short there as in 1982 he left to go to Colorado, where fellow assistant Bill McCartney was named head coach.

After spending five seasons in Boulder, Miles once again returned to Ann Arbor from 1987-1994, where he helped Gary Moeller's team to eight consecutive winning seasons, including four Rose Bowl appearances.

Upon Moeller's resignation Miles went to Oklahoma State, where he served as offensive coordinator from 1995-1997 before doing a stint of three seasons as tight ends coach for the Dallas Cowboys.

Miles returned to Oklahoma State in 2001 as their new head coach, where he spent four years turning around the program while compiling a 28-21 (16-16) record. During his time in Stillwater, Miles led the Cowboys to three bowl games (and had some fun with this one), giving the program the boost it needed to be a competitor in the Big 12.

Following Nick Saban's departure from LSU to go to the NFL, Miles was named as the Tigers' new head coach and has held that post for seven years. Baton Rouge has brought the head coach great success, as he has compiled a 75-18 overall record (80.6%) and registered a 41-15 (73.2%) record in the SEC.

Under his leadership LSU has won three division titles, two conference titles, and has played in two national championship games, winning one (we will forget that as well). The Tigers have been to a bowl game in every season Miles has been the head coach, earning a 5-2 record in those games, including a 2-1 mark in BCS games. 

The Mad Hatter's accolades were certainly questioned heading into last year, as much of his success was with Saban's players, but Miles has proven himself on the recruiting trail and brought his team to an undefeated regular season and SEC championship before falling to division rival Alabama in the title game.

Miles once again has a top three team heading into 2012 and the Tigers are one of a handful of teams with a great shot to win the national championship this year.

3. Bob Stoops, Oklahoma University

One of Youngstown Cardinal Mooney's finest checks in at number three on this list and that is something not to be ashamed of as the Oklahoma Sooners' head coach has had an outstanding coaching career.

Choke artist or great coach?Stoops has had trouble in the big games, but wins often

After a four year playing career at the University of Iowa, Stoops started his coaching tenure as a volunteer under Hayden Fry. After spending time with the Hawkeyes he was an assistant for Kent State in 1988, was hired by Kansas State in 1989, where he was named co-defensive coordinator in 1991, and then finally left for Florida to head up Steve Spurrier's defense in 1996. 

During his first year at Florida, Stoops vastly improved the defense which helped the Gators to a national title win in January 1997 over rival Florida State. He quickly became one of the hottest names in the business and his hard work paid off when he was hired as Oklahoma's head coach prior to the 1999 season.

In his 13 season in charge of the Sooners' program, Stoops is 139-34 (80.3%) overall and 84-21 (80%) in Big 12 play. He has been to eight conference title games, winning seven of those, and claimed a national title during his second season.

The knock on Stoops has been his performance in big time games. He has led OU to eight BCS games, but has only gone 3-5 in those, while leading the Sooners to three national title games and winning one. That being said, making eight BCS bowls and three title games is impressive and speaks volumes to the consistency and success he has had while in Norman.

With another talented roster in 2012, led by QB Landry Jones, the Sooners are projected to win the Big 12 once again and should extend his coaching legacy.

2. Urban Meyer, The Ohio State University

Buckeye fans will be disappointed to see Meyer check in at number two rather than at the top spot on this list, but at just 48 years old Urban is still ripe to be carving his place in college football history .

It's Urban Renewal time in ColumbusUrban Meyer can be Ohio State's savior after "Tatgate"
 

You all know the story already, but Meyer began his coaching career as a defensive backs intern at Cincinnati St. Xavier High School during the 1985 season. Following his stint with the Bombers, head coach Steve Rasso helped Meyer connect with the Ohio State coaching staff, where he served as a graduate assistant under Earle Bruce for two seasons.

It was under Bruce that Meyer first truly realized what it takes to be a successful head coach at the college level and learned many valuable lessons that he still uses today. After his two year gig in Columbus came to an end, Meyer went on to serve as an assistant over the next 13 years at Illinois State (under Jim Heacock), Colorado State, and Notre Dame.

In 2001, Urban landed his first head coaching job at Bowling Green and started to make a name for himself in the college football world. He led the Falcons to a 17-6 (73.9%) mark in his two seasons leading the team, earning MAC Coach of the Year award in his first year and making QB Josh Harris a household name across America.

Utah knew Meyer was a special coach and hired him ahead of the 2003 season. Like with BGSU, a quick turn around was in the books for the Utes' program and Urban led them to a 10-2 mark, conference title, and Liberty Bowl win during his first season. His second year was even better, as the Utes went 12-0 on the year, once again claiming the MWC crown and defeating Pittsburgh 35-7 in the Fiesta Bowl behind future number one overall pick QB Alex Smith.

Meyer probably did just a little too well in going 22-2 in his two seasons in Salt Lake City, as Florida came calling in 2005 after firing Ron Zook. It was at Florida where Meyer reached his current "rock star status", with the coach going 65-15 (36-12) during six seasons in Gainesville before retiring following the 2010 season due to health concerns. Meyer led the Gators to three SEC title games, winning two of them, and six bowl games, where he posted a 5-1 record. Included in those six games were three BCS games (3-0), with two of them being national title victories in January of 2007 (really need to stop bringing things like this up) and 2009.

After a year in the booth working for ESPN in 2011, Meyer returned to grab the headset for Ohio State when he accepted the vacant coaching job in November of last year. Despite not being able to play in a bowl game this upcoming season, Meyer has re-energized Buckeye Nation and the Ohio State football program after "Tatgate" left the Buckeyes limping to a 6-7 mark last season.

Will Meyer bring the Buckeyes the immediate relief they are in need of? The answer is unknown, but his track record at Bowling Green, Utah, and Florida certainly point to yes.

1. Nick Saban, University of Alabama

Following his career as a defensive back for Kent State, Nick Saban jumped right into coaching, becoming a graduate assistant for the Golden Flash from 1972-1974.

The King of OversigningHate or love him, Saban has titles at two different schools

Saban showed a great work ethic and was promoted to an assistant on the staff from 1975-1976, before moving on to other assistant coaching stops in the college ranks at Syracuse (1977), West Virginia (1978-1979), Ohio State (1980-1981), Navy (1982), and Michigan State (1983-1987).

Following his time as the Spartans' defensive coordinator/defensive backs coach, Saban left the college game to coach the Houston Oilers' secondary for two seasons. He made a brief return to the college game to get his first head coaching job with Toledo in 1990, but left after just one year and a 9-2 record to become the defensive coordinator under Bill Belichick for the Cleveland Browns.

After four years in Cleveland, Saban once again came back to the college game, taking the head coaching job at Michigan State, where he stayed from 1995-1999. While in East Lansing, Saban recorded a 34-24-1 (23-16-1) mark that included four bowl berths. He turned around an MSU program that had not had a winning season since 1990, something that went noticed in the coaching world and ultimately landed him the big job he had been waiting for.

Before the 2000 season, LSU hired Nick Saban as the 31st coach in program history. Saban was a great fit in Baton Rouge and rose to the top of the coaching ranks after going 48-16 (75%) overall and 28-12 (70%) in the SEC during his five years with the Tigers. He went to three conference title games, winning two, also helping LSU win a national championship over Oklahoma in the 2003 season. Saban's time in the bayou granted him the same "rock star status" Meyer earned at Florida, and maybe a bit of an ego too, as he left the school in 2005 to go back to the NFL.

During his two seasons in the NFL, Saban went 15-17 as head coach of the Miami Dolphins. Despite maintaining he would continue as the team's head coach following a 6-10 year in 2006-2007, rumors were flying around that the coach would return to the college ranks with a big time program. No traditional power needed help more than Alabama, and the Rolling Tide made Saban their 27th head coach on January 3, 2007.

Since taking over in Tuscaloosa, Saban has done everything and more that Bama fans could have hoped for when he was hired. He has gathered an incredible 55-12 (82%) overall record and has dominated the SEC, going 32-8 (80%) through five seasons thus far. More importantly, Alabama has been to three SEC title games, winning two, and has gone 4-1 in bowl games, including 2-1 in BCS Games with the two wins being national titles.

Despite losing many of his defensive stars and star back Trent Richardson, Saban has Alabama poised for another national title run in 2012 and continues to reload his roster year in and year out with some of the top talent in America.

Honorable Mention: Lane Kiffin, Gary Patterson, Kirk Ferentz, Mike Gundy, Bill Snyder, Brian Kelly, Kyle Whittingham, Bret Bielema, Mark Dantonio, Mike Leach, Pat Fitzgerald

54 Comments

Comments

osu07asu10's picture

I would slide Petersen into the number 3 or 4 slot. Otherwise, I think its pretty spot on. 

"They don't know what they don't know." - Coach Mick

Alex's picture

I know he's done a heckuva job at BSU, but can he do it on the big stage?

To be honest the hardest part was ranking the coaches after Saban and Urban...you can really slot a lot of these guys in many places...for example Mack Brown could have been 8-10 on this list an nobody would complain...but take away the last two seasons and he's in the top 5 for sure...very very tough

osu07asu10's picture

I can give you that. He definitely has a "patsy" of a regular season but he has shown time and again in some of his annual match ups, the ability to beat big programs, and has a perfect BCS record. Can also boast having beat 3 of the coaches on the top 10 and 2 ranked higher.
They are all good coaches and I would be happy to have them coaching the buckeyes (if Urban ever left)

"They don't know what they don't know." - Coach Mick

pcon258's picture

i agree. relatively speaking, its easy to win at a school like osu, alabama, michigan, etc. but to take a school whose only claim to fame is having blue turf, and turn them into consistent national title contenders, its a damn impressive thing

BrewstersMillions's picture

I'm cool with anything that gives Frank Beamer his deserved cred. That man can flat out coach-and no one bounces back from bad losses like the Hokies. Beamber Ball is a ton of fun to watch.

Do I come off as arrogant? Shame on me, I was hoping it would more obvious.

Rural Meyer's picture

IDK about Richt, has a top tier program and hasnt won anything in years. Bill Snyder should be at 10 IMO 

Alex's picture

Gary Patterson was probably next in for me....Richt just made it in my book

joel121270's picture

Call me pciky, but you just had to give Bielama HM? Too bad.
 
:-)

Alex's picture

haha pained me to write that but two straight Rose Bowl appearances is impressive and he may have a third this year considering they have the Leaders Division on lock already

hodge's picture

Guy's been doing great things in a top conference with virtually no recruits, virtually the opposite of Mack Brown--who wins on talent alone.  Guy plays football Woody Hayes-style, and wins--even in an age where that offense is considered "outdated".
Hate to admit it, but he's deserving of his accollades; even if he's a dick.

hodge's picture

Great list.  It speaks volumes to the fact that numbers four, three, and two are native sons.  Also, good on ya giving Snyder an honorable mention.

BacknBlack's picture

What's w/ the SEC love fest? Thought 11W was redirecting me to an to ESPIN article. No way Richt or Miles is in the top ten, Don't reward dumb luck (LSU)  and a carrer 7/8 wins per season guy (GA).
How is Gundy being overlooked. June Jone should also be ahead of either of these SEC babysitters. 

Alex's picture

seriously? can take an argument for leaving Richt out, but Miles has done a pretty darn good job.....

BacknBlack's picture

While gathering talent is part of coaching, it remains a small measure of the total job. SEC teams win w/ talent, this only means the coaches are good recruiters.  
I give more credit to a guy that does more w/ less (no pun intended).  

Kurt's picture

Couldn't agree more with your pun.

Ken-Yon Rambo's picture

Uhhhh not sure if trolling or not.  Les Miles belongs up there.  His teams are perennial Top 5 teams, year in, year out.
Which makes him a Top 5 coach if you're scoring at home.

How firm they friendship...

sir rickithda3rd's picture

miles 100% should b on the list

mark may wins douchebag of the year... again

OSUBias's picture

SEC teams win championships, so nobody does "more" than them. Other people do less with less, and some people do less with the same. But 6 straight NCs = nobody doing more...period

Shitter's full

BrewstersMillions's picture

Since when is it a knock on a guy for having talented players? Les is a damned good coach and sits comfortably in his spot. I never understood why 'doing more with less' is somehow more noble than "Winning with studs". If anything, its harder to win with the great expectations great talent brings.

Do I come off as arrogant? Shame on me, I was hoping it would more obvious.

yrro's picture

Miles is an amazing recruiter and incredible at preparing teams, especially defense. His game-day coaching is atrocious.

Ethan's picture

Quality list. Only strong gripe I have is with Patterson not included in the top ten. TCU has been a team that, without the resources of the big dogs, has put up strong numbers and has fared well against the top competition. Not only that, but they're always counted among the top teams in CFB. Last year, after losing the heart of his undefeated team the year before, still managed to lead the Frogs to an 11-2 record, with losses in the first game to Baylor (by two points), and SMU in overtime. Patterson would've been immediately behind Urban on my list to lead the Buckeyes. Heck of a coach. 

BacknBlack's picture

Talented players require less coaching, they can get by on pure ability. So when you take a group of less talented players and make them compeitive credit must be given to the coach.
Are the managers at Google really that good or does it help that they only hire elite applicants?  

BrewstersMillions's picture

You can't be serious dude. Talented players need to be properly utilized. Jimbo Fisher isn't on this list anywhere but no one will ever argue FSU's talent. The Noles are among the most talented squads in the NCAA and win exactly bubcus each year. And Mike Gundy had two first rounders on his offense this year-so its not like his cupboard is bare...
The SEC is king of college football because they have talented players and the top coaches and assistants in the country. Like James Hetfield said..."Sad but true"

Do I come off as arrogant? Shame on me, I was hoping it would more obvious.

Baroclinicity's picture

Mike Gundy's cupboard isn't bare... on offense.  Defense is usually a different story.  But I agree with what you are saying.

When you're holding a hammer, everything looks like a nail.

Ken-Yon Rambo's picture

It's part of a coach's job to recruit.  

How firm they friendship...

Baroclinicity's picture

Can't knock the list, although I think that Spurrier is riding the coat tails of his past more than anything else.
I know honorable mention doesn't mean all that much in a list like this, but I think you have to include a few more "under the radar" types: 
June Jones, for making Hawaii and SMU relevant (especially at Hawaii where recruiting is impossible due to location and lack of facilities). 
Jim Grobe has done a pretty good job at Wake Forest for a number of years.
And Troy Calhoun at Air Force, although his resume is still sort of... incomplete.

When you're holding a hammer, everything looks like a nail.

BuckeyeSki's picture

HONORABLE MENTION?!?!?

Banned from BlackShoeDiaries since 2008. Crime: Slander/Defamation of Character Judgement: Guilty

ATXbucknut's picture

Richt? He seems like the antithesis of Ferentz at Iowa. Instead of taking 2 and 3 star athletes and getting them to play like 4 and 5 star athletes by the time they're seniors, Richt takes 4 and 5 star athletes and has many of them playing like 2 and 3 star caliber players by senior year.
And Mack Brown?!?!  He's on this list because the Texas hype machine is a potent monster (as opposed to an impotent monster?). As a proud alum of the Univ of Texas here in Austin (I still bleed S&G though), I can tell you that Mack is the worst X's and O's coach on this list. Or just about in any BCS conference, for that matter. He readily admits that he leaves play scheming and player development up to his assistants. He describes himself as the CEO who manages the overall football program (rather adeptly), but when it comes to the X's and O's he is aloof.  Know why Texas went from the title game in '09 to a losing record in '10? Because several of his assistants left! They were the X's and O's guys, not Mack. 
I'm not hatin on this list tho. 11W 4 EVA.

Boom777's picture

I guess anyone could rearrange the list but Richt has lost some questionable games since they smashed Hawaii, they just haven't performed like some thought. And they have had some great talent but he is better at groaming qb's(Which isn't bad) but not having a great a great defense (or just falling asleep on defense)

Wherever you are, there you be!

phxbuck's picture

Richt is not a top 10 coach, he makes the top 10 good guy list, but not sure about the whole coaching thing. 

avail31678's picture

Alex,
Towards the end of the article, you say "(really need to stop bringing things like this up)" - maybe I'm way too much of a silver lining type of guy, but perhaps it's a good thing that a lot of our worst losses in recent memory were against some of the best coaches in the game?  Still painful moments, nonetheless, but at least it took a mastermind to hand us those tough losses.
Also, I must admit, at first I totally disagreed about Mark Richt, but as I read on I saw his conference win percentage is actually pretty good considering all the teams he's been up against over the years.  I still don't know if he's top-10 or not, but it's certainly closer than I would have thought yesterday.
 
Good article!

fear_the_nut70's picture

How you rank coaches will have a lot to do with what criteria you put the most emphasis on.  For example, with Bielma, he has a nice 60-19 record (.759) but is only 2-4 in bowl games and really hasn't come close to sniffing a natty (I hate to agree, but I do think he does more with 2 & 3 star guys than anyone else on that list).  It's nice to get to the Rose Bowl two years running, but it's two losses, and that keeps me from putting him on that list.
As for Bryan Kelly, can we end the ND fascination?  He has a nice .727 winning percentage, but that's based mostly on assignments at smaller schools.  You want to sniff the top ten list, you need to do it at a big boy school, and his time thus far at ND has been pretty "meh" if you ask this guy.
I have Richt on that list because he has amassed that record mostly during one of the best runs a conference has had historically in all of college football. 
 
 

osu07asu10's picture

@Alex
Also have to say I was pretty peeved at seeing Kelly make HM. Granted, growing up catholic and having my church drill Notre Dame football into my mind, I truly hate all things ND.  That being said, I can't say at this point that Brian Kelly is a good college football coach. He has had some good recruiting classes at ND, but ND is ND, like OSU is OSU, and that will happen with any coach that puts in half an effort (reading this Bolls?) He may have a high powered offense, with an "improved" defense but I haven't seen him take an "elite" program to heights it wasn't already previously at. No BCS games, heck he didn't even coach the one game he qualified for. Bottom line, I would file him under the "gimmicky offense" category that Meyer spoke of in his initial presser. One of those "whoa whoa whoa, its not schematics, its player". I truly think he has peaked at ND, maybe peaking this season but otherwise I don't see them take the next step. Soon he will be just another former ND coach.
 
However, I was pacified to not see Brady Hoke's name on the list.  However, time will tell if he is truly deserving of that honor. 1 year does not make a good coach
 

"They don't know what they don't know." - Coach Mick

fear_the_nut70's picture

It pains me to admit this, but I think one could make an argument for Pokey just being outside the top 10.  In my mind, it isn't one season at TSUN (where everything broke their way), but the fact that he has had 3 stops and all three programs showed immediate improvement.  Dude's gotta be able to coach if he can win at Ball State.  Now, that said, resume is still a little light and I need to see more, but I would feel better about giving him an HM than that dude currently in South Bend.

NoVA Buckeye's picture

I cant believe you have the nerve to not put Kirk ferentz, the Tim tebow of coaching, at number one. This is an outrage and I question the legitimacy of this list (sarcasm intended)

The offseason begins when your season ends. Even then there are no days off.

thorvath22's picture

Replace Richt with Patterson and you've got yourself a god damn deal.

btalbert25's picture

I think this top 10 list shows exactly why the SEC has been so damn good.  If Petrino were still coaching it'd be awefully hard not to put him on the list as well.  I don't know that I think Miles is great, and I certainly don't think he's racked up so many wins because DUMB LUCK, but you couldn't leave him off of the top 10.  Much like, despite the failures in big games for a stretch, you'd have to include Tressel in the list if he were still coaching. 
You can't blame a coach when the team fucks up, but give him no credit when they win and are very good.  They can't lose because of the coach and win inspite of him.  It doesn't work that way.  

btalbert25's picture

Does Richt really coach an upper tier program?  When was the last time Georgia legitamately competed for the title?  There have been plenty of times in their history where they've come in with huge expectations and fallen short every time.  He's had a ton of talent, but is he really the reason Georgia doesn't succeed or is it that they've always been little brother to Tennessee and Florida?

Ultrabuckeyehomer's picture

No, GA was always the little brother of Tenn and Alabama. I don't know when you started watching college football, but when I was younger, when you thought of southern football, it was: Alabama, Tenn and GA.  No Florida at all.  Hell Arkansas was thought of as a southwestern team, not a southern team.  Even LSU wasn't thought of that highly, but certainly higher than florida, which basically hit the national scene in the 1990's.

SPreston2001's picture

Well thats kinda the point, GA hasnt been relevant for a long time and Richt hasnt really done anything about it lol. I agree GA has alot of tradition and used to be big time, but times have changed and nowadays GA never lives up to their hype. Solid coach just not top 10 IMO. Hell I may even put Kiffen ahead of him...

fear_the_nut70's picture

Sorry, I can't let the Kiffin comment pass.  Um what?  Was it the 7-5 season at Tennessee that did if for you?  Is it his 25 total coaching wins or his .657 winning percentage?  At this point, I'm just going to assume you were kidding and move on...

btalbert25's picture

Yeah, I'm talking in the last 20 years or so really.  When I was younger and watching football it was at the tail end of Bama doing well, like 92 maybe?  Tennessee and Florida were certainly the powerhouses at the time.  The west was kind of a mess.  Auburn had an undefeated probation season, Bama was still pretty good, but not great ( I think Kentucky beat them sometime in the mid 90's).  It was Tennessee and Florida.  I don't remember Georgia being much.  Of course in the early 80's when they were great, I was not born- 2 or 3 years old.

Ultrabuckeyehomer's picture

Sorry, after re-reading your post, I see you qualified the time-frame with Richt ... yes, I think a lot of it has to do with the rising up of other powers around him during his tenure.  I think he is a top ten coach - all those wins in the best conference, no real down years, etc.  that's not easy

Bucks43201's picture

good read, but thought Gary Patterson of TCU is in the 4-6 range

"You win with people." - Woody Hayes

ShadyBuckeye's picture

The Browns had Belichick AND Saban and still couldnt field a decent team? Wow, Cleveland really is cursed.

SPreston2001's picture

Yeah Cleveland needs a miracle to be relevant again. Its so sad to see that franchise down in the dumps...

avail31678's picture

Trent Richardson baby!....Plus a bunch of other things to help them win...

Kurt's picture

Agree with everyone about Patterson and Grundy.

Sort of crazy but Bill Snyder probably deserves some recognition.

ginntroy's picture

Mack Brown is the most over rated coach in college football.  If he didn't have superman in Vince Young he wouldn't have a title.  Also one coach that does an amazing job with little to no talent look at Kansas St.

Buckeyevstheworld's picture

Just out of curiosity, but where would Tress be ranked if he were still coaching?

"YOLO" = I'm about to do something extremely ignorant/stupid & I need an excuse to do it.

flipbuckeye's picture

I'd argue Bielema over Richt.
Please don't hurt me.

fear_the_nut70's picture

Both have similiar records and haven't been able to take their teams to the "next" level.  Difference for me is that Richt is doing it in the S.E.C. and Bielma in B1G, and it would be very hard to put forth an argument that the B1G has been a tougher conference during the duration of their careers.

Poison nuts's picture

God I hate that man...but you might be right.
Good list IMO. Hey - anybody remember when Chip Kelly kept saying his guys were too fast for the Buckeyes in 2010....that was funny. 

"Do not pass me, just slow down - I can move right through you" Superchunk - Precision Auto.

razrback16's picture

The only major issue I have with ranking Saban and Miles so high is that they have a consistent, on-the-field competitive advantage over many teams they play, particularly in the NCG against non-SEC opponents (and even some SEC teams who choose not to cheat). They have been and continue to oversign, and use questionable ethics when cutting players and signing more players than they have a budget for. Teams in many other conferences don't have this option. I don't remember Saban setting the world on fire before he got to the SEC where he was allowed to cheat compared to many other schools. I'm not saying he's a bad coach as he is obviously a good one, but it cannot be overstated that he and Miles have a BIG advantage over some of the big opponents they play.