BlogPoll Ballot: Week Two

By Alex on September 5, 2011 at 12:00p

Week one has come and gone in the 2011 college football season and it was exciting as anyone could have hoped for. Our beloved Buckeyes got the job done in convincing fashion against the lowly Akron Zips, but some other teams weren't as fortunate.

We now head into week two where we get to see a little bit more from those vying to make a trip to New Orleans this January. In the polls, there was already some shake up and with some big time match ups set for this upcoming weekend, there's bound to be some more.

Take a look at our latest breakdown of the top 25 teams in the nation and let us know how we did. Into our polls this week goes Baylor for their impressive offensive output in beating TCU, as well as USF for their road victory in South Bend. Out go the Horned Frogs and the Fighting Irish for miserable defensive and offensive performances respectively.

All of your input is greatly appreciated, so commentary is highly encouraged. The more the merrier folks!

1 Oklahoma Sooners The nation's #1 team sure looked like it in a 47-14 victory over Tulsa. Landry Jones had 375 yards passing with a touchdown, but the real show stopper was Dominique Whaley, who rushed for 131 yards and 4 scores on just 18 carries. --
2 Alabama Crimson Tide 'Bama made Darrell Hazell's coaching debut a rough one, as the Tide rolled to a 48-7 victory over Kent State. Trent Richardson started his Heisman campaign by notching 3 rushing touchdowns, while Marquis Maze has 8 catches for 118 yards and a TD. Nick Saban's team travels to Happy Valley in a slightly tougher game in week two. UP1
3 LSU Tigers Jarrett Lee didn't look too good, but it didn't matter as LSU's defense and running game helped the Tigers take care of Oregon 40-23. Ohioan Spencer Ware had 99 yards and a touchdown and Michael Ford had 96 yards and 2 scores to lead the running game. UP2
4 Stanford Cardinal The David Shaw era started off on the right foot as the Cardinal took down lowly San Jose State 57-3. Andrew Luck tossed 2 touchdown passes and RB Stepfan Taylor had 2 rushing scores to contribute to the cruise control win in Paolo Alto. --
5 Boise State Broncos Next to LSU, Boise State had the most impressive victory in the opening week of the season. Kellen Moore went 28/34 for 261 yards and 3 touchdowns, as the Broncos went down to Atlanta and knocked off a ranked Georgia team 35-21. Although they're in tougher Mountain West Conference this year, BSU's toughest game is now behind them. UP1
6 Florida State Seminoles The Seminoles defense pitched a shut out and EJ Manuel threw for 252 yards and 2 TDs in a 34-0 win over Louisiana-Monroe. It looks like Jimbo Fisher's team is coming together nicely early on in the season and this may be the year FSU finally takes back the ACC. UP1
7 Nebraska Cornhuskers Taylor Martinez has 135 yards and 3 TDs on the ground to go with 116 yards through the air in Nebraska's 40-7 win over Chattanooga. Rex Burkhead also rushed for 75 yards and a score on 11 carries for the Corn Huskers in an easy victory in Lincoln. UP1
8 Texas A&M Aggies Mike Sherman's team looked impressive in dismantling an SMU team trying to join the Big 12 by a score of 46-14. The backfield tandem of Cyrus Gray and Christine Michael combined for 35 carries for 217 yards and 4 TDs, while QB Ryan Tannehill threw for 246 yards and 2 scores in an impressive first game as a top 10 ranked team. UP2
9 Oklahoma State Cowboys America's greatest air show didn't disappoint as the Cowboys took down Louisiana-Lafayette by a score of 61-34. QB Brandon Weeden threw for 388 yards and 3 TDs, with 8 passes and 144 yards going to All-American WR Justin Blackmon. RB Joseph Rade had 129 yards and 2 touchdowns to make sure fans knew OSU can hurt you on the ground as well. A tougher Arizona match-up awaits Mike Gundy's team next week. --
10 Wisconsin Badgers Russell Wilson's debut was a successful one, but Montee Ball wasn't too shabby either in the Badger's 51-17 win over UNLV. Wilson threw for 255 yards with 2 TDs and ran for 62 yards and another score, but it was Ball who did it all, tallying 130 yards and 4 TDs in the Thursday night match-up. Wisco faces a much tougher Oregon State team in week two so we'll see their new offense a bit more tested this coming weekend. UP1
11 Oregon Ducks A disappointing start for Chip Kelly and the national runner-up Ducks as they fell to LSU 40-23. The offense turned the ball over way too many times and the defense seemed to really miss the departure of key players including Kenny Rowe and Casey Matthews, among others. The Ducks are still a front-runner in the Pac 12 so they can't drop too far as it's not unrealistic they can win out their remaining games this season. DOWN 9
12 South Carolina Gamecocks The east coast USC trailed East Carolina early, but Stephen Garcia came off the bench to save the day in leading the Gamecocks to a 56-37 win over the Pirates. Garcia likely took back the starting job as he threw for 110 yards and a TD, while rushing for 56 yards and 2 TDs after coming in for the ineffective Connor Shaw. South Carolina goes down to Athens to take on Georgia next week in what should be one of the best games in week two. --
13 Virginia Tech Hokies Just over 4 years after upsetting Michigan in The Big House, Appalachian State came far from replicating that surprising feat as they fell to the Hokies 66-13. In true Frank Beamer form, the VT defense forced 4 turnovers and scored a touchdown, while David Wilson helped the offense move the chains, rushing for 162 yards and 3 TDs on just 16 carries. --
14 Ohio State Buckeyes It wasn't always pretty, but the end result was defining as the Buckeyes got Luke Fickell his first head coaching win in a 42-0 victory over Akron. Joe Bauserman connected with Jake Stoneburner three times through the air, while Carlos Hyde and Rod Smith stepped in admirably for a suspended Boom Herron and Jordan Hall and an injured Jaamal Berry. The defense was pretty impressive too, registering 5 sacks and forcing an interception on the day. UP2
15 Michigan State Spartans MSU drops a spot after a less than impressive effort in beating Youngstown State 28-6. If you watched the game, the Spartans continually let the Penguins deep into their territory before YSU squandered a bunch of opportunities and the offense struggled to put up a ton of points despite moving the ball well at times. One highlight from this contest was that WR BJ Cunningham tied a school record for career receptions and will likely pass Matt Trannon in the team's next game. DOWN 1
16 Arkansas Razorbacks Arkansas certainly looked impressive, be it with a 51-7 win against a Missouri State team that didn't even belong on the field with the SEC power. Tyler Wilson picked up where Ryan Mallet left off, throwing for 260 yards and 2 TDs, while Kody Walker had two rushing scores in place of Kniles Davis who is out for the season due to injury. UP4
17 Mississippi State Bulldogs Dan Mullen's team is on a mission to silence the doubters and started off the right way in taking care of Memphis 59-14. The Bulldogs' defense forced 3 turnovers and Vick Ballard rushed 10 times for 166 yards and 3 TDs in the victory. MSU goes to Auburn next week in a game that should make it more clear if they are contenders or pretenders this season. UP5
18 Arizona State Sun Devils Brock Osweiler threw for 262 yards and 2 TDs, both to Aaron Pflugrad, as the Sun Devils skated in a 48-14 win against UC-Davis. ASU plays host to Missouri next week in another week two match up that should be exciting to watch. UP5
19 Missouri Tigers Missouri probably should move down after only beating Miami (OH) 17-6, but we decided to let them hang onto the #19 spot until after their trip to Tempe next week. If Missouri can take down the Sun Devils they deserve to move up in the rankings, but unless James Franklin has a repeat week one performance (129 passing yards,TD; 72 rushing yards, TD)  it looks like that won't be an easy task for the Tigers. --
20 Florida Gators The Gators helped Will Muschamp get a win in his first game as head coach in the town he grew up in as a child. UF took care of Florida Atlantic 41-3 in The Swamp and Chris Rainey scored three times on a reception, a rush, and a return off a blocked punt. Jeff Demps also had a nice day with 12 rushes for 105 yards and 2 TDs. UP4
21 West Virginia Mountaineers Dana Holgorsen continued the trend of first year coaches recording victories on Sunday, as WVU beat in-state rival Marshall 34-13. The Big East favorite were lead by QB Geno Smith, who was 26/35-249-2 on the afternoon. The rushing game did struggle though, as the Mountaineers only recorded 42 total yards on the ground for the day. UP4
22 Baylor Bears In one of the more exciting college football games in recent memory, Baylor took down Rose Bowl champs TCU by a score of 50-48. Robert Griffin III launched himself right into the Heisman race, connecting on 21 of 27 passes for 359 yards and 5 touchdowns, with a more impressive 0 turnovers. His favorite target was WR Kendall Wright who had 12 catches for 189 yards and 2 TDs in shredding what was the nation's top ranked defense for the last three seasons.  --
23 South Florida Bulls Like Baylor, it's an uncertainty to how long South Florida will remain in these rankings, but traveling to South Bend and beating a ranked (and over-rated) Notre Dame team certainly deserves them getting some credit. The Bulls' defense force 3 interceptions and returned a fumble 96 yards for a touchdown, while kicker Maikon Bonani connected 3 of his 4 field goal attempts in the 23-20 win. --
24 Georgia Bulldogs I expected Georgia to be more competitive in a game against Boise State in Atlanta, but can't fault them too much for falling to one of the nation's best teams the last five years. Despite the loss, Georgia has a chance to redeem themselves in a week two game against South Carolina at home, where Aaron Murray (16/29-236-2) will have a national audience to see what he can do.  DOWN 7
25 Auburn Tigers Auburn looked horrific in trailing for most of their game against Utah State, but rebounded when it mattered most and picked up a 42-38 win over the Aggies. Barrett Trotter went 17/23-261-3 in replacing Cam Newton, but the defense didn't fair as well in replacing those departed on that side of the ball. Overall the Tigers had to replace 16 of 22 starters and it certainly showed as they now hang on a thread for their top 25 life heading into a second week match-up at home against Mississippi State. DOWN 4
Dropouts: TCU Horned Frogs, Notre Dame Fighting Irish
SB Nation BlogPoll College Football Top 25 Rankings »




Bucksfan's picture

What good are polls if beating highly ranked teams don't do anything for you?  Why the hell aren't LSU and Boise both ranked in the top-3 after their weekend?

Alex's picture

It's not fair to boot Bama or Oklahoma because they didn't get the chance to play ranked opponents in week 1. LSU and BSU both moved up this week but you have to have some consistency in the polls. You rank the teams based on how good you think they are, not just on one game. Results in one game do shake up the polls each week though so if they continue to do their thing, they will move up.

buckeyedude's picture

"It wasn't always pretty, but the end result was..."  <-------------------WTF is THAT?

 OSU played a nearly flawless game, and the one-handed catch by Evan Spencer caused Urban Meyer to remark, "That may be the best catch I have ever seen."

I think SB Nation must not have watched the game.



Alex's picture

These are my comments, not SB Nation's. I watched the game and any fan who removes the Scarlet and Gray glasses for a minute knows it wasn't always pretty at times. The defense was solid and Bauserman looked great, but there were two broken plays (one luckily went for a TD), a fumble on the 4-yard line, a bad snap, a missed field goal, and other mistakes that need to be cleaned up this week. Overall the Bucks gave up 0 and scored 42, something you can never complain about, but there's definitely room for improvement. OSu beat a team many rank last or next to last in FBS football. They will be much more tested this week against an under-rated Toledo team--let's see how they fare here.

Also note they did move up in the rankings, even ahead of a victorious MSU team.

buckeyedude's picture

Copy. I get it Alex. I'm not a total homer. I just thought there were many less mistakes than in past openers. That's saying something for a first year coach, that has never been a HC, IMO. This team looked more prepared to play than many of Tressel's teams in the opener. I agree with you though, that there is certainly room for improvement.

Glad to hear you are giving the Rockets some respect, because even though it wasn't much of game last year, Toledo has a habit of beating B1G teams that don't respect them. They've beaten: Michelin, State Penn, Purdon't, Minnehaha, and the Who's Your's?. If my stats are correct, I believe until last year's defeat in Cleveland, they had a winning record vs. the B1G.




BuckPirate1981's picture

I'll be honest, while the comment doesn't deserve a "WTF" per se (much like Columbus drivers don't merit the storm of profanity my gf dishes out whenever we hit the road, but I digress and am glad she doesn't read this), I do agree that it is unfair to throw out the "wasn't always pretty" when that could likely have been said for any of the above teams.  But nice that you are able to take off the OSU beer goggles to criticize when needed - just may not have been that time?

Bucksfan's picture

Any team that gave up over 20 points to a non-BCS team should not be ranked in the top-20.  Defense matters, right?  Ok, they saw that with Auburn, great.  Then why is Oklahoma State a top-10 team after they gave up 34 to Louisiana-Lafayette?  Why did South Carolina not drop at least 5-10 spots after their gawd-awful defensive performance against East Carolina?!

If you're going to be considered one of the best teams in the nation, these sorts of defensive melt-downs cannot happen, not when there are plenty of other teams that are WAXING their lowly opponents.  Where's Penn State, for example?

Alex's picture

as previously mentioned, you have to realize this is week one and there has to be some consistency in polls....we had pre-season rankings and if a team wins by over 27 points can you really drop them? If OK State isn't for real, they will eventually lose and fall in the rankings. Right now they stay where they are because their offense is beastly and can outscore most teams. yes, they gave up more points than they should, but did you watch the game to see how/when those points were given up? may have been 2nd/3rd teams playing prevent defense or soft defense with a big lead.

South Carolina played a decent ECU team and turned things around once Garcia came in. They gave up a late TD to make the score even closer than it looks and got hit in the mouth early but rebounded nicely.

Finally, why should PSU be ranked? i think they are a 7-5/8-4 team at best this year with no quarterback, a depleted O-line, and a mediocre defense. They beat Indiana State so they should be ranked? Only to fall out again when they get slammed by Alabama? Let PSU prove they are a 9-3 type team and they can be ranked in the high 20's.

As I said, if you watch the game, sometimes scores can be deceiving. Rankings need to be consistent. We will see how the season plays out but for now you need to take things week by week. This is a big reason I'm not a fan of polls coming out until after week 4 of the season.

BuckPirate1981's picture

Cough *go buc(k)s* Cough - thank you for calling my first alma mater a "decent" team.  That means so much.  This guy --> single tear, down the face.  

Will in Arizona's picture

"Missouri probably should move down after only beating Miami (OH) 17-6, but we decided to let them hang onto the #19 spot until after their trip to Scottsdale next week. "


Arizona State is located and plays in Tempe, not Scottsdale.

Alex's picture

you're right...brain fart...edited

Bucks's picture

I agree with most of these rankings. Very happy to see that Auburn fell significantly for you as obviously they won't go that far in the polls.

rampageripster's picture

How can you still have Auburn ranked...  it's [markmay] like this pollsters... you put more stock in your preseason polls than you do on what has transpired on the field... so what if Oklahoma and Alabama haven't gotten a chance to play anyone good?  When they do, you move them back up.  Right now, Boise St and LSU have the most impressive resumes bar none.

Cause I couldn't go for three

BuckPirate1981's picture

Boise St. beat the Notre Dame of the South (in regards to preseason rankings, not to douchebagery), and LSU beat a team that can't seem to put anything together against teams with decent defensive lines.  Wouldn't say those are the most impressive resumes?  Though I will say, big props for playing legitimate teams the first week of the season as opposed to, oh, say, one of the worst teams in college football.  Just a thought, what about offering spring game ticket prices for these types of events for those who can't normally afford to go? Since it is essentially a glorified scrimmage, after all.

Bucks's picture

What the heck is wrong with some of you? It's a week one blog poll. Relax a bit, lordie.

Sgt. Elias's picture


It doesn't count ffs, it's just for funzies.  Some of you have a pulsating forehead vein for no tangible reason. 

"Okay -- I've got an El Camino full of rampage here." 

BuckPirate1981's picture

OOooooo what does F5 do?  And a pulsating forehead vein is what got a certain somebody the Ohio State football head coach position, thank you.  Imagine what it can do for us.  

NC_Buckeye's picture

Good Lord, Maryland is wearing clown unis for the game tonight.

BTW, didn't you guys jump the gun on the BlogPoll since this game just started?

Ian_InsideTheShoe's picture

I can't speak for 11W, but in our blogpoll ballot we (My writers and I) had a general consensus that we wouldn't be ranking Miami for 2 reasons, one being that they played on Monday, and 2 even if they won on Monday, that wouldn't be enough to crack our Top 25. It was just a thought we had agreed on. Of course, if they win tonight and next week then obviously they would have a shot at being in. Perhaps they have a similar thought.

Buckeyejason's picture

Miami gives up 4th and 8..those uni's are eww.


Menexenus's picture

I dig Maryland's new uni.  <shrug>  I guess if you don't like the Maryland state flag, then you won't like the unis.

Real fans stay for Carmen.

Buckeyejason's picture

Wow great D there Hurricanes. 7-0 already. Joe B is licking his chops LOLz


NC_Buckeye's picture

Anyone catch that latenight Colorado at Hawaii game on Sat? The Buffs don't look to be much of a challenge either.

rider1's picture

There is a thread on the Oregon football blog Addicted to Quack asking if their program would be better with Mike Bellotti back as coach. And I thought Buckeye fans were reactionary!

Seth4Bucks's picture

I'm hoping that both Toledo and Miami end up being top 35 teams, with at least one of them ending up in the final 25. Otherwise it'll be too easy for the mainstream media to dismiss the Bucks even if they do finish with a 10+ win season.

Bucks's picture

From watching this Miami game ... there is a better chance of Akron cracking the top 25. Miami could possibly pull this out, but suspended players or not, the defense is atrocious.

We're talking about simple bubble screens run, at times, 3 times in a row for 1st downs. Miami will absolutely NOT help strength of schedule. Lordie.

Bucks's picture

To add to this, Miami has given up 408 yards through 3 quarters. Maryland can pretty much do anything they want ... just a matter of one leaping INT & screwups by UMD that keeps this close.

Seth4Bucks's picture

Yeah, Miami didn't look all that great which sucks for our SoS. I still despise Miami, but can't they suck in years we don't play them? I know I was really looking forward to the Buck's series against them  when they first announced this years ago. They were an elite team when this was first scheduled . .  . but fast forward to this year and the top 10 tilt I pictured years ago isn't happening.

It's kind of sad that Toledo may be the toughest OOC game for us this year. But, we can't help that Miami isn't all that great.