Varying Opinions: A Look at Where Each Recruiting Outlet Ranks Ohio State's Commits

By Andrew Lind on January 31, 2017 at 2:15 pm
Chase Young is the No. 4 prospect overall in 247Sports' rankings.
75 Comments

Few things in life get the message board commentariat more fired up than recruiting rankings.

“[247Sports/ESPN/Rivals/Scout] hates us, so that's why he dropped to a four-star after he committed.”

“We didn't want him anyway. He had [character/grade/personal issues].”

“Recruiting rankings are meaningless. All-Pro linebacker Khalil Mack was only a two-star at Buffalo.”

The list goes on.

Recruiting rankings should be a pretty good indicator of future success. Yet when it comes to evaluating the nation's top high school talent, opinions vary considerably across the industry.

So how does one outlet have five-star defensive end Chase Young as the fourth-best player in the country, while another has him at No. 27?

Each recruiting service uses its own criteria, thus a consensus is rarely reached. Some sites put more emphasis on game film, while others give more attention to recruits who frequent their camps and combines.

As one parent of a five-star Ohio State commit put it, there are a lot of politics involved.

So how does each future Buckeye stack up across the industry? Find out below:

RECRUITS POSITION COMPOSITE 247SPORTS ESPN RIVALS SCOUT
JEFFREY OKUDAH CB 12 7 16 15
CHASE YOUNG DE 8 4 27 8 12
BARON BROWNING LB 11 10 26 9 23
SHAUN WADE CB 17 16 6 24 55
WYATT DAVIS OG 24 58 38 22 16
TREVON GRIMES WR 39 72 35 33 63
J.K. DOBBINS RB 43 43 44 66 67
JOSH MYERS OT 54 63 85 55 57
TATE MARTELL QB 57 92 127 39 27
ISAIAH PRYOR S 59 77 45 106 70
HASKELL GARRETT DT 70 74 102 119 47
BRENDON WHITE ATH 126 133 235 91 161
KENDALL SHEFFIELD CB (JUCO) 3 4 4 3 1
AMIR RIEP CB 183 433 139 243 99
JAYLEN HARRIS WR 184 165 296 198 137
MARCUS WILLIAMSON CB 195 162 259 NR 123
JERRON CAGE DT 236 170 138 NR NR
PETE WERNER LB 273 270 NR NR 266
ELIJAH GARDINER WR 1,217 1,032 NR NR NR
BLAKE HAUBEIL K 1,268 1,839 NR NR NR
75 Comments
View 75 Comments