Here are the winners, along with the runner-ups:

Offensive Player of the Year

Clemson QB Deshaun Watson – WINNER
Alabama RB Derrick Henry
Stanford RB Christian McCaffrey

Defensive Player of the Year

Notre Dame LB Jaylon Smith – WINNER
Duke DB Jeremy Cash 
Clemson DE Shaq Lawson

Play of the Year

Michigan State game-winning punt return vs. Michigan – WINNER
Georgia Tech game-winning FB return vs. Florida State
Arkansas fourth-down lateral vs. Ole Miss

Best Supporting Teammate

Clemson C Jay Guillermo – WINNER
Stanford OG Joshua Garnett
Notre Dame LB Joe Schmidt

Season-Defining Moment

Michigan State kicker Michael Geiger makes game-winner vs. Ohio State – WINNER
Clemson stops Notre Dame two-point conversion attempt
Oklahoma’s Baker Mayfield leads comeback win vs. Tennessee

Ultimate Herbie

Stanford RB Christian McCaffrey – WINNER
Oklahoma WR Sterling Shepard
Navy QB Keenan Reynolds