BlogPoll Ballot: Week 2

By Luke on September 7, 2010 at 5:00p
27 Comments

College football's opening week has come and gone, and what a week it was. While all of us reverse-weekend-only-college-football-vampires return to our tombs (see: day jobs) to rest up for the feast to come, we reminisce over what was: a goal line stop to secure a win; a Hail Mary to a 6'8 wide out to steal a victory; a battle of potential heavyweights that wasn't decided until the final moments; a head coach's debut go down in flames against a 3-9 FCS squad; and Giggity. While we once again provide a look into what we think the national landscape looks like, we remind you all that we're no where as awesome as Doug Lesmerises. Maybe we'll scrap the whole thing and go quasi-SOS based rankings but until then, let us know where we're wrong. We've got a little less than 24 hours to revise this puppy if necessary.

1 Alabama Crimson Tide 1-0. The Crimson Tide opened with lightweights San Jose State and rolled them accordingly to the tune of 48-3. Greg "Southeast Krenzel" McElroy was robot like in his efficiency completing 13 passes on 15 attempts for 218 yards and a touchdown. Freshman running back Eddie Lacy was also a revelation in helping pick up injured defending Heisman trophy winner Mark Ingram ruhsing 13 times for 111 yards including 2 TDs, even going as far as to outgain "better than Ingram" Trent Richardson and his 66 yards on 11 carries (though to be fair, Richardson tacked on 2 scores of his own). 'Bama won't have much time to rest on their laurels with the Baby Nittany Lions coming to town next week. Next up: #18 Penn State. --
2 Ohio State Buckeyes 1-0. Ohio State opened their season with a resounding 45- 7 victory over Marshall at home. HE ATE ME was hungry, Brian Rolle Brianrolle’d folks left and right, Ty Moeller was the Jesus at Star, TP 3.0 looked as purty as 11Dub 3.0, etc. You know what’s at stake next week too. Next up: #11 Miami. --
3 Boise State Broncos 1-0. As you probably already well know, outlasted VT 33-30 on Monday night. This one probably caused much debate and consternation around your office water cooler this morning (it most assuredly did at the 11Dub Road House). Was Virginia Tech a paper tiger or was Boise that good? I come correct from the camp that firmly believes we witnessed two of the top teams in the country do battle yesterday evening, and while yes there were moments of sloppiness, such is life when two relative juggernauts run head on into one another in Week 1 sans any kind of tangible pre-season. The Boise State players waxed endlessly about the great play of the Boise State d-line and should Boise’s secondary continue to mature as the games roll by, there’s no reason why the Broncos can’t play with the big boys on any given Saturday (or Monday as was the case this go around). Next up: BYE. Arrow_up 3
4 Texas Longhorns 1-0. Took it to Rice at Reliant Stadium (home of the Houston Texans; playoffs?) 34-17. This was a bizarre one that was tough to get a read on. One second the Texas secondary looked mortal; the next their defensive line looked superhuman. Texas quarterback Garrett Gilbert was hit or miss in his first ever collegiate start, though their much maligned running game looked to have come a long way from last season’s inconsistencies. The real kicker will be if the Texas offense can be consistent enough to keep them in the same breath as the likes of the rest of the Top 5 for an entire season. Next up: Wyoming. Arrow_up 3
5 Oklahoma Sooners 1-0. Outlasted a plucky Utah State side 31-24. After nearly blowing a 21-0 lead, Oklahoma held on late and was able to close things out at home in a rocky debut against Utah State. While the talent is still there for a national championship run, the Sooners will need more consistent play from quarterback Landry Jones who threw 2 picks during the evening. Running back DeMarco Murray quietly set him up for a potential dark horse Heisman run rushing 35 times for 218 yards and a pair of scores. The Sooners won’t have much time to pat themselves on the back for making it out alive as the Seminoles come to Norman next weekend. Next up: #20 Florida State. Arrow_down -2
6 Nebraska Cornhuskers 1-0. Took down Western Kentucky, 49-10. Freshman Taylor Martinez was the story in this one was ash the QB was 9/15 through the air for 136 yards while also rushing 7 times for 127 yards with 3 TDs. Returning starter at running back Roy Helu Jr., as well as the Blackshirt defense, led a decent amount to be desired (the defense gave up nearly 300 yards to the Hilltoppers). Nebraska faces a legitimate bowl opponent next weekend, however, with Robb Akey's Vandals coming to Memorial Stadium. Next up: Idaho. Arrow_up 3
7 Iowa Hawkeyes 1-0. The Hawkeyes rolled easily over Eastern Illinois, 37-7. For one brief moment, it looked like your entire way of life was in jeopardy. But worry not America: Ricky Stanzi bounced back from an early knee injury completing 18/23 passes for 229 yards in a touchdown in letting freedom ring. Adam Robinson helped with the cause rushing 24 times for 19 yards and a trio of TDs. Next up: Iowa State. Arrow_up 3
8 Florida Gators 1-0. Won on the scoreboard over Miami University 34-12. Florida needed classless repeated 4th down and long conversions to superficially inflate a relatively sad effort against Miami University. The Redhawks, for all their mistakes, vastly outplayed the Gators and opened up all kinds of skepticism to the entirety of Florida’s 2010 campaign. Tebow replacement John Brantley looked ill prepared and despite completing 17 of his 25 passes, barely cracked the century mark totaling just 113 yards. Track crossover Jeffrey Demps finished with 98 yards rushing a TD, mostly on a long 72 yard touchdown he’ll struggle to pull off against superior opposition.Next up: South Florida. Arrow_down -4
9 Virginia Tech Hokies 0-1. Lost to Boise State 30-33. As I mentioned above, I firmly believe that Virginia Tech is still amongst the best in the country. They needed to take a temporary hit for failing to close the deal, but this team should roll through the remainder of their ACC slate. The secondary remains their one glaring weakness, but as the season goes by, Foster/Beamer should course correct and get Virginia Tech back in the late season title mix.Next up: James Madison. Arrow_down -4
10 TCU Horned Frogs 1-0. Beat Oregon State 30-21. Quarterback Andy Dalton was back in the same sloppy form that helped lead TCU to a BCS bowl loss last January. Despite a pair of picks, the Horned Frogs (largely behind Dalton and tailback Ed Wesley's legs; 15/64 and 2 TDs and 17/134 and a TD respectively) held on and left Saturday evening with arguably the second best "resume rankers" worthy win of the weekend. Next up: Tennessee Tech. Arrow_up 3

11 Miami (Florida) Hurricanes 1-0. Beat Florida A&M 45-0. Jacory Harris was efficient and the 'Canes beat the FCS bottom dwelling Rattlers with ease. On the plus, the 'Canes got absolutely smoked in the battle of the bands. Next up: @ #2 Ohio State. Arrow_up 3
12 Wisconsin Badgers 1-0. Beat UNLV 41-24. The Badgers couldn't quite get that cover for all the gamble happy Badgers in Sin City, but they certainly more than held their own in dismantling the Rebels in former Montana coach Bobby Houck's debut. Next up: San Jose State. --
13 Oregon Ducks 1-0. Beat New Mexico 72-0. Has Oregon not skipped a beat with new QB Darron Thomas? With Jeremiah Masoli too busy losing to FCS schools, the Ducks exploded in what actually could have been much, much uglier. Next up: @ Tennessee. Arrow_up 2
14 Southern Cal Trojans 1-0. Beat Hawaii 49-36. USC looked absolutely hapless in yielding 692 yards to Hawaii's sexy, new pistol based attack. Lane Kiffin undoubtedly ripped Monte a new one for "making him look like an idiot in front of all those other mean kids at school". The Trojans none the less will continue to exempt tackling from their practices in an effort to avoid injury and likely keep the upset bug never too far from biting until they discover something resembling an identity defensively. Next up: Virginia. Arrow_down -6
15 Stanford Cardinal 1-0. Beat Sacramento State 52-17. How much can be gained from a victory over the best the Sacramento metro area has to offer? Harbaugh's bunch was impressive none the less in a thorough dismantling of the FCS side. Andrew Luck looked Heisman'tastic, though he'll have to do so against live bodies (such as in their Pac-10 opener this coming week) to stay on the radar. Next up: @ UCLA. Arrow_up 2
16 Auburn Tigers 1-0. Beat Arkansas State 52-26. CHIZIK LOVE CUPCAKE. The Fightin' Tigers/War Eagles did their thing against an inferior Sun Belt opponent, putting up a ton of yards and points in a relatively easy afternoon. They'll have to step their game up with the conference opener just days away. Next up: @ Mississippi State, Thursday night. --
17 Penn State Nittany Lions 1-0. The young Nittany Lions beat the older Youngstown State Penguins 44-14. True frosh QB Rob Bolden looked the part, but just how far along he is will be tested in a hurry with the upcoming gargantuan litmus test with Next up: @ #1 Alabama. Arrow_up 2
18 Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets 1-0. The Ramblin' Wreck downed South Carolina State with the utmost of ease 41-10. Josh Nesbitt looked anything but Heisman worthy with his arm but did his flexbone thing running for 130 yards and 3 TDs. Next up: @ Kansas. Arrow_up 2
19 Arkansas Razorbacks 1-0. Petrino's bunch routed Tennessee Tech 44-3. The Razorbacks actually managed to look impressive on both sides of the ball, but it will be a few weeks before we have an honest feel for whether or not this group is for real or not. Next up: @ Louisiana Monroe. Arrow_up 3
20 Florida State Seminoles 1-0. Beat Samford 59-6. Dadgum: life after Bobby Bowden opened in style as the 'Noles absolutely routed their athletically inferior FCS foes. Christian Ponder kept his Heisman hopes in the realm of possibilities in the W. Next up: @ #5 Oklahoma. Arrow_up 3
21 Utah Utes 1-0. Beat Pitt 27-24 (OT). The Utes looked legit in surviving a ferocious comeback attempt by Pittsburgh an captalized on an OT pick to open the season 1-0. Kyle Whittingham's bunch gets a far different offensive look with the spread tastic Rebels coming to Salt Lake City next weekend. Next up: UNLV. --
22 Brigham Young Cougars 1-0. Beat Washington 23-17. The Cougars forced Heisman candidate Jake Locker into poor decisions all evening long and quickly put a hamper on the UDub bandwagon with a big opening season win. The Cougars won't have much time to shift gears with the versatile option-based look the cadets of Air Force just on the horizon as they travel to Colorado Springs next Saturday. Next up: @ Air Force. --
23 Georgia Bulldogs 1-0. Beat Louisiana-Lafayette 55-7. New defensive coordinator Todd Grantham's 3-4 seemed to take in their opener against the Sun Belt Rajun Cajuns. QB Ginger Ninja successor Aaron Murray looked capable completing 17-of-26 passes for 160 yards, 3 TDs, and just 1 INT. Next up: @ South Carolina. --
24 West Virginia Mountaineers 1-0. Beat Coastal Carolina 31-0. By God WVU played Coastal Carolina like the banjo riff to "Deliverance" (and the defense didn't look half bad either). After a helacious weekend for the Big East, the conference's hopes may fall on the 'Neers. Next up: @ Marshall, Friday night. --
25 Michigan Wolverines 1-0. Beat Connecticut 30-10. Either Michigan is closer to making The Game mean what it should, or Connecticut is outstandingly mediocre. Either way, Denard Robinson looked like he'd discovered a Super Mario invincibility star in running (and throwing) all over what was supposed to be a decent Huskies D. The honeymoon may not last long with a stout test coming in South Bend next weekend. Next up: @ Notre Dame. --
SB Nation BlogPoll College Football Top 25 Rankings »
27 Comments

Comments

KenK's picture

Luke,

Close enough after week 1. Your 'up' and 'down' arrows make good sense to me, from what I saw and read, but I'll leave smarter others to weight in..

kk

Johnny Hooker: "He's not as tough as he thinks". Henry Gondorff: "Neither are we".

SouthBayBuckeye's picture

I'm glad someone else REALLY watched that Flor-duh game.

Banned from ATO since June 3rd 2PMish PST

BuckeyeSki's picture

They looked tuuuuurble and I loved every second of it

Banned from BlackShoeDiaries since 2008. Crime: Slander/Defamation of Character Judgement: Guilty

Is it Saturday Yet's picture

The two idiots on ESPNU picked Miami to win Saturday.

BuckeyeSki's picture

You sound suprised...the only time that tOSU is picked to win a game on eSECpn is when it would be ludacris to pick against them

The Junkyard Dog and Tito Santana can suck it *real names left out to protect the sportscasters involved*

Banned from BlackShoeDiaries since 2008. Crime: Slander/Defamation of Character Judgement: Guilty

BTwrestle04's picture

LMAO in regards to that BlogPoll ballot in the good Shizzy. Michigan ranked #12 and highest of the Big Ten teams. Iowa not even ranked? LSU and UNC ranked #4 and $6 respectively? Idiotic.

Joe Beale's picture

Lesmiris-what's-his-name had Michigan at 8.  Hard to figure what game he's playing but maybe he's had too much Nyquil or something.

RoweTrain's picture

I saw that as well.  There is one thing I noticed that makes his ballot crap (I guess there's more than one thing but this is the one that really had me head-scratching).  He says that he doesn't worry about preseason rankings, tradition, or the names of the players; he simply sees everyone as Team X (and Team Y I suppose so things don't get complicated).  What I dont understand is if Team X (The OSU) beats Team Y (Marshall) at home by a score of 45-7, how is that not more impressive than the other Team Y (Boise) beating the other Team X (VT) on the road 33-30 by his standards?  In reality Boise's win was "more impressive" then the Buckeyes win, but how would he know that if his plan is just to look at the games with teams being labeled variables for his stupid ass ballot?

Sorry for the rant but that just bothered me.  Go Bucks!!

RoweTrain's picture

He also adds that he doesn't use the variable method 100 percent of the time, so I guess he means he doesn't really do that.

Luke's picture

HATERS GONNA HATE. (thanks)

Poe McKnoe's picture

In closing, suck it Miami.  The football team, the school, and their incompetent fan base.

BTwrestle04's picture

Stoneburner via twitter: "Were gonna be so ready for this game"

We can only hope.

Nik's picture

is it just me, or is the "Giggity" link not working for anyone else?  I wanna know what that links to, lol

 

EDIT: figured it out, there was an extra http://  I just copied link location, and pasted it in a browser and took that out and it worked... Great pic, lol

Bucksfan's picture

Very few struggles against cupcakes this year.  Pretty impressive week one for BCS conference schools against weak non-conference opponents with drubbing after drubbing.  Much better than having to rely on a 2-point interception, 2 blocked field goals (Iowa), and a host of struggles against directional Michigan schools like last year.  This is setting up to be one monster in-conference year for everyone.

Go Bucks!

NW Buckeye's picture

While I will agree that Boise deserves to be in the top 10, I don't buy into the idea that we witnessed two of the best teams in the country.  VT gave that game away.  Ineffective clock management on their possession before the last Boise score lost the game.  The Q did not wind down the play clock, players stepped out of bounds, they threw an incomplete pass before they punted.  I watched my tivo replay, and VT could have run another 1:30 off the clock with effective clock management.  That would have given Boise the ball with 17 seconds left.  If the punter had been given instructions to coffin corner the kick Boise would not have had a short field for their last drive.  End of game.  Also, VT's record against ranked teams is the worst in the country - 0 fer!  Any other top ten team would have won that game with effective clock management in the last 5 minutes of play.  So, how can you justify VT in the top 10?  I just don't buy into your reasoning. 

Welcome to Buckeye City's picture

VT is 1-26 ALL TIME vs. Top 5 teams.  They played absolutely horrible in the 1st quarter and gave Boise a large enough of a lead (17-0) that they made it damn near impossible to come back from and they almost did anyway.  Boise's first 17 points weren't really earned.  VT had a turnover on a bad snap deep in their territory, #2 who blocked the punt came off the edge completely unaccounted for and went untouched.  Hell, even Florida could've put up 17 points in the first quarter against VT on Monday even with their inept offense.

What happens if/when Boise struggles against a weak WAC opponent?  Do they fall in the polls out of #3 when all the big boys are playing 4-5 ranked teams throughout the season?  A spot in the MNC should be earned throughout the season, not by winning ONE game in early September when teams haven't had a few weeks to gel and establish an identity.

To say Boise is #3 at this point in the season is crazy if you ask me.

What Would Woody Do?

Matt's picture

out of curiosity -- who was the 1 in th 1-26?

tampa buckeye's picture

to not have a playoff in college football is crazy if you ask anyone

Welcome to Buckeye City's picture

You beat me to it, but here are some additional items of note I came across:

1.  This from eSECpn: No. 10 Virginia Tech enters its game against No. 3 Boise State with an all-time record of 1-25 vs teams ranked in the top 5 of the AP poll (beat No. 2 Miami in 2003). Even worse, the Hokies are 0-21 in such games away from Blacksburg, VA. This is the first meeting between the two schools.

Miami was ranked #2 at the time, and finished #5.  VT is nowhere to be seen in the final 2003 poll after finishing with an 8-5 record after the usual strong start to season, although three teams from the great state of Ohio made the final top 25.

2. VT is 1-18 all-time verse top 5 teams under Beamer.

3. The ACC has now lost 29 consecutive games vs. Top 5 teams, and let's sure as hell hope that number hits 30 this Saturday
 

What Would Woody Do?

jonnyreb02's picture

Isn't it Lesmeris that has that has a wierd voting method?  I remember reading a blog post last year by an AP voter who votes based on quality wins for the week, and quality of play or something like that.  It may be someone else, but that may help with his d-bag listing.  I do think its ridiculous that Boise St. has 8 first place votes, but given they are the only top 10 team to play another ranked team, that should give them some merit.  (BTW I also think it's ridiculous that Alabama has so many and OSU so few).   Regardless of what happens if OSU wins out, they are in.  I really don't care about OSU's opponent b/c at this point I think we would pretty soundly win (10-14 pts barring special teams errors on our part).  I'd much rather see OSU play a name (Alabama, Oklahoma, etc.) and hoist the crystal ball rather than Boise-  which would be a lose lose situation.  Bottom line, we need to win out and that continues this week.

JakeBuckeye's picture

I'm the type of guy who thinks that the previous year's national champion should be number one in the polls until they lose.

Just how I feel personally.

Welcome to Buckeye City's picture

Even if that team loses 15+ starters and several key players on the depth chart to the draft or maxed out eligibility? 

What Would Woody Do?

JakeBuckeye's picture

"Denard> Pryor. Not even being biased, Pryor is overrated."

-Coincidentally coming from a Michigan fan.

Cory's picture

florida will be mediocre this season