How would you rank them 1-4? Which OSU team would win, 2006 vs 2022? Would this UM team beat 2006 or not?
If we were 100% healthy, I'd take 2022 OSU - but without seeing all phases clicking together I give the overall nod to 2006 OSU. Tough call on UM, but slight edge to 2006 as they weren't so one dimensional.
2006 OSU Offense: Smith, Pittman/Beanie, Ginn/Gonzalez
2022 OSU Offense: Stroud/RB committee/WRU
2006 OSU Defense: Laurinaitis/Freeman/Gholston/Jenkins
2022 OSU Defense: Eichenberg/Chambers/Ransom/Hickman
2006 UM Offense: Henne/Hart/Manningham
2022 UM Offense: McCarthy/Corum/Bell
2006 UM Defense: Harris/Hall/Woodley
2022 UM Defense: Colson/Barrett/Jenkins