Preview: #9 Ohio State at Penn State

By Kyle Rowland on October 26, 2012 at 1:00p
From walk-on to stardom.
Ohio State Buckeyes #9 Ohio State 8-0, 4-0 Big Ten Roster | Schedule 5:30 PM ET - ESPN —— Beaver Stadium State College, PA Penn State Nittany Lions Penn State 5-2, 3-0 Big Ten Roster | Schedule

Dating to 1993, when Penn State joined the Big Ten, the Ohio State-Penn State game has morphed into one of the conference’s premier games. The series' roots began in 1912, when Penn State beat Ohio State, 37-0. The Buckeyes actually quit that afternoon, walking off the field in the fourth quarter after a disputed illegal blocking call.

The two teams wouldn’t meet again till 1956.

In the 27 contests – Ohio State leads 14-13 – between the two schools, the nation’s No. 1-ranked team has been involved four times. On seven occasions, both schools were ranked in the Top 10.

Another creation in 1993 was ESPN College GameDay taking its show on the road. Ohio State-Penn State ranks behind only Florida-Florida State as the most attended game by the traveling college football preview show.

When the Nittany Lions joined the Big Ten, the game became one of the most anticipated matchups on the schedule for Ohio State fans, and rightly so. Ohio State is fifth all-time in wins and Penn State is sixth (with vacated games counting as wins).

Saturday night will usher in a new era of Ohio State and Penn State, and possibly be the first in a legendary matchup between Urban Meyer and Bill O’Brien. Revered coaches have defined the game – first Woody Hayes and Joe Paterno and later Jim Tressel and Paterno.

In a season where Ohio State and Penn State are banned from the Big Ten championship game, the two heavyweights sit at the top of the Leaders Division undefeated.

On Saturday night, that tie will be broken.


Despite arguably the biggest scandal in the history of intercollegiate athletics hovering over the program, the 2012 Penn State Nittany Lions have persevered. Starting the season 0-2, Penn State has rattled off five consecutive convincing victories.

They may not be the best team in the country, but they might be the most confident. O’Brien has instilled a level of self-assurance that has few rivals. Perhaps the single biggest contributing factor to Penn State’s resurgence has been the development of Matt McGloin at quarterback.

“When you have a new staff, you have a couple of things happen early in the year, but this is still Penn State,” Meyer said. “Make no mistake about it, Penn State was undefeated at this time last year. As a result, when you’re undefeated, you’ve got very, very good football players. I mean, very good.”

The NASCAR offense, as Penn State calls it, is fast-paced, as expected. And McGloin has taken a liking to it. In the Nittany Lions’ losses to Ohio and Virginia, McGloin didn’t complete more than 56 percent of his passes and threw four touchdowns and an interception. Since then, he’s completing more than 65 percent of his passes and has thrown 10 touchdowns and just one pick. McGloin has 1,788 passing yards, 14 touchdowns and two interceptions on the season. The passing yardage and touchdown totals are already career highs.

“I think he’s the most efficient passer we’ll see all season,” Ohio State co-defensive coordinator Everett Withers said. “He does a nice job of finding the open man. He knows exactly where he wants to go with the football, but if it’s not there he does a good job going through his progressions.”

But it hasn’t been all McGloin on offense. Bill Belton, a former wide receiver, has replaced Silas Redd at running back. Redd, you may recall, was one of 13 Penn Staters to hitch up the wagons and abandon State College. In his first significant action since the Ohio game, Belton rushed for 103 yards and three touchdowns last week at Iowa. In his absence, fullback Zach Zwiniak had consecutive 100-yard rushing games. The team has gained over 1,000 yards on the season in seven games and scored 12 rushing touchdowns.

At wide receiver, Allen Robinson has developed into McGloin’s favorite target. Robinson has 563 receiving yards and eight touchdowns this season. He’s been a big part in why McGloin leads the Big Ten with 255 passing yards per game.

Few positions in the country are as thin as Ohio State’s linebackers. And Penn State has just the ingredient to exploit the Buckeyes’ problem: tight ends. Penn State’s quartet of tight ends – yes, four – have an NCAA-best 51 receptions this season.

“We like to put the tight ends in a good position to make plays,” O’Brien said.

When you play from ahead, as Penn State has done in nearly every game, it’s much easier to win a game. The Nittany Lions have outscored opponents 66-0 in the first quarter this season and 110-23 in the first half. Ohio State, meanwhile, has been outscored, 56-51, by opponents in the opening quarter.

McGloin is the most widely known player on the team, but linebacker Michael Mauti is the heart and soul. It was Mauti who stood in front of the media with his team behind him and delivered a stirring speech in the days after the NCAA decimated the Penn State football program.

That leadership has carried onto the field, where Mauti leads the team with 64 tackles, including 3.5 for loss. Twice he’s had 12-tackle games. He also has 2.5 sacks.

“His dad and brothers are Nittany Lions,” Meyer said. “I recruited him hard at Florida. Loved him as a high school athlete. He’s a tough guy. He’s a leader. Love his family. He’s playing his tail off after his knee injury.”

Fellow linebacker Gerald Hodges is also a brute, tallying 55 tackles on the season.

Mauti and Hodges have each been named as semifinalists for the Butkus Award. They have three Big Ten defensive player of the week awards between them and have wreaked havoc on opponents week in and week out.

“We’re constantly motivating each other,” Mauti said. “We’ve been competing against each other for four or five years now. It’s been a fun relationship. As far as on the field, we’re constantly competing.”

Defensive lineman Jordan Hill adds to the defensive prowess by clogging running lines and disrupting the quarterback.

Then there is special teams. Placekicker Sam Ficken became a national story in Week 2 when he missed four field goals in a loss at Virginia. Ficken has only made four of 11 field goal attempts all season. That has led O’Brien to go for it on fourth 23 times. Penn State has converted on 14. That looseness and nothing-too-lose attitude has rubbed off on the Nittany Lions.

It’s also made O’Brien a leading candidate to win national coach of the year honors.

Buckeye Breakdown

The obvious story surrounding the Buckeyes is the health of Braxton Miller. Last Saturday afternoon not many would have expected him to play this weekend, let alone start. But Miller is near 100 percent, with a sore neck the only adverse effect from a gruesome near horse-collar tackle.

The offense – and the team to a large extent – has gone as far as Miller has taken it. If it’s the same old Braxton, as he says it will be, Ohio State should have an advantage. But any tentativeness could prove problematic.

Through eight games, it's looked like the myriad injuries Miller has sustained have added up and taken a toll on the sophomore quarterback. On Saturday, he’ll be introduced to Mauti and Hodges, and they won’t be welcoming hosts.

Braxton Miller will have his running shoes.

Another one of Ohio State’s playmakers – Corey Brown – was hobbled last week with a head injury. He’s expected to play, and Ohio State will need him. Even with how well Carlos Hyde has played, the Buckeyes will likely need good performances out of their skill players to offset the effectiveness of Penn State’s monster front seven. It’s the secondary that’s the weak spot of the defense.

Ohio State’s linebackers will factor largely into the game, but it’s the defensive line that could be the difference on that side of the ball. Penn State’s hurry-up offense will be tough to defend. McGloin has only been sacked eight times in seven games, and the Buckeyes haven’t exactly gotten after the quarterback this season. There have been zero sacks on pass plays the past two weeks.

Any pressure at all from John Simon, Johnathan Hankins, Nathan Williams could free up the linebackers. Not facing much pressure for seven games, McGloin could be forced into making bad decisions.

Ohio State’s secondary is also better than any unit Penn State has gone against this season. McGloin has two interceptions in 255 attempts on the season. But he also hasn’t gone against Bradley Roby. It’s not just him, though. Travis Howard and the safeties also provide solid coverage for the Buckeyes. The thing that sticks out about them is their physicality.

The special teams play of the Buckeyes could also be a gamechanger. Ficken’s miscues are well documented. But something that has flown under the radar is Ohio State’s propensity to block kicks. Six have been deflected so far. It’s an area of emphasis by Meyer, who has turned into the current generation’s Frank Beamer when it comes to special teams.

Meyer says you win a game 90 percent of the time when you block a kick. In a close game on Saturday, a special teams miscue could loom much larger than a 50-yard touchdown pass.

How It Plays Out

Before the season started, and even weeks ago, no one thought this game would be close. But as Saturday night in Happy Valley looms, there is a very real possibility that Ohio State will return to Columbus with its unblemished record gone.

Ohio State’s trend this season, other than inconsistency, is playing to the level of its opponents. At this point of the season, it doesn’t look like either team is considerably better than the other, which points to a good game.

Blocked kicks have been mentioned already, but the special teams unit that is likely to have the biggest impact on the game is Ohio State’s kickoff coverage group. Kicker Drew Basil has done an outstanding job all season of pinning teams inside the 20. When you have two evenly matched teams, field position is magnified.

Ultimately, the quarterbacks will decide this game. If Miller is as effective as he’s been all season, Penn State will have a tough time winning. If he’s off and McGloin stars, the Buckeyes will struggle to come out on top.

The past two trips the Buckeyes have made to State College have had similar intrigue surrounding them. In 2007, Ohio State was undefeated and ranked No. 1 in the country. Penn State was primed for the upset, but Ohio State left Beaver Stadium with a 37-17 win, dominating every aspect of the game. Two years later, Rose Bowl hopes were on the line. A close game was expected, and Ohio State won, 24-7. That is a combined score of 61-24 the Buckeyes have managed to win by in one of the nation’s most hostile environments.

The margin will be smaller this time around, but the result won’t differ.

Ohio State 27, Penn State 24


Comments Show All Comments

Boxley's picture

Hope you are right. I was laughed at two weeks ago when I said we should rest Braxton and give Kenny more live action. Last week made me look pretty smart. I wish kenny had more game reps under his belt as he p[oses different problems for PSU and if we swtched back and forth I think PSU would not know what to do.
But, i guess we will see in the next 28-32 hours .

"...the man who really counts in the world is the doer, not the mere critic-the man who actually does the work, even if roughly and imperfectly, not the man who only talks or writes about how it ought to be done." President T. Roosevelt

Alhan's picture

KG has impressed me every time he has had to come in and play. I would be comfortable with them rotating the two in order to create the confusion you seek even with his limited reps.

As much fun as close games can be, I would prefer a blowout in this case. The suspense is killing me!

"Nom nom nom" - Brady Hoke

jthiel09's picture

Great preview and knowing how we have played this year I can only imagine this going down to the wire.


Run_Fido_Run's picture

Nice preview, Kyle.
After reading this article on Zach Boren in the CD this morning, I'm skewing optimistic on the Buckeyes defense. This is Boren's third game at Mike and he's starting to hit his stride there. With Boren "playing downhill," he makes their run defense much better. He compliments the other LBs, freeing up Shazier to do his thing, and taking pressure off Joshua Perry (who will need to be good in coverage in this game). Boren's activity in run support probably also helps get both Spence and Williams together on the field more often, with Simon moving inside, bolstering the pass rush.
I'm feeling the defense will come to play in this one. If the Buckeyes OL plays well and/or Braxton is close to 100-percent, that'll be ball game . . .   

O-H Kee Pa's picture

From your keyboard to God's ears.

DoctorSJ's picture

I think it is obvious that Boren is aiding on D - Shazier led the team in tackles last week - hence proving your point above. I look for this game to not be as close as some are projecting just based on the FACT that PSU has played NO ONE!

cinserious's picture

looks like McGroin might get some looks by NFL teams in the draft this yr. "Mauti and Hodges have each been named as semifinalists for the Butkus Award".---- This sytatement shows that this yr, PSU is linebacker-U.

One day I will valiantly become a political prisoner of 11W jail.

Doc's picture

Nice right up Kyle.  I sure hope you are right.  I'm confident the Buckeyes will be pumped and ready to play.  Here's hoping to be 9-0 come Saturday night!

CJDPHoS Member

The Official DDS of 11W

osu07asu10's picture

I'm going to stick with my prediction from earlier in the week. I think this is the game where Penn State's mass exodus of players is finally exposed. I think O'Brien is doing a fantastic job with what he has and he will continue to do so. 
However, I do not think O'Brien and staff are better than our coaching staff and I certainly do not think their roster is comparable to ours in both talent or depth, I will give them the experience factor.

By no means is this going to be an easy victory. It is going to be a B1G slugfest, but I see the buckeyes coming out firing and in the end, it won't be that close on the scoreboard.
tOSU 38 psu 20

CJDPHoS Board of Directors // Best friends with Homey Hache

The 0 is silent.

DoctorSJ's picture

^^^^^^^THIS! This is my thinking as well.

AirForceNUT's picture

Great preview! If Braxton plays like he did vs the TTUN last year and MSU and Neb this year, I think it'll be tough for PSU to beat up.  Lets hope OSU responds well the pressure of HV.

ziplock007's picture

Penn State uses the Tight Ends more than any other team in the nation.
The best medicine to fight Tight Ends: Linebackers.
Ohio State's top three fullbacks: Ryan Shazier (awesome), the True Freshman Perry (ooh...), a Fullback (really?).  Followed by Storm Klein (uncomfortable silence), and ??? (Buehler? Buehler?)
Yeah, totally optimistic the OSU D dominates tomorrow.

beserkr29's picture

No one's expecting domination from this year's version of the defense.  It's young, banged up, not as talented as previous years (at least at the linebacker position), and is learning a new system.  All most want to see is steady improvement.  Purdue was a nice start in that direction.

bodast67's picture

Yeah, totally optimistic the OSU D dominates tomorrow.

          Ummm...sarcasm ?




     " I hope when I die, I die laughing"...                

BME_Buckeye's picture

Does anyone know if we've ever faced Penn State undefeated and lost in our 27 meetings? Just curious...

Look closely, because the closer you think you are, the less you will actually see.


Maestro's picture

Hmmm, '05 was a one-loss team going in after the non-catch by Limas Sweed.

vacuuming sucks

osu07asu10's picture

Doesn't look like we've ever lost when undefeated. We played them as the #1 ranked team in 2006 and 2007 and won both contests. We also played them undefeated in 2002 ranked #4 at the time and also scored a victory.

The 2005 loss looks like our worst. With the Pryor loss in 08 being the second worst, but we were carrying losses heading into those games.

CJDPHoS Board of Directors // Best friends with Homey Hache

The 0 is silent.

osu07asu10's picture

@BME...not sure about undefeated but they ruined any chance we had to play for the national championship in 05. 

CJDPHoS Board of Directors // Best friends with Homey Hache

The 0 is silent.

BME_Buckeye's picture

That game gives me nightmares every time I think about it... This will change how I write my post game story. For my sake I hope we win... Thanks. 

Look closely, because the closer you think you are, the less you will actually see.


stantmann's picture

OSU will either win big, or lose a squeaker. Just look at the last bunch of games between these two teams. PSU wins a close game because of OSU turnovers, or OSU doesn't turn the ball over and wins in a blowout. Here are the last handful of games: PSU 20-14, OSU 38-14, OSU 24-7, PSU 13-6, OSU 37-17, OSU 28-6, PSU 17-10, OSU 21-10, and there are a few others, Also, OSU dominates the series since PSU joined the B1G - 12 games for OSU, 7 for PSU.  This game will not be close OSU 45 - PSU 13.

sir rickithda3rd's picture

i have faith in urbs. unfortunately i dont see braxton being able to stay healthy all game. psu is very dirty and i think they will hurt him on purpose

mark may wins douchebag of the year... again

Maestro's picture

Maybe things will just all come together this week.  Defense has finally had a little bit of stability with the line up for a few weeks.  Passing game has showed flashes.  Time for the offense, defense and special teams to all have a good week in the same game.

vacuuming sucks

timdogdad's picture

lets get this one tomorrow because we'll be basking in the glow of 10-0 (we can't lose to illinois can we?)  for 3 weeks until kickoff in madison.   win tomorrow or not it will look bad if we don't beat illinois easily. psu beat them  35-7 and scum 45-0.   so lets get to 10-0 and and 1. shut up the urine bomb throwers(u stay classy university park) and 2.  beat a team easily that we should beat easily.

Dougger's picture

@tim. not thinking about illinois or anybody but State Penn. We definitely got what it takes to win the game.
I'm sorry but anytime somebody says "in HV" (referring to Happy Valley) my mind processes it as "HIV".. so everyone stop writing that. just kidding. GO BUCKS

I like football

jestertcf's picture

I think it's going to be an ulcer inducing game, but we end up with the W.

~Because we couldn't go for three~

Matthew's picture

From walk-on to "stardom"?
On what planet is Matt McGloin a star? 95 out of 100 people probably couldn't tell you who he is outside of Columbus and Happy Valley.

Class of 2010

BuckeyeBoyer85's picture

The play of both the lines has been steady enough to keep us in every game. We have controlled the line of scrimmage at key points in every game. I've seen more consistency from the O-Line than their defensive counterparts, but we all know the talent is there for Vrabel's unit. I think winning at the point of attack is crucial for a young team that is progressing it's skills each week. I believe the effort of the lines will win tomorrow's game for the Buckeyes.

Wayne Woodrow Hayes