Look if Aikman had Zero rings he's no HOF'er.... but he has 3 rings so he's in.
If McNabb had 3 rings (forget the statistical comparisons) then he is in the HOF... but he has ZERO!!!!... he is NOT a HOF'er.
Lot's of QB's have better numbers than Aikman but they are not HOF'ers. Heck, 80% of the average to below average QB's playing today will end their careers with better numbers.