Completely disagree. Replay fixes errors. Bad errors.
What we had in the Fiesta Bowl was not 'replay'. It was a replay official (or officials) using their power to reverse a perfectly good call on the field, without the irrefutable evidence that gave them cause to reverse the call.
Anyone notice how quickly Herbstreit called it a fumble and a touchdown on the first replay? Then the 'expert' weighed in, and said "well in slow motion it looks like a fumble, but in regular speed it looks like he didn't have possession." Then Herbstreit essentially says... "well yeah I guess you're right". End of story.
That official, whatever his name was, went against the Buckeyes every time. It could be coincidence. But the fact is, you cannot reverse a call on the field without IRREFUTABLE evidence, and nobody even mentioned that during the pause for the replay.
I was astounded... literally speechless when they reversed that call.