To me it is easily Greg Frey. One play. One MUST HAVE clutch 19-yard completion.
This from 11W on The Game in 1987 (Earle’s last Game).
In the 4th quarter, the two teams traded punts but OSU finally got the upper hand midway through the quarter when they drove 77 yards to set up a 26-yard FG by Frantz to put Ohio State ahead 23-20. During the drive, Tupa was momentarily dazed by a hit from a UM defender, and he had to leave the game with OSU facing a 3rd and 9. But backup QB Greg Frey came in and delivered a 19-yard completion to Workman to get the first down. After that, they moved in for the winning field goal.