Haskins may throw a little harder from the pocket. Has good size and arm talent and somewhat mobile.
Martell is elusive and can run the option, but his arm talent is better than Barrett just not Haskins or Burrow from what I have seen albeit limited.
Burrow has the size, arm talent, accuracy and can run the option. He is a stronger armed Alex Smith that is also not scared to take a chance throwing the deep ball. Just watching that kid make his playoff run in highschool showed he has that IT factor too when the game is on the line.
Haskins had comp% in the high 50% low 60% in highschool and his SR year his team went 5-5. Not sure of the competition in Maryland highschool football. Threw 22 TDs as a JR can't find his SR numbers.
Martell played for one of the toughest highschools in America and never lost.
Burrow played in Southern Ohio where people feel the football is not as good but he dominated his competition, threw 47 TDs as a Soph and Jr then 63 and only 2 ints as a SR and had COMP% of 62% 71% and 72%. I would wager Southern Ohio football is not far off from Maryland football in highschool.
Haskins has the talent, and that was where his star rankings came from, T-shirts and drills on camp visits. Burrows and Martell came from game film and play on the field. Martell was the Gatorade player of the year for a reason.
Now I feel Haskins has all the talent in the world and if he won the starting job I would be excited I think he could be a great one!
But if Burrow won, I think some people would question it which I don't understand why, only that it has to do with Star rankings.
However our team is set at QB, we have three QBs I feel could easily lead this team to greatness to be honest I would be happy with any one of the three winning the job.