We'll probably have a few guys that I'd love to swap with Rutgers
The off season bites !!
It's not a rivalry .............. it's a wreckoning.
Seattle Sounders 2019 MLS Champions
Can we swap Ash for Shiano please?
Shitcan Schiano, Grinch, Davis, and T. Johnson. Larry Johnson is a proven commodity; he should be retained. The rest can go coach D3 teams.
"I say let us give them all they want; not a word of argument, not a sign of let up, no cave in till we are whipped or they are."
-William Tecumseh Sherman
Firing the whole defensive staff would be a disaster. Start with Schiano and Davis, work from there
"The hate of men will pass, and dictators die, and the power they took from the people will return to the people. And so long as men die, liberty will never perish" - Charlie Chaplin
Is surrendering 600 yards and 51 points to Maryland not considered a disaster?
Just minor adjustments needed, nothing to see here!!! +1 QA
Grinch, to me, is the worst of the staff. His safeties have actually regressed throughout 2018. They were bad in September and they're horrible in November. I saw Fuller and White square up more than once today and whiff. His entire room is a clinic on how not to tackle, which is the most fundamental element of playing defense, and they take abysmal angles. They get lost in coverage and the get blown out of the hole. The linebackers take a beating on here, as well they should, but the safeties are the most embarrassing unit on that side of the ball, and Grinch is getting paid 800k to oversee that shit show.
When I die, sprinkle my ashes over the 70's
Why can’t it be both? Back 7 as a whole is awful. Only 1 player will make an nfl roster right now (Fuller) and that’s as a 3rd to 5th round pick.
"Great moments are born from great opportunities." - Herb Brooks
Sheffield’s getting drafted on his 40 time alone. And it’s too early to judge Wade.
His speed was not evident at all this whole season.
To clarify, I acknowledge Okudah and Wade as well as White may develop into NFL talent. sheffield might get drafted but I bet he doesn’t make it. If Doran Grant can’t make a roster, Sheffield has no shot. And it’s not like he plays special teams.
If that is the case bench him NOW! We don't want to get him hurt and he might be forced to stay.
I just want to know, why the fuck can people not tackle on our defense? Since Urban has come here, our defense has really struggled with just tackling. It got an improvement I think when Ash was here 2nd year or so and for a couple years it seemed reasonable. But its back to being absolutely shit at tackling again. This is so frustrating to watch.
Since Urban has been here? Stop.
I am not saying he is the direct correlation at all. Just after watching Tressel teams, I don't recall tackling issues being this prolific. There have also been changes in the rules regarding how you can tackle and I understand there have been adjustments in general in regard to this. But the big bookmark for me left scratching my head coincides with him becoming the head coach. Not causation but correlation.
I know it's just an expression, but LJ is not a "commodity" he's at the top of his craft. Lucky to have him here. As a bonus, he seems happy where he is, and is not shopping himself around.
True. If the rumors of Urban retiring are true, you can bet Larry Johnson will leave also.
I'm good with this. Hopefully Schiano gets a head coach offer somewhere and takes it. Doubtful, but weirder shit has happened
I think Schiano takes the Purdue job after Brohm selects his next destination.
Why would Purdue hire Schiano? He's a defensive coach whose unit was just torched by Brohm's team, and he's having an embarrassing year of epic proportions by Ohio State defensive coordinator standards. Brohm has recruited players for two years to fit a particular offense, which is Purdue's thing. Whenever they've been solid it's been predicated on good offense, so they're going to look for a climber and an innovator on that side of the ball. I'm not saying you're wrong about a Schiano hire, but I don't see it there.
I hope he is right with Schiano to Purdue, but I dont see it happening either. I'm not sure if Schiano will get a offer, just hopeful. If he doesnt then we are stuck with him more then likely. I dont see Urban firing him
If only there was a New Jersey based college that might have a head coaching position opening soon.
If there was one out there.
I was just flinging poop against the wall for conversation's sake. I don't have any reason to think he would want to go to Purdue or that Purdue would want him other than the "known name" factor that plays into coaching hires. Personally I think it would be cool if Brohm stayed long term and made Purdue a consistently good team again. Not at all likely, but it would be something different in this day and age.
Going back to Rutgers might sound logical at first, but does anyone know if Schiano has any real desire to go back to Piscataway? It seems like he has been intent on coaching elsewhere since he left there.
He went to Tampa, then Columbus. 2 jobs in 7 years of coaching is pretty stable.
He wants to be a HC again and his flirtation with UT was an example of that. As terrible as they’ve been lately it’s still a great job and Rutgers wasn’t an option at the time. He was born and raised in NJ and his first coaching job was in NJ. Also his kids are in the dcm area aren’t they?
I don't think it matters...UFM will shitcan this guy either way.
Do you guys realize he made the comment before the first game and said "this might be the best defense every at OSU
Those who stir the shit pot should have to lick the spoon.
I remember that
A Schiano- Ash trade makes a lot of sense
Seems like we'd have a lot of cooks in the secondary kitchen. Chris Ash as Co DC and was our safeties coach in 14-15. Grinch is a Co DC and safeties coach, and Taver Johnson as DB coach. But if he brings back his rugby tackling then I'm all for it. Tackling has been not as good under Schiano.
Id be fine with a new DC, a new LB coach, and a new OL coach. There needs to be a makeover on the coaching staff after this season.
Rugby tackling hasn't gone anywhere...
If you laugh, you think, and you cry, that's a full day. That's a heck of a day. You do that seven days a week, you're going to have something special.
When Brendan White went for McFarlands ankles on that long TD today, that wasn't Rugby style. Just one example I can think of. I'm used to seeing that shit from Oklahoma, but not us.
It was a catch.
Press the hip -> Cheek to cheek -> Wrap and roll -> SWEEP THE ANKLE
You may have got me this time...
As a rugby player I can confidently state that no one out there is rugby tackling.
Fighting the good fight in SEC country. "Our honor defend"
To make a rugby tackle, don't actually have to, you know, make a tackle?
I don't think they are teaching it now. Ash and the staff that was there under him is now mostly gone. I've been seeing a lot of head across the body tackling this year and funny thing is they are getting trucked. It was one of the first things I noticed at the beginning of this year. Guys putting their heads down not keeping them up, and not putting their heads behind the player's hips.
One of the real strength of rugby tackling (besides less injuries) is that is is safe to practice. I don't think they are tackling that way anymore. If they are still teaching rugby tackling then some players need to be benched
Taver Johnson and Alex Grinch aren't going anywhere so you can scratch that idea.
I can live with that. Schiano and Davis are absolute disgraces, though. I cant stomach another year of them.
I think Schiano will be offered a HC position somewhere. Davis has to go!!! +1 Kangarooman
At least for 1 more year to complete Urbans 2 year plan at OSU. +1Buckslan
Is it often a guy goes back to his old position after getting fired? I feel like if he does come back to OSU he’s giving up being a head coach unless he’s given an option whenever urban moves on.
Won't be Urban's decision to make as he's gone after this year.
Surprised there hasn't been a thread about Urban's migraine flareups during the Maryland game
Here's an article with some gifs in case you missed it
He is a mess, that is evident
I've long said Urban's gone after this year. Family is hugely important to Urban and those health issues have got to be weighing in and adding stress to an already stressful year, stepping away from the coaching spotlight allows him to focus on his health and prepare for that nice ESPN gig down the line.
You spew a lot of crap though so who’s to say
and yet for someone that spews a lot of crap, a lot of it sure does seem to come true, doesn't it?
No actually it doesn’t. I’m still patiently waiting for your video breakdown from when you blamed Pryor for pass interference.
You said you’d do that and nothing came of it so who’s to say this isn’t more of you running your mouth of bull crap?
Lmfao I never said I would do it, I said "Do you want a fucking video breakdown?"
Your meds must need increased as you're imagining shit again.
Link the thread
Contrary to popular belief, I don't bookmark every thread I post in. You have the ability to find the thread just as well as I do.
You’re right, it was lazy of me to expect you to uncover your own crap.
Luckily I found it
Lmfao I never said I would do it, I said "Do you want a fucking video breakdown?"
Thats not even close to how that went down.
The cyst is not caused by stress, guys.
The most "loud mouth, disrespect" poster on 11W.
And it’s drainable if there’s enough discomfort
But stress causes the headaches
Alright, alright. Calm down everyone. Watch this, it always makes me feel better. https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://m.youtube.c...
Folks. Meyer has been a mess. I know he is battling some issues with the cyst. But the crumbling on the sidelines, the facial expressions in interviews, his actions on the sideline, he is a mess right now. Get the cyst drained again, make some coaching adjustments, come back on fire next year. The guy has been put through the wringer this year, just get through two more games then regroup.
I don’t think he is done yet. I heard him speak down in Columbus, pre Zach Smith mess, the dude was on point and had that fire/swagger. This Zach Smith crap took its toll. He will regroup, make some coaching changes and be good to go.
When he got suspended I told a friend of mine, welp, looks Urban is gone after this year. The president should have fired him or did nothing, a suspension just made the university look dumb, and it pissed Meyer off as the university didn't have his back. This season has been a mess, Urban is a mess, and I think all the wincing and odd behavior, as well as his general apathy he shows toward the team in interviews are his way of setting up an exit for health reasons again.
Replace Schiono and Davis with Ash and Marcus Freeman at UC.
That would give OSU three different co-DCs because I doubt Freeman or Ash accept any position less than that to come back to OSU.
Never said it had to make sense.
No, because I feel like OSU already has too many cooks in the kitchen in the secondary this season with Schiano, Grinch and Johnson. OSU next defensive hire should probably be focused on the LBs/front-7.
Posted this in another thread. When Rutgers hired Ash, he had a clause in his original contract that if Rutgers received a bowl ban (and or scholarships) from last coaching staff that he would receive an extention.
Well, they did and had to extend him. He will get 1 more year at the very least (imo). If they fire him, they will (and can not afford) to pay him out.
I forget what show it was, maybe Beau Bishop, they said it will be a while before Rutgers fires Chris Ash. They can't afford it. They are still paying the last guy, somehow.
They're all chickens. The rooster has sex with all of them.
Not sure where this fire ash stuff comes from...he is good for a couple more years at least.
Justice delayed is justice denied....#FTP
I'd love to have Ash back. Doubt Grinch and T. Johnson go anywhere, as Meyer has always stood by the 2 year commitment. Schiano, Davis, and Studrawa need replaced.
I'm not sure what Larry's aspirations are, but I would love to give him a shot running the show.
I'd hate to Peter principle a great DL coach like L. Johnson and end up like we did with Warinner.
He's already stated he's only around another year or so... retirement
Yes 1,000,000%. Id even consider a trade bringing him back and sending Schiano back to Rutgers as the HC. Bring in Marcus Freeman in as LB coach and Co-Co DC
Go for two only because you can't go for three
Freeman would make a fine LB coach. Its effort or personnel at this point guys. The linebackers have been awful this year.
I know Ash had success here in the past, but hiring guys he already knows well is what got Urban in trouble this season.
Bring in some new blood.
Yes, because passing on a known (good) commodity for the unknown is always smart
Shandy is not beer
a column about it from a few weeks back
Let me just preface this with I’m very fond of my left nutt. But I would give my left nutt to have Ash back next year.
How about Houston Nutt?..
I think the scheme is the biggest issue with this defense. That falls on Schiano's shoulders. Linebacker play has been terrible for two years in a row as well. That falls on the shoulder of Davis. Replacing both seem s to be the most logical solution to our problems. If we bring in Ash, what do we do with Grinch? Ash was the safeties coach. Do we move Grinch to LB or have Ash coach them? These are all questions UM will have to answer if he decides to make staff changes. More than anything, Davis has to go!!!
Schiano may leave anyway. He seems like he would be a homerun hire for Maryland...
As for other coaches... only guy that needs to go imo is Davis... I just think it creates all kinds of problems when your best man is coaching a position that's been awful. I still think a big part of the problem is the talent but having that personal connection with a coach just seems like a conflict of interest... time to move on..
Never fire their boss though! That would be insane!
Lifetime vs. UM: L 9-1, C 8-0, T 5-0
Ohio State University President Jim Tressel
I would like to see Urban call it a career after this season and give way to Day. It seems unlikely, though.
He does need to go back to the drawing board in the offseason, though. Keep Day if you can, Hartline, and Larry Johnson, and everyone else is up for grabs.
No one has ever said we should fire LJ... lol
LJ might be the only couch who has ever coached at OSU where fans weren’t up with pitch forks for a firing. I remember when there were disgruntled fans calling for Herman and Coombs.
Not sure if you guys get to Vegas, but casinos must freakin love you. You want to boot the winningest coach in D1, because you don't like the way we're winning (or the terrible losses)...and roll the dice with a guy who has zero experience (okay 3 games with absolutely no pressure, a ready-made scapegoat and nothing on the line). Hell, Day doesn't even have much of a recruiting track record (he may be great, but he has a very small sample size of big-time school recruiting).
Let it ride...c'mon 7s!
Listen, Meyer is a great coach. One of the best of this generation. But if he CANNOT coach to the best of his abilities anymore, is it wrong to question his place as the coach of this team? I believe he has gas left in the tank, and that he is better than 95% of any other options, but clearly there are issues that he has done nothing to change.
Buckeye fan in Germany.
Personally, I only see two coaches that need to go if Urban wants to maintain the trust of the fanbase.
As frustrating as the DB's have been this year, Urban makes a two-year commitment to every coach he brings on staff, so Taver Johnson and Alex Grinch aren't going anywhere.
I understand the frustration with Schiano, but the guy coached two years of elite defense. And now, with a bunch of first year starters (who are not receiving the same level of positional coaching as before) , it's depressing how we're so quick to throw him under the bus.
Stud and Davis have to go, though. The O-Line has regressed every year since Warriner left, and Stud was supposed to make up for his less elite coaching skills with better recruiting than his predecessor. Needless to say, I'm not impressed enough with his recruiting hauls to make me happier than when Ed was turning 2-4* prospects into All-Americans. Davis should never have been hired in the first place, and Jerome Baker going from a first round talent that couldn't declare in 2016, to a "project player" in the eyes of NFL scouts in 2017 summarizes his level of ineptitude perfectly.
When did Schiano all of a sudden become a bad DC?? Give us Ward, Bosa, Hubbard , Hooker and Baker who ALL had eligibility for this year and our now all in the NFL or quit the team, and our defense is a top 3 defense!
Bucks fans in Mass
Stud definitely has not done a good enough job IMO. It seems like we have excellent recruiters on staff but not so great developers.
Just hoping to win every game remaining and enjoy the optimism of some new coaches on the staff.
Banks of olentangy
coaching is only half the problem. we have some bad players playing defense.
you're right our entire defense full of 4 and 5 star recruits isn't talented enough to hold maryland to less than 51
Grinch did a great job last year at Wash St.Hard to get talent out that way.We lost Tyquan Lewis( 2nd rd),Sam Hubbard(3rd rd),Jalyn Holmes(4th rd),Trace Sprinkle,Michael Hill(both free agents) off of the defensive line(not to mention Nick Bosa).Defensive backs Denzel Ward,Damon Webb,Erik Wright.Linebackers Jerome Baker,Chris Worley.Think of that depth lost - the program didn't recover specially the D-Line that was the deepest that I've ever seen coupled with this years starters.All those guys are on NFL rosters except Erik Smith - think about that.5 lineman,2 starting lbs & 2 starting db's - gone.That defense habitually gave the ball back to the offense with Billy Price and J.Jones still blocking.Haskins would look real good with all that help
Under Grinch's guidance, Washington State finished 74th or better nationally in scoring defense all three seasons. The Cougars were 56th this season. In the three seasons prior to his arrival, Washington State never finished better than 97th nationally and was 117th in scoring defense the year before he came.
The Cougars also ranked fourth nationally in third-down defense last season and had forced 75 turnovers during the past three seasons compared to 59 over the three seasons before Grinch joined Mike Leach in Pullman.
We are thin talent wise compared to previous seasons.I'd like to see Grinch have free reign like he did in Pullman.None of this Co-coordinator BS.People on this board were not crying rivers when Ash left.Nothing against Ash it's just people have feeble memories.If you have talent that will cover a lot of miscues
Agree about the talent leaving. But where is the growth? Its the last week of the regular season and we are still doing freshman mistakes at best and look clueless in the defense as a whole.
I agree BB,just think they need to go with fresh blood and Grinch showed marked improvement all 3 seasons in Pullman.I can't believe Booker has fallen off that bad from 2 seasons ago when he got injured.He has to be better than Borland/Warner.Browning and K.Jones have to see some snaps the LB play is what everything hinges on and they seem like revolving doors
Grinch will probably take over if Schiano leaves.
Fields of Dreams
Gregg Williams will be looking for a job in a few weeks, huh?
Tressel for prez, tOSU or USA, I'm good with either
How would he pay the bounties on opposing players to his defensive squad? Pizza bites?
You never lose to those pricks. Ever. Ever. Urban Frank Meyer
Gregggg Williams took over a team that was tied for first in penalties and then right away quit being a problem even though the players were the same.
Randy Shannon might be an interesting choice.
I don't care who we can I just want to change made... never seen an Ohio State Defense this bad but this much talent
this sounds a lot like when Fickell was here and a lot of posters wanted him fired and said just bring in someone else, well how did that work out for everyone?
I think we need to start thinking about who the head coach is going to be next year, then worry about coordinators. Urban is gone. He looked like someone who has lossed their mind and is off their meds today. He was all over the place emotionally, he had a tick where he kept rubbing his head, and he was wincing every time a camera was on him. He's not well, even when we win he looks and acts miserable. He gone.......
I can't ever recall a group of defensive backs as far as corners and safeties as bad as a group that Ohio State has this year... as far as knowledge of the game coverage and tackling.
Id give them Winovich if it meant us having Bosa. no excuses .
An easy way to improve the staff and please the fan base, as well as clean up our image would be to replace Shiano & Bill Davis. Image is an easy upgrade with whoever replaces Schiano and Davis is a huge liability so a guy like Marcus Freeman would even be worth a reach. Whatever the case next year I really hope Urban realizes that loyalty has a cost and in business sometimes it is just that, business. #FIREBILLDAVIS ASAP
So heres the thing if this is Godfather 2, Im all for it. Hell even Back to the Future 2 would work, but if this is Hangover 2, I'm out.
It doesn't matter whether you're the lion or a gazelle-when the sun comes up, you'd better be running.
One guy I'd consider is Mike Tressel from Sparty. Obviously has family ties with OSU and his defenses have been pretty solid with far less talent.
When Coach Combs left, I knew it was a very bad thing for Ohio State...