Another possibility is that he just wasn't a "track" speed kind of guy. All I know is that he looked pretty damn fast with the football pads on. I don't remember ever noticing him being "slow" on a play, so a lack of top end speed definitely wasn't obvious to me.
I was kind of looking forward to how Kevin Wilson would utilize Noah Brown. In my opinion, the best thing for Noah Brown would have been staying at least one more year and moving into a hybrid TE/FB type position. He may have put up some big time stats. I'm positive that Kevin Wilson would have known how to use him very effectively.
Before anyone counters with "Well, Jalin Marshall was only a 4.7 guy", because of a reported 4.7 40 he ran at a combine between his junior and senior years I just have this to say: "No... he... wasn't."
You can easily convince yourself that he was at least a 4.45 guy by re-watching Zeke's awesome 85 yard jaunt through Alabama's defense in the Sugar Bowl. Jalin followed him all the way to the endzone stride for stride, and may have actually been gaining a bit.
WOW. We can certainly use the scholarship, but I seriously can't see Noah Brown getting drafted at this point in time. IMHO, he's too slow to be an NFL wide receiver. He's probably about a 4.65 40 guy at best. He also dropped a fair number of well-thrown balls this year, a lot more than you'd expect for a guy that supposedly has suction cups for hands.
I do believe he can make it in the NFL, but at tight end, not wide receiver. He's going to need to be picked up by a team that sees his long range potential, and looks at aspects of a player's game that don't produce great stats but are essential for producing a winning team, like being a great blocker.
Best of luck to Noah Brown.
This is not an accurate take on "who" Urban Meyer was when we hired him. He did NOT over-sign players while at Florida.
Also, I have to believe that the coaches have had a pretty good idea overall about who would be staying and who would be leaving way before this season even began, and adjusted their recruiting strategy accordingly. So it's probably misguided to think that it's going to be a situation where at the end of the summer the coaches are going to say, "Oh shit. We're still over 85. Time to ruthlessly kick some kids to the curb!"
I don't have a problem with "over-signing", unless it means we kick a player off the team who genuinely wants to stay with his teammates and get his degree from Ohio State. Most kids, though, want to have a chance to play before their career is over, even if it means going to a notoriously bad FBS program or going down to an FCS school.
I don't know. I think Barrett can be great again, better even than he was in the middle of the 2014 season. I think it highly depends on an offensive coordinator who is able to streamline the game plan and distill it down into a form that Barrett has confidence in executing. I think that is what Herman was able to do for Barrett and later Cardale Jones. They didn't have to do a lot of thinking on the field. That is what really messes up offensive players, when they aren't certain of what they should do. And I believe that is exactly what we were seeing in 2015 and this year.
I'm assuming you meant "...anyone who DOESN'T see a star in Joe Burrow..."
I see the same thing in Joe Burrow. I think people have it backwards, expecting that Haskins is the favorite and Burrow will be awesome if he beats out Haskins. I think the true story is if Haskins beats out Burrow, he is one helluva MONSTER at QB.
Burrow has the accuracy and timing we haven't seen since Joe Germaine.
I get that everyone is upset about the offensive performance, but some of these "all-knowing" comments about which coaches should be fired are pretty hilarious.
Most of you are probably way overthinking what is "wrong". Here are some things to remember:
1) The OL is very young and pass-blocking takes the longest time to perfect. They were going up against a defensive line that may have up to 4 future NFL players. Let's see how Clemson holds up against a very strong Bama team. Personally, I think Clemson is going to take them down.
2) The WR group is still missing a lot of talent due to injuries and other issues. Johnny Dixon, Torrance Gibson and Corey Smith are the ones that come immediately to mind. Dontre Wilson and KJ Hill have also missed a lot of time from injuries. Parris Campbell, Terry McLaurin and James Clark are good program players that play and practice hard, but they simply aren't good wide receivers.
3) Curtis Samuel, our best player, has dropped a number of very easy passes the last few games, including at least 2 last night, 1 resulting in an interception ending a good offensive drive.
Now, I do agree that there are definite issues with the way this offense has been designed. Lack of identity sums it up pretty well. All the pieces simply do not fit together. And there are definite timing issues in execution, which seem like mostly JT Barrett's fault, but I would not presume to really understand who or what is really to blame. There's no doubt it is multi-factorial and not as simple as firing coach X.
"Seems pretty black & white to me."
What you unintentionally did there, I see it. :)
But seriously, UFM frequently says they recruit the whole family, so after getting that response from the dad there was little chance he would continue to pursue the son. I can even imagine UFM backing off even if the dad had a much more metered response and left the door open. The dad was obviously highly prejudiced against Ohio State, and given the number of prospects OSU can recruit there's not much sense in fighting that battle.
Agreed on Dobbins. When I heard our pursuit of Akers might cause him to look elsewhere, I was like F that shit, just keep Dobbins. He's a perfect feet for any spread offense as a tailback. Reminds you a lot of Thurman White and even Barry Sanders. Just go watch his tape. Dude has some unreal moves and quickness.
Yeah, it just seems like we don't have that "meta" thinker about the passing game, that can see things from a higher level and come up with a passing strategy based on a defense's weaknesses. I believe Herman was excellent at that. Beck and Warriner not so much. I think they are doing an "okay" job, but that really isn't good enough based on the quality of players we are recruiting. Maybe it's possible for Beck/Warriner to improve with intensive study of some other very successful passing offenses, but I have my doubts.
And the truth is, we don't really know where the main problem is. What Beck/Warriner are coming up with for a passing scheme may actually be pretty awesome, but Barrett, the offensive line and the wide receivers just aren't good enough yet to execute it. It could well be that Barrett simply isn't reading the defenses quick enough yet, combined with his accuracy issues, and that's what is keeping the passing game from humming.
I love JT Barrett, but I'd also like to see how Burrow would do in this offense. He seems to make very quick decisions, and has a quick release combined with the best accuracy I've seen in an OSU QB since Joe Germaine. Maybe even better than Germaine.