He also said on Twitter that "Buckeyes would get 7-8 starters of the 22 (QB, EE, Decker (maybe), Elflein, Bosa, Lee, Perry, Bell)" against an SEC All-Star roster. Not bad, having 1/3 of the squad come from one team.
I haven't seen it linked anywhere in the thread yet, but Stewart Mandel (then with SI) had a pretty good breakdown back in '07 and revisited his rankings in '12.
I agree that less is more, so I think he's a bit generous with his "Kings" rankings (particularly with the Florida schools). But for the most part I think he's pretty spot on.