Least favorite argument. You are comparing the young energetic Thad who could recruit to the current Thad who is no longer energetic and isn't bringing in the same type of talent. At OSU, Thad has never made it past the first weekend of the tournament without a 5* recruit on the roster. If Thad isn't getting his recruits that can carry the team then what use is he?
Are we going to bring someone who was better than Thad back in his prime? Idk, but just about anyone can get the results Thad has delivered the last few seasons. I would rather bring in a young coach who can infuse some sort of energy to the program. The results don't have to come immediately. Just make the games watchable and show us you care.