You can't use logic with the mentally challenged.
1) Forget that it is generally acknowledged that Oho State played the strongest schedule in the country.
2) Discount that the loss was to Penn St. due to a botched/blocked punt and a weird score on a botched/blocked field goal. and please ignore the stats of that game that show who clearly dominated it.
3) Avoid considering the fact that Ohio State had to play two night games back to back on the road with top 2 top 10 teams who both had 2 weeks to prepare for them due to byes (Penn St. being the second).