I understand your point of view. I also understand that the staff is working with more information than any of us and perhaps I misspoke when I mentioned stars and rankings. Therefore, I ultimately trust their decision.
The point of my post was just to convey my gut feeling, which is essentially worth nothing when all is said and done, that these two should have been kept in this class. Part of that feeling is based on my belief that you need a few tweeners in each class and that I feel like these two were the tweeners that could push the rest of the roster and perhaps become very good buckeyes.