Tough to tell all their strengths and weaknesses accurately given he scrimmage rules and limitations. FWIW-- I really only care about the 1st half. Second half was like garbage time, get people playing time, etc.
Telling: Jones completed 6 passes for 7 yards in the first half. Barrett had 14 completions for over 100 yards...
I came away thinking JT Barrett was better for these reasons:
1. Started slow/nervy but then settled down found poise
2. He moved the chains (even had long drives). This is key. This is what Kenny G. Did so well. Not flashy, but got yards.
3. He broke off some nice runs at the right time, showed quickness, kept eyes downfield.
4. Seemed better in the read/option decision making department
Happy to have both guys and while they're not Kenny G, I think they both have more physical upside than Smooth Jazz. Can't make a call until the hitting is real and they each have time to run the offense with a real line. I think they could keep the offense going if they needed to step in. I don't think either has the moxie/poise to go win us a game when the chips are down like Kenny G. (Yet).