With only one season to his name, it's hard to put him over anyone you listed.
However, it's pretty amazing that we are talking about him as a top 10 Buckeye RB (or higher) after just one season. He was that good.
I firmly believe if he stayed three years he'd have won at least one heisman trophy. Remember, he played before all of the SEC hype and bias. OSU gets the most attention from media coverage.
After his freshman season and that NC game, he was perfectly set up to be the front runner. Jason White won in 2003 and Matt Leinart won in 2004.... both mostly on team hype/talent surrounding them. MoC would have a leg up on both of those guys.