I watch it often too. Not quite once a week, but pretty often. Such an amazing, gutsy play.
I'd have to say Holy Buckeye is probably the most important come from behind win. It probably didn't make the cut because it wasn't really a "comeback rally." We were only down by 3. So there are obviously "bigger" comebacks in terms of points. But Holy Buckeye was the most important...at least in my lifetime.
2011 Football Season: Brady Hoke starts calling OSU "Ohio."
2011-2012 College Basketball season: As a 4 seed, tsun basketball team loses in the first round of the tournament to...Ohio.
I'm pretty sure that Kelly left Cincinnati before this game, so he did not coach. Maybe he should have waited to leave so that he could get some more experience coaching in big games.