Other than being a rabid Buckeye fan, I don't have standing to evaluate whether Grant or anyone else who dons the Scarlet and Grey has been a bust or a success. I want a dominant defense, but isn't it coaches who select who to offer scholarships, who to play, how to deploy players, and how to develop kids into men? I try to separate "he is a great football player" from "he is a great person I would want my daughter to date." The latter is the more important, but I certainly don't know enough to have the answer to either question. All I know right now is:
Go Buckeyes. Beat Navy!