I agree with all the points you made Cosmo, and for the longest time I thought JT should be starter. Lately I've been 2nd guessing myself. As good as JT is, this isn't about stats, reading defenses, presence.... It's really about who makes OSU the best team they can be. This is where Cardale has an argument. There is 1 major thing Cardale does that IMO affects the games more than anything: the deep ball. At any given moment, Cardale can sling it 60+ yards downfield and defenses were forced to defend it. That REALLY opened up the offense because the defenses were so stressed in the secondary.