I tend to disagree - great recruiter. Well above average coach, thinking about the various tourney runs. His teams (in my mind) have always taken time to get the defense in place, and some years the system (zone) doesn't work out.
Isn't the team without this year's top recruit (Mitchell)? They lost a ton last year, from a team that wasn't great. They're going to be bad. But personally I won't throw Matta under the bus. There is no one out there available who will be better at both aspects (recruiting and coaching), and destabilizing only makes things worse.