The 2012 Buckeyes going undefeated in Urban's first year. And the seniors who stayed to finish their careers at the OSU. The COTY goes to Urb... what the hell did you say?
- College Football Player: Archie
- College Basketball Player: Hopson, Jackson, and Craft
- NFL Team: None
- NHL Team: None
- NBA Team: None
- MLB Team: None
- Soccer Team: None