Both Eddie and Zeke are great but don't sleep on Byars in 1984.Besides his rushing stats he also led the team in receptions with 42!!!
He had an amazing 2441 all purpose yards that year (he had some as a KO Ret and threw a 35 yard TD pass as well)
He averaged over 200 yards all purpose for the season, had he played 12 games like Zeke he would have had closer to 3000 yards all purpose vs Elliot's 2114
He led the team in rushing and receptions which means he had more catches than Chris Carter that year and Mike Lanese, 2 guys who rank in the tops all time at OSU,,,and he got the ball more than them on receptions
Between rushes and receptions he was responsible for nearly 50% of all touches which means literally every other play the ball was in his hands and he was unstoppable
he averaged over 24 yards per KO return including a 63 yarder
in terms of all purpose yards per game, no one comes close to Byars in 1984 (203.8), Elliott's season last year (140.9) ranks 12th best ever, behind even Hyde's 2013 season
don't discount Archie either, from 1973-1975 he had 3 seasons of more all purpose yards per game than what Elliott put up last year.
Tim Spencer had 2 seasons (81 and 82) with more all purpose production per game
Elliot's great but maybe not to be anointed yet