After watching a few other teams play this weekend I think I have more agreement with your grades. Seeing how other guys play gives you perspective on our guys I think.
Yes this was frustrating team to watch and we all hoped for more but we got great effort form most (ahem Amir) and the Bucks aren't alone as elite teams with huge holes in their game. Did anyone watch Kansas and Syracuse play? They were very Buckeye like. Long periods of no offensive output but a sound defense that kept them in the game. Giving themselves a chance but no one being able to hit the big shot. Kansas is OSU with a couple better athletes at a couple positions. They were so bad down the stretch offensively, KU fans must be pulling their hair out and Syracuse too! Both those teams spent time at #1 this year and were seeded much higher than Bucks. We are a hairs breadth from being an Elite 8 team with all our flaws.
We are a defensive minded team at our heart. If you won't play D, Matta doesn't really want you. That means some guys won't even be looked at. Im okay with that. Mattas calling card has put the Bucks in position to be one or two 3 pointers of a final four every damn year!!
If Zell and Q makes 3 or 4 more 3 pointers at the right times or if Craft had 5 more made three throws and 3 less TOs we wouldn't be having this discussion right now and neither guys numbers would be significantly different. We'd be prepping for a Sweet Sixteen matchup with someone and knowing that if we hit a couple big shots, we are an Elite eight team...............again!