1. Eddie (G.O.A.T. that I have watched in college football. Perfect mix of size, speed, agility.)
2. Reggie Bush (by far one of the most electric players to play in the NCAA)
3. Troy Smith (maybe not the best stats wise but as far as leader on the field he was one of the best)
Honorable mention: Barry Sanders. Didn't get to watch him in college much but I could only imagine how good he was.
Worst is probably Jason White. Both undeserving and really not good.