That's a whole different scenario Brutus. If you weren't born in Cleveland, or never lived in Cleveland, how can you call yourself a 'Clevelander'? You CAN say you are a fan of Cleveland sports, but you can't actually say your from Cleveland.
I'm not from Columbus (although I have lived here since '98) and I am a Buckeye fan. I don't say "I'm from Buckeye". However, having lived in Columbus for nearly half my life, I could possibly say I'm from Columbus and that would be entirely true.
Truth is, here in C-Bus (or anywhere in Ohio) if asked where I'm from, I would respond with 'Cincinnati'. But when abroad elsewhere in the U.S. I would respond with 'OHIO'. Hope that doesn't offend you too much Brutus.