In addition to Ginn, 2005 also had Holmes and Gonzalez at WR, so plenty of speed there. On the flip side, Antonio Pittman was a good back, but Zeke outclassed him in about every way imaginable. All in all I think 2014 takes a close one. That team was so locked in down the stretch.
The closest we see to Meyer's Buckeye's vs Tressel's is watching the first four Michigan State - Ohio State games under Urban Meyer. 2-2 so far with both sides delivering haymakers.