I'm assuming that this would be a hypothetical "if all things were equal" question. Obviously if JT had played 10 games straight, you wouldn't bench him for no reason.
Otherwise, I'm still shocked that anybody would pick somebody other than Braxton Miller. One of the best QB's in the country coming in to this season. A Heisman favorite. The past few years, he was the best athlete on the field hands down. I know everybody is going to say: "Barrett is a better passer". Look at the dropped passes Braxton has thrown! *Looks at Corey Smith in the Clemson game* Can anybody say that Braxton has ever had more weapons than Barrett had this year? Receivers couldn't get open! Urban called them a clown show! Now, we have playmakers everywhere! Even Devin Smith, who everybody has said was just a deep threat, is getting open underneath. The WR are making plays! Just like Cardale's first TD against Wisconsin, was that really a great pass? It was a good pass, but it was one hell of a play by Devin Smith to go over the defender and catch the ball.
I love all 3 QB's. We are truly blessed at that position. At the end of each of their careers, we can have a fairer comparison,but right now for me, give me #5 all day.