Primary tabs

Should Urban Meyer allow Storm Klein to return to the team?

Comments

johnblairgobucks's picture

I voted no on the return, this late into the process, only what 14 weeks left in the season, Klein has a lot to learn, taking away from coaches game-plan implimentation and turning it into teaching time , unless he was limited to kick coverage kamikazee.
I think in fairness Klein should keep his scholarship. 
I don't know.  tough spot- it's why people despise jury duty. Go Bucks!

AJBor41's picture

I'm with you on this one.  If the lesser charge had been a done deal in June, then maybe he'd have a tougher decision, but I think the "9 days until kickoff" reason should suffice in keeping him dismissed from the team.

yrro's picture

I think he should go back on the team, but with a suspension. Gives him time to catch back up, still shows a penalty for what he did.

Phoenix824's picture

Agree,   6 games is my vote.    Kill half his season but helps him out with the education.

Northbrook's picture

That sounds like the best option to me.

Steve Earle Bruce Springsteen's picture

Don't need him, don't want him. An unnecessary risk. Look at it this way: he gets back on the team and he contributes as a back-up. That's the maximum positive outcome. He isn't going to start unless there's an injury. On the other hand, if he gets in trouble again (likely), it's another black eye for the program nationally. 

The North remembers.

andyb's picture

I'm good with him coming back with conditions...LET EM LIVE!

billy04's picture

This isn't his first foray into unnecessary off-field violence.  He's a punk, and he doesn't deserve the opportunity to play for this team. 

macbraddy's picture

Funny how everyone seems to only care how much he will contribute as being the only reason why he should or should not be let back on the team, I'm not sure why that matters. If you don't want him back on the team because of what went down that's one thing but just saying that Urban should toss him aside because he's not that good isn't right. He has given 4 years of his life to Ohio State and he has started and played a lot. That's more than many highly rated recruits ever accomplish . The kids a senior I say let him back with Urban's conditions and I don't care if he plays or not he can finish his career with his football brothers.
 
 

Go Bucks!!!

Chise47's picture

"Common sense, is not common."-Chinese Proverb
Glad to see someone w/common sense. I should get Biblical & start quoting some redemptive/forgiveness lessons for some of these folk that are our Buckeye "Brethren".
3 games, 120 charity/community service hrs.,(for domestic violence victims), joint counseling for he & his girlfrind/childs' mother; then see how it all plays out on the field.
He is MUCH too young a guy to be just thrown away as if he doesn't have a chance to really make a change in his life, or really become something much stronger from this tuff lesson he has had to endure.

buckeye76BHop's picture

It all depends on what direction the staff is going with those freshman LBs.  If they're playing no matter what, then say sorry but no thanks Storm.  If some of those LBs are going to redshirt...then OSU needs Storm for a #s stand point.  I do believe the charges were changed correct...so reevaluation of his status will be happening I'm sure considering he's a senior.  We'll see I suppose...

"There's nothing that cleanses your soul like getting the hell kicked out of you."

"I love football. I think it is most wonderful game in world and I despise to lose."

Woody Hayes 1913 - 1987 

4dorr's picture

He would be great for the practice squad.

Tomorrow

LadyBuck's picture

I voted no. Right now is a time for Urbz to stick to his guns, and he dismissed Storm.

ohst8buxCP's picture

I say no on his return to the team. He's had more than one chance and continues to have an inclination towards hitting women. That being said let him keep his scholarship, the details of this incident are sketchy at best and something like that shouldn't be allowed to completely derail a kids life.

M Man's picture

FWIW, I voted "Yes."
I have serious doubts that Urban Meyer or 11W will be much concerned with my vote.  But since when does "Charges dropped" get you suspended? 
Now, I have to say that I appreciate the uniformly-classy comments on this thread.  OSU fans sticking up for the credibility of the program.  I have to tip my M cap to all of you.  And we should be clear; a not guilty verdict does not necessarily win you the privilege -- and it has to be regarded as a privilege -- of wearing the scarlet and gray on the field in Ohio Stadium.  If Storm Klein privately confessed something to his coaches that was legally irrelevant to any prosecution, I can understand how that could earn him a dismissal.  But we don't know that.  And if Storm Klein really does have a pattern of behavior that could damage the program, that too could be grounds for voiding his privilege -- again that word -- of putting on a silver helmet.
But (here is where I blow all of my cred with my friends at 11W) I think back to another OSU linebacker, Robert Reynolds, for whom I had some real bad feelings at the time, and how he has found redemption:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reynolds%E2%80%93Sorgi_incident
I open this up to my good friends in Columbus.  Robert Reynolds?  Storm Klein?  Discuss.

Run_Fido_Run's picture

M Man, thanks for the kind words about the classiness of comments on this thread, but the reason not to bite on your invitation to discuss Reynolds v. Klein is right there in your comment. We do not know about all the background details - what the coaches might know, beyond what's been made public, concerning Klein's past or recent actions.
I can say that, if it had been up to me, I'd probably have given Reynolds a 2 or 3 game suspension.

M Man's picture

Remind me what Reynolds did get; it was 1 game, right?  And thereafter, he didn't start for a game or two, right?  I defer to you guys on that...

Run_Fido_Run's picture

It was officially a 1-game suspension. Cannot recall if he was further penalized by not being allowed to start and/or given other restrictions on playing status or team privileges, etc.
1-game was too light. 3-games was probably about right, IMO.  

JJB's picture

What exactly are we supposed to be discussing?

M Man's picture

Well Reynolds committed what was arguably/nearly a felonious battery.*  Which resulted in an injured Jim Sorgi.  A lot worse harm to the victim than Storm Klein's baby mama.
I dunno.  I'm the first guy to confess what I don't know about all of this.  That's why I suggested, "Discuss."
*Never charged; no criminal allegations, no arrest.  No nuthin'.  That much would have been obvious to most of you as long-time and wellinformed observers of Buckeye football; I just wanted to make it clear in fairness to Reynolds.

OSUBias's picture

The charges were dropped because he plea bargained a lesser charge. Something happened or he wouldn't have pled guilty. Something involving him handling a woman physically in a way that was harmful/frightening to her (not that there's an ok way to physically handle a woman, ever).
Based on the original charges and story, and then him plea bargaining something smaller, it sure seems like it was a case of the girlfriend backing down because she didn't want him to get into too much trouble.

Shitter's full

M Man's picture

I respect, and accept, your point.  Well said.
Here's one thing I'd offer in response.  Prosecutorial charges can be like offers or demands in civil litigation.  Bargaining.  Speaking lawyerly, I'd strongly resist the temptation to say that Klein was guilty of anything more than what he pled to.

JJB's picture

Its also possible he just didn't want to go to trial. These things are far from black and white. I'm not trying to back him, just saying we still have to wait and see.

Run_Fido_Run's picture

Seems like a reasonable guess, but we don't know.
The coaches probably know a lot more about the pertinent issues than we do - if not all/some of the key facts specifically pertaining to this case, at least they are the most knowledgeable concerning Klein's track record with the team.
Therefore, I'm inclined not to prejduge things and wait to see how the coaches handle Klein's request to be reinstated. Barring some sort of public disclosure of key facts (which would be illegal), the coaches will always know more about the relevant facts they we do.

OSUBias's picture

Agree with all points in response to my first post. We really don't know. In reality, only the two of them know. The police and the prosecutor only know what they were told, which may or may not be the truth.
It's too soon to form a valid and comprehensive opinion because we don't know the facts. But that is what we do in this day and age; make an opinion by sifting through the available information and taking a guess at what we really think happened. So I figured I'd throw my viewpoint in there with all of the other "too soon" discussion points.

Shitter's full

dubjayfootball90's picture

i just think the privilege to play for Ohio State and a free eductaion has been abused both in the present and in the past..... Yank 'em.

You can feed a bobcat all the chili it wants. That don't mean it's going to crap out diamonds.

Baroclinicity's picture

I posted this in the skully and was wondering... would our thoughts be different about Klein returning if he had the talents of Shazier?

When you're holding a hammer, everything looks like a nail.

OSUBias's picture

I'd like to say no, but the reality is probably yes. I have no evidence to back that up, just my gut feeling. I'd like to think that something like manhandling a woman is bad enough to rise above our fandom and make us see it for what it truly is (without our scarlet colored glasses on). But I'm not entirely sure that it would. At least not across the board.

Shitter's full

johnblairgobucks's picture

You bet reactions would be different.  I'd bet 3-1 people would say "bring em back today!".  Though we are just giving opinions, and this would be an opinion on a hypothetical event..... the original event was not witnessed by any of the commenting people, so this whole thing is silly.
I was against Robert Smith coming back to OSU in the early 90's, after he quit the team and then came back, I thought Robert Reynolds should have been booted off the team for choking another man.  I thought Troy Smith should have had a longer suspension for taking $$$ in 2004. 
It is a team game and the team comes first.  Dealing with other's knuckle-headed actions take away from the team, and need to be dealt with aggressively, IMO. 
The whole problem with Klein's situation is we are all commenting but none of us KNOW what really happened.

Pam's picture

I believe that Troy's punishment was fair. Two games, one a bowl, pay the money back and apologize publicly. The NCAA agreed with it too. He was pretty much a choir boy after that. From what I understand JT and Geiger were ready to boot him, this coming on the heels of the Mo C. situation.

rkylet83's picture

I voted no mainly on my gut feeling that it could turn into a distraction.  Like many have said where there is smoke theres fire and there's potential that something else could happen.  
If he was to come back I think it would only be reasonable to come back on as a practice squad player and help the team that way.  He'd still get to be with his teammates and hopefully graduate.  He's missed a lot of time with the team as far as building chemistry compounded with the training time he's lost as others have mentioned; so playing time in my opinion is out the window. 

Boom777's picture

I say yes(meaning he should be able to if allowed). This is why we have a legal system so opinions should not matter, rule of law should. He went through his legal process now its up to the coach. Call him what you want we should put aside his legal trouble because it has been" taken care of". Whether or not he can contribute is another topic.

Wherever you are, there you be!

SPreston2001's picture

I have no feelings about this either way. If he lets him back on fine, if he doesnt oh well...

hodge's picture

Judging that Urban's as in-the-dark as us, I'd talk to Klein's child's mother and get her feel for the kind of man he is.  If it can be determined that he physically abused her and got off with a plea bargain, boot him.  He still violated a core rule, and it's not his first offense (or even his first case of domestic abuse).  Good riddance.
If nothing can be definitively determined, the young man should be allowed back on the team--albeit with the provision that if anything like this so much as surfaces again, he's out without question.  

Buckeye06's picture

Here's my only question...if this is Braxton Miller, do you guys kick him off the team?  Simon?

schooey's picture

Keep him as a back-up and to make the Freshmen better at pratice. 

Hoody Wayes's picture

I voted to reinstate. Redemption. Maybe, he has a few good plays to make?