Loaded question! Depends on the offense we're running. I might select Newton or Griffin if we did what their offense does, but for Jim Tressel's offense, the choice is obvious: Pryor. Newton or Griffin would have their head explode.
And we all know Barkley would put up Jacory Harris-ish sack numbers.
It's a tossup: Terrelle Pryor or Hurricane Ditka.
Taylor Martinez is pretty nasty for being a Freshman.