Primary tabs

Who is Ohio State's best offensive lineman over the last 10 seasons?

Mike Adams
2% (73 votes)
Kirk Barton
1% (25 votes)
Alex Boone
3% (95 votes)
Justin Boren
2% (57 votes)
Nick Mangold
80% (2674 votes)
Jack Mewhort
12% (384 votes)
Other
1% (27 votes)
Total Votes: 3335

Comments

Oyster's picture

He is also the best Photo Bomber of late too.

May you R.I.P. Otsego, but know this. Gaylord Rocks!

TMac's picture

Consensus (n) general agreement

Seth4Bucks's picture

Brewster's not even worthy of being on the list?                                  

Chris Lauderback's picture

Not to me he wasn't. Just being honest. I definitely don't think his career outshines any others on that list and I had to cap it somewhere. More hype than substance and I personally believe he regressed over his time here.

rkylet83's picture

He really did regress.  He was good enough to start when he came in and honestly I didn't see a difference between his performance between senior and freshman seasons.  

ScarletGray43157's picture

Agreed.  Who was his O-Line coach again?

In old Ohio there's a team that's known throughout the land...

joel121270's picture

Can't argue with that assessment.

Hovenaut's picture

Hard to go against Mangold here, he's been solid for so long now.

IH8UOFM's picture

Mangold was an animal. Got my vote.

rkylet83's picture

Mangold was an all-time great.  
I think Mewhort is a close second based on college production.  

Kindell's picture

I had to go Mangold here.  I really like Jack Mewhort a lot though.  I think if this question asked who is the best O-line as a  unit, it would have to be this years for me.

luckynutz's picture

Seeing mike adams on this list makes me cringe a little. Kid had soooooo much potential, but never really seemed to be able to put it together on the field. Same with boone. Although he has made a hell of a turnaround in the NFL. Imagine what they could have been with a coach like warriner to tap into that vast well of potential they were sitting on.

Mangold is the clear cut winner here, even if based solely off of his time at OSU. Took over starting job as a freshman, and never let loose of it. Consistent, nasty and the heart of some pretty solid buckeye lines in his career. And even though the Jets have become a dumpster fire, mangold is still one of the best centers in football.

dan_isaacs's picture

To be fair to Mike, we expected Orlando Pace 2.0.

Dan Isaacs

Knarcisi's picture

We did, but the disappointment was that he was 0.2

droessl's picture

Why isn't JB "move back 5 yards" Shugarts on the list? 

3cent's picture

I know, that is why I voted other for him.

Ahh Saturday's picture

Alex Boone was a tremendous talent as was Mike Adams.  Different issues of alcohol and pinnipeds kept each from realizing his full potential in S&G.

OurHonorDefend09's picture

Mike Adams and Alex Boone... Good one.
 

 
 

Don't give up... Don't ever give up.

gobucks96's picture

Mangold, and I would think Brewster should be included as well.

hspbuy1's picture

Wow! Manglod - Mewhort, A couple of great linemen, tough to go against Mangold, but Mewhort is a beast also.  eeny meeny miney moe!

hspbuy1

Ethos's picture

I voted Brewster

"What do you need water for, Sunshine?!" - Coach Coombs, if you don't love this man, you have no soul.

Buckeyetml's picture

Would have like to see how different the careers of  Brewster/adams/shugart would have been if they had Warriner as their coach.)

Phoenix824's picture

I can't even believe Adams, Barton, Boone, and Boren are on this list.    Its a two man race Mangold and Mewhort.    Those two lived up to their potential.     The others either did not develop or only developed when they got good coaching. 

scarpenter614's picture

Alex Boone is one of my least favorite Buckeyes of all time.  I want to see a ranking of tOSU starting linemen based on the number of holding and false start penalties.  He has to be up there with JB "False Start" Shugarts.  I almost went up to Boone at Little Bar and told him what I thought but he is literally twice the man I am.  

BKLYN_Buckeye's picture

Mangold. A lot of people forget but he got MAJOR PT during the NC game against Miami.

OSU_ALUM_05's picture

Odds that O Pace would get 100% of the vote if we opened up the poll to last 20 years?

otrain2416's picture

Best Drinker of all those names: Alex Boone by a land slide

walshy's picture

This list should also include Corey Linsley.

"Without winners, there wouldn't even be civilization."

southbymidwest's picture

I would vote for Kirk Barton as most enthusiastic former OSU OLine GA- he always seemed totally into it and pumping up his boys last year-he and Warriner must have been some combination. He has received quite a bit of love from the seniors and Reid Fragel.

Buckeye in Illini country's picture

And the sexiest linemen?

Columbus to Pasadena: 35 hours.  We're on a road trip through the desert looking for strippers and cocaine... and Rose Bowl wins!

Squirrel Master's picture

I said other because I believe if he was playing at RT his whole time there, he would have been by far the best. I'm talking about Reid Fragel.
throw in the fact that if he did play RT his whole time on the team, it would have put Shugarts on the bench. I think that would have been a double whammy on how great he would have been!
but true, Mangold and Mewhort have had the best careers!

I saw a UFO once.......it told me to have a goodyear!

joel121270's picture

No false start shugarts? Lol

ArizonaBuckeye's picture

No offense to the other fellas but as soon as I saw Mangolds name it wasn't even close. He's by far our most efficient linemen this past decade. And all he manages to do in the NFL is make the Pro Bowl year in and out.

"There's nothing that cleanses your soul like getting the hell kicked out of you." -Woody Hayes-

gravey's picture

Mangold was a beast, and exceptionally consistent.  I guess LeCharles is beyond the 10 year mark.
I think this has turned into a "which lineman have you disliked most" thread....which really isn't a Buckeye thing to do.   Leave the fratricide to Michigan blogs.
GO BUCKS!

Knarcisi's picture

I voted for Mewhort with OT being a much more demanding position. 
Barton and Boone:  I'm still having a hard time getting over the beating they took from UF in the 2006 championship game.  
Adams:  to me, never reached his billing. 

Calgarybuck's picture

I believe Center is because he's the quarterback of the O-line and he was just a beauty to watch! 
Agree with Barton and Boone however we could've schemed better for that game and I'll always blame Tressel for that..
Adams on the list just magnifies how dire our O-line was over the last 10 years under the Walrus.