What if this was the last year of the BCS era, not last year. 

Which 2 teams should get in? 

It would be easy for me,  Alabama and Oregon. There is no way Florida State should be selected over those 2 teams.

If an undefeated team isn't worthy of making a 2 team playoff, why MUST an undefeated make a 4 team playoff? Only one thing is required. Use the eye test. Florida State IS NOT one of the 4 best teams in the country TODAY.