Ohio State Football Forum

Ohio State Football Forum

Ohio State football fan talk.

Why I hate the current poll format

0 HS
Haubtimus Prime's picture
October 7, 2014 at 10:59am
25 Comments

So, how do you climb from the depths of being an unranked team in the preseason all the way to #3 after only five games.  Well, let's ask Mississippi State how this amazing feat was accomplished.

Step 1 - Defeat a Top 10 team.  This was accomplished in Week 4, when Mississippi State defeated "#8" LSU.  LSU is currently unranked, with a signature win over a Wisconsin team who just lost to Northwestern. 

Step 2 - Shoot up the polls.  Mississippi State went from unranked to #14 after their win over LSU. 

Step 3 - Beat another Top 10 team.  Enter Texas A&M, who saw a huge climb in the polls, from #21 to #9 after their win over "#9" South Carolina, to be sitting at #8 going into last week's game.  Mississippi State pulls off the win, and BOOM! #3 in the country.

So, to recap, from Week 4 to Week 7, Mississippi State has gone from unranked to #3 in the country with a single win over a team currently ranked in the Top 15.

How does Baylor sit at #5 in the country having not played a single opponent with a winning record, and with five wins over opponents whose record is a combined 8 - 18, while Georgia Tech sits at 5-0 and at least has a win over a Power 5 school with a winning record (Virginia Tech), and is ranked #22????

Michigan State also sits at #8 with a record of 4-1, with a loss to 4-1 Oregon, who checks in at #12.

I take great pleasure in knowing that these polls have ZERO influence on the selection committee. 

This is a forum post from a site member. It does not represent the views of Eleven Warriors unless otherwise noted.

View 25 Comments