pro's- He was a Buckeye. He led a last minute drive to win a Rose Bowl.
Cons- wasn't the best OSU QB of the decade (Bob Hoying). His constant audibling vs Michigan State in '98, were audibles out of run plays into pass plays, Germain had a bad game that day, OSU never imposed their will (run game) on MSU. Sure Joe wasn't covering Plaxico all game, but I do give him the majority of blame for OSU's loss in that game.
just my thoughts, due to the comments I've read on the 70's and 80's Mt Buckmore announcements, about who we should see on the highly competetive 90's 4some.