I just had this thought: What college teams besides Ohio State do you find yourself rooting for?
For me, the list includes Bowling Green, Miami (The U), USC, Xavier, North Carolina, Florida, Kansas, Houston, Dayton, Wichita State, Butler, and (gulp) Sparty. And of course, anyone who is playing against Bama or TTUN.
You don't have to like them in all sports, but at least one.